Search results
Search this site
36 results found with an empty search
- Ivory-eyed drones: what a mutation teaches us about honey bee genetics
Why a small mutation can teach us so much Drones have no second copy of the same gene capable of masking its effect · Photo by USGS Bee Inventory and Monitoring Lab · Wikimedia Commons · CC BY 2.0 Honey bee breeding considers complex traits such as gentleness, hygienic behaviour, colony development and productivity. Occasionally, however, a very rare genetic variant makes it possible to see an evolutionary process that is normally difficult to document with exceptional clarity. This is the case of ivory-eyed drones studied by a group of researchers and beekeepers in the United States. The study, published in July 2026 in Molecular Biology and Evolution, followed a recessive mutation from its identification in a queen through to its disappearance, reconstructing its genetic, physiological and behavioural consequences. It does not describe a useful production trait to select for: it provides a concrete example of how natural selection works in honey bees. Haplodiploidy: why drones are a special case In honey bees, workers and queens are generally diploid, whereas drones normally develop from unfertilised eggs and possess a single set of chromosomes. This system, known as haplodiploidy, allows recessive genetic variants to be expressed directly in males: there is no second copy of the same gene capable of masking their effect. In females, by contrast, a recessive mutation can remain hidden in the heterozygous state. This difference has important implications when considering maternal lines and the origin of drones. It does not, however, mean that every recessive trait is harmful or that haplodiploidy prevents every unfavourable mutation from persisting. The initial observation: ivory-eyed drones Drone reproductive tissues Working with beekeepers, the researchers identified a normal-looking queen that produced both ordinary-eyed drones and others with abnormal ivory pigmentation. Her diploid daughters did not express the phenotype. The colony was monitored, and drone production observed over several seasons. Ivory-eyed drones were less common than expected from simple one-to-one segregation of a recessive allele. Approximately one in four emerged drones had ivory eyes, consistent with possible adverse effects on early survival, but this alone does not establish exactly when the losses occurred. A mutation associated with the cinnabar gene Genomic analysis and other molecular methods identified a small sequence change in cinnabar, a gene involved in metabolic pathways essential to eye pigmentation. The researchers examined gene expression, proteins and metabolites to link the molecular alteration to the appearance of the eyes. This multiomics approach goes beyond a simple visual correlation. The observed variant disrupted production of the substances responsible for pigmentation. Yet an obvious phenotype such as eye colour does not encompass all the mutation's effects: the most consequential effects emerged from behavioural studies. Drone size was not the problem Macro photograph of a honey bee drone with white eyes, illustrating altered eye pigmentation Ivory-eyed drones showed no significant differences from their normal-eyed brothers in the main morphological and reproductive measurements analysed. Simply examining the body or certain sperm parameters would therefore not have fully identified the problem. In orientation tests, however, ivory-eyed drones had considerable difficulty finding their colony. In one trial, ten days after transfer to an isolated hive, only one of the 51 introduced ivory-eyed drones remained, compared with 83 of 192 normal drones. In another trial involving release at a distance, no ivory-eyed drones returned, whereas some controls did. The authors interpret these results as a severe orientation deficit. Why the mutation disappeared A drone that cannot orient itself and complete its flights properly has fewer reproductive opportunities. In the reported observations, the mutation did not persist in the study population and disappeared with the death of the carrier queen and her sons. This is an example of purifying selection, which reduces transmission of unfavourable variants. The authors also discuss possible mortality during early development. This hypothesis should not be treated as an established fact: the behavioural evidence is more direct, whereas the precise dynamics of embryonic losses require further investigation. What is the relationship with the csd gene? The cinnabar mutation studied in these drones is distinct from csd, a gene involved in sex determination. These are two different genetic issues. Although both involve haploids, diploids and allelic variants, this does not justify diagnosing brood defects on the basis of a vague notion of “inbreeding”. In genetic improvement, complex traits, risks associated with genetic variability and individual Mendelian defects should be considered separately. Pedigrees help formulate hypotheses and plan crosses, but verifiable observations are needed to establish which process is actually occurring. A case study is not a trial across many colonies To assess this work properly, its central biological unit must be identified: the mutation was found in the offspring of a single carrier queen. Numerous drones subsequently provided genetic, anatomical and behavioural measurements; nevertheless, this was neither a comparison of dozens of independent families nor a breeding trial involving Ligustica lines. The defensible conclusion concerns the mechanism observed for this particular variant. It cannot establish the frequency of other harmful mutations in Italian breeding operations, the quality of a strain or the breeding value of every family displaying abnormalities. The difference from exploratory studies with three or five colonies per treatment lies in the scientific question. This study does not claim to compare two management practices: as a genetic case study, it reconstructs the connection between an identifiable mutation and a rare phenotype using converging molecular techniques. Replication at the individual level helps compare the two phenotypes within the offspring studied; generalising to populations and lines would require additional independent cases. How the genetic association was verified The researchers followed the appearance of ivory-eyed drones during the 2022 and 2023 seasons, documenting an imbalance between phenotypes relative to the expected one-to-one Mendelian proportion in three trials: Fisher's exact test gave p = 0.03. This result supports the loss or non-expression of part of the phenotype, but does not by itself identify the biological stage of any mortality. The authors considered alternatives, including worker egg laying, and the relatedness data did not support that explanation. To map the variant, a genome-wide association study was performed on 50 ivory-eyed drones and 50 normal-eyed brothers, alongside other mapping strategies. The strongest association involved a change in the coding sequence of cinnabar on chromosome 4: a small insertion/deletion that interferes with correct RNA processing and protein synthesis. Gene expression, proteome and ommochrome-pathway metabolite analyses provided convergent evidence. The interpretation is supported by agreement between genetic and biochemical data rather than a single statistical value. What evidence supports the orientation deficit? Ten reproductive and morphological parameters, including body measurements and sperm characteristics, showed no statistically significant differences between ivory-eyed drones and their normal brothers in the reported trials. A negative result does not prove perfect biological equivalence: it means that no difference was detected with the samples and methods used. Observations of orientation flights, however, revealed a substantial discrepancy in return to the colony. Ten days after the experimental transfer, 1 of 51 ivory-eyed drones and 83 of 192 normal drones remained: these are observed fractions under that protocol, not universal probabilities of drone survival. A second line of evidence concerning light responses and phototaxis is consistent with a visual deficit. It remains appropriate to distinguish directly recorded homing behaviour from natural mating success, which was not measured for every individual. For queen breeders, the methodological lesson is this: an easily visible trait can indicate broader functional effects, while a favourable morphological examination or sperm assessment does not automatically guarantee orientation ability and reproductive success. Mendelian genetics, quantitative selection and the csd gene The cinnabar gene is involved in a highly specific single-gene phenotype. Traits such as production, hygienic behaviour, gentleness and colony development instead depend on polygenic networks and interactions with the environment. The percentages observed in ivory-eyed drones cannot be used to estimate the heritability of production traits or to attribute diagnostic powers to a pedigree that it does not possess. Selection against unfavourable variants is also distinct from positive selection for complex breeding performance: it requires different indicators, experimental units and statistical methods. It is also essential to distinguish cinnabar from the csd locus, which is involved in sex determination and the possible production of diploid males under particular allelic combinations. Irregular brood is not evidence of an eye mutation or a csd problem without further investigation. In organising a breeding programme, this research supports caution when interpreting exceptional phenotypes, the importance of traceability and genetic variability, and cooperation with qualified laboratories; it does not justify new procedures for indiscriminately eliminating lines. Implications for ESA Regine and queen breeders In work with Apis mellifera ligustica, monitoring paternal and maternal lines is important precisely because it allows matings to be studied and offspring followed. The ivory-eyed drone case nevertheless reminds us that a good programme cannot rely on a few laboratory indicators or a pedigree alone. Behaviour, function and colony performance also matter. ESA Regine did not conduct this research and does not claim to be able to identify or eliminate every unfavourable genetic variant. The practical message is simpler: use genetics to make better decisions, preserve diversity and continue to assess what the animals actually express. Frequently asked questions Is a normal-looking drone necessarily a good breeder? No. Some problems emerge only through behavioural, physiological or genetic measurements. Does haplodiploidy automatically eliminate harmful mutations? No. It can expose recessive variants to selection in males, but their fate depends on the severity of the effect, frequency, matings and population structure. Scientific sources Shultz R.R., Nixon J.M., Ryals D.K. et al. (2026). The life history of recessive deleterious alleles as seen through the eyes of a honey bee (Apis mellifera). Molecular Biology and Evolution 43(7), msag156. DOI: 10.1093/molbev/msag156. Claire – ESA Regine editorial team
- Tropilaelaps mercedesae: recognising the emerging mite and understanding the risk to bees
Scientific review | Research applied to beekeeping At a glance Comb of capped brood Tropilaelaps mercedesae is an ectoparasitic mite that reproduces in the capped brood of Apis mellifera. Several 2026 publications document its geographic expansion and describe its biology. The issue calls for preventive awareness, not alarmism: the sources reviewed here do not provide an officially confirmed report of this parasite in Italy. The important point for beekeepers is that established surveillance methods for Varroa destructor do not necessarily have the same sensitivity for Tropilaelaps. Understanding this difference helps critically assess reports, symptoms and prevention strategies. A mite different from Varroa Tropilaelaps sp. mites on Apis mellifera pupae. Photo: Denis Anderson / CSIRO, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons. The genus Tropilaelaps was originally associated with Asian Apis species, especially giant honey bees. T. mercedesae has acquired the ability to develop on managed Apis mellifera. Its functional similarity to Varroa lies in its association with brood; this does not make the parasites diagnostically interchangeable. Tropilaelaps spends very little time on adult bees and much of its life cycle in capped brood cells. Reproductive biology and mite mobility influence population growth. Consequently, an adult-bee wash that detects no mites cannot alone rule out Tropilaelaps infestation. What the 2026 studies say about distribution The 2026 scientific reviews describe established populations in many Asian regions and more westerly reports in Eurasia, including Georgia and Russia. Expansion warrants surveillance, but “Europe” must not be taken to mean demonstrated presence in every European country. Interpretation must account for place and time: parasite distribution is continually updated through identifications and publications, and a report from one territory does not establish the Italian situation. Local suspicions must be assessed by competent veterinary authorities and reference laboratories. Recognising a suspected case Brood may show damage consistent with parasitism and weakened pupae, but an irregular brood pattern alone cannot identify the species. Correct sampling and morphological examination are required, with molecular analysis where appropriate. Recent reviews compare brood-cell examination, collection of fallen mites and adult-bee methods. Direct brood inspection is informative because mites spend most of their cycle there. Environmental DNA diagnostics are promising but require expertise and analytical controls. Beekeepers observing unusual mites or unexplained symptoms should retain a properly labelled sample, document the hive and material origin, limit unnecessary movements and contact veterinary services or a competent laboratory. Online photographs cannot replace diagnosis. Can genetic selection help? Ventral micrograph of a female Tropilaelaps mite collected on Apis florea, illustrating morphological features. Photo: Pavel Klimov / Bee Mite ID, USDA. For now, the answer must remain cautious. Breeding programmes for hygienic traits, VSH and other Varroa-resistance phenotypes provide valuable knowledge but do not automatically demonstrate effective resistance to Tropilaelaps. Specific trials and repeatable colony assessments are needed. ESA Regine has worked for years on Apis mellifera ligustica, colony selection, pedigrees and progeny evaluation. This experience supports vigilance towards new health problems; it does not mean that the business has already selected mite-resistant lines or can guarantee protection against an emerging parasite. What we can do now The first useful steps are to consult official and scientific sources, trace introduced live material, follow applicable health requirements and distinguish surveillance from treatment. Varroa management remains a separate, current priority. Tropilaelaps research reminds us that biosecurity is ongoing work: learning about a problem before it appears helps prepare observations and procedures without creating concern disproportionate to the evidence. Frequently asked questions Is Tropilaelaps mercedesae present in Italy? At the time of writing, the scientific sources consulted did not establish confirmed presence in Italy. Updates from the competent authorities must be checked. Is Varroa monitoring sufficient to detect it? No. Tropilaelaps biology makes some adult-bee methods less sensitive; diagnosis requires suitable procedures and specialist identification. Scientific sources Esmaeily M. et al. (2026). Tropilaelaps mercedesae: an emerging global threat to apiculture. Frontiers in Insect Science. DOI 10.3389/finsc.2026.1871985 Review (2026). Tropilaelaps mercedesae: rapid geographic expansion in a novel honey bee host. Trends in Parasitology. DOI 10.1016/j.pt.2026.07.002 Miao L. et al. (2026). Living with Tropilaelaps mercedesae: its history and impact on Chinese beekeeping. Apidologie. DOI 10.1007/s13592-026-01302-3 Claire — ESA Regine editorial team
- Vespa crabro – biology and interactions with honey bee colonies
Scientific review Preface The European hornet, Vespa crabro Linnaeus, 1758, is a eusocial vespid native to much of Eurasia and a generalist predator of arthropods. Apis mellifera is among its possible prey. The relationship between the two species depends on the hornet’s social biology, the strength of the honey bee colony and the strongly seasonal hornet life cycle [1,2]. The implications for beekeeping become more pronounced in the second half of the year, when a colony of V. crabro reaches its largest size, its brood needs more protein, and it produces reproductive individuals [2]. Hornets mainly intercept bees outside the hive. Colonies of A. mellifera can mount collective defences, including balling [1]. Food baits can help monitor hornets, but they may also concentrate them locally and increase encounters around an apiary. Researchers have therefore explored systems in which an insect carries a substance into its own colony. This approach, known as trophic transfer or a Trojan horse approach, draws on food collection, prey processing and trophallaxis [3]. Most of the experimental evidence concerns Vespa velutina. Studies have examined protein baits containing fipronil and, more recently, the oral toxicity of acetamiprid, spinosad, cypermethrin and natural pyrethrins [4,5]. Analytical work has also detected the fipronil metabolites fipronil sulfone and fipronil sulfide in larvae. This raises the research question of whether metabolism in the target species could influence the effect of low doses [6]. These findings cannot be assumed to apply to V. crabro. The European hornet has a different ecology, and control research needs to account for its role in ecosystems. Future studies of baits should focus on behavioural and pharmacological selectivity, examining species-specific attractants, suitable food matrices, social transfer, and compounds that maximise effects on the target while limiting risks to other organisms. 1. Introduction European hornet specimen (Vespa crabro) The presence of Vespa crabro in apiaries is often described simply as hornets eating bees. Several aspects of its biology shape the interaction. V. crabro is a generalist predator. Its diet includes many arthropods and plant resources, and honey bees are one component [2]. Its colonies are annual and strongly seasonal. A founding queen starts a nest in spring. The colony grows through summer and reaches its largest size in late summer and autumn. Workers and males die at the end of the cycle, while the new queens overwinter individually [2,7]. For beekeeping, the number of hornets present is only one part of the picture. The stage of the hornet colony’s development and the vulnerability of the honey bee colony also matter. The hornet’s social behaviour is also relevant. Workers capture and process prey and carry food back to the nest. This colony food network offers a route to study control methods that work differently from trapping alone [3]. 2. Biology of Vespa crabro 2.1. Colony life cycle A colony of V. crabro lasts one season. The population persists through the mated females produced late in the season, which found new nests after overwintering [2,7]. It helps to distinguish three biological entities: the nest, a temporary structure; the colony, a social group that lives for one season; the population, which persists through future queens. An abandoned nest is therefore no indication that a new colony will occupy it the following year. 2.2. Spring nest founding Vespa crabro founding queen on an early nest The season begins with a queen that has survived the winter. At first, she builds the first cells, lays eggs and gathers food on her own. This founding stage differs from life in a mature colony. There are few individuals, and the whole reproductive investment depends on a single queen. The division of labour changes rapidly once the first workers emerge. They gradually take over foraging, leaving the queen to concentrate on egg laying [2]. 2.3. Summer growth Emergence of a European hornet (Vespa crabro) The colony grows rapidly in summer. Workers forage, care for the brood, maintain the nest and defend it. Adults and larvae have different dietary needs: adults rely mainly on liquid, sugar-rich foods; the brood needs protein-rich food derived from animal prey [2]. The colony therefore forages for two kinds of food. Hornets can gather carbohydrates for adults and hunt prey to feed the brood. 2.4. Late summer and autumn The colony needs more food as it grows. Towards the end of the cycle, it produces new queens and males. Observations in Sardinia documented foraging on fruit, flowers, plant exudates, water and a range of prey, including A. mellifera [2]. Late summer and autumn are therefore the periods when V. crabro may be most conspicuous to beekeepers. 2.5. Overwintering Workers and males die at the end of the season. The newly mated females leave the nest and seek sheltered places to overwinter individually. Overwintering is part of the annual cycle: colony → production of new queens → mating → dispersal → overwintering → founding of a new nest. Recent work on nest architecture also shows that the summer nest is a temporary, structurally complex construction that grows substantially over the season [7]. 3. Diet and interactions with Apis mellifera 3.1. A generalist predator Interpreting V. crabro as a honey bee specialist is unsupported by the literature. Research on the hornet’s biology and behaviour in Sardinia found a broad, generalist diet [2]. Honey bees are available prey in some circumstances and account for only part of the hornet’s feeding niche. For bait design, this shifts the question to which food cues hornets respond to at a given stage of the season. 3.2. Predation on foragers Observations by Baracchi et al. in central Italy showed that V. crabro often intercepts returning foragers outside the hive [1]. A returning forager is a relatively large and readily recognisable prey item. An apiary can therefore become a predictable food source, especially when the hornet colony’s demand for protein is high. 3.3. Honey bee defences Honey bees can defend themselves collectively. Colonies of A. mellifera can surround an attacking hornet. This behaviour, known as balling, can raise the temperature around the hornet beyond what it can tolerate [1]. Colony size can therefore influence the bees’ ability to withstand predation. This has a practical implication for beekeepers: a strong colony is the first line of defence against predation pressure. 4. Trophallaxis and the colony’s food economy Feeding behaviour in social wasps creates a network for distributing food throughout the nest. Larval saliva in V. crabro contains carbohydrates and amino acids and forms part of the colony’s food supply. Kojima’s comparative study found relatively high levels of specific amino acids and described a role for larval secretions in hornet social behaviour [3]. Food moves among individuals within the colony. A worker can: collect food; process it; carry it to the nest; pass it to larvae or other adults; receive food from other colony members in turn. Trophallaxis thus forms a biological distribution network. For research on social wasp control, this network is of interest because a foraging worker could, in principle, carry a substance back to the colony. 5. Baits: from attraction to changes in behaviour 5.1. Sugar-based and protein-based food matrices The choice of food matrix should account for the target species’ nutritional needs. Sugar-based baits may be more attractive when the colony is seeking carbohydrates. Protein-based matrices may become more relevant when the brood’s demand for protein is high. Research in Campania in 2025 compared beer, canned baits and commercial fish-based food. It found a marked preference in V. crabro for beer in September and October [8]. The result does not establish the best bait year-round. It shows that attractiveness depends strongly on the species, the season and local conditions. 5.2. Attracting hornets near hives Baits can be counterproductive if their placement is poorly planned. A baited trap deliberately creates a point of attraction. If it is right next to the hives, it can increase hornet activity in the area it is meant to protect. Research has not shown that food-baited traps cause a lasting increase in the population of V. crabro. A trap should nevertheless be understood as a factor that changes where hornets gather, rather than as a passive barrier. 5.3. Monitoring and control serve different purposes A bait that works well for monitoring may be unsuitable for control. Monitoring aims to maximise the chance of detecting the species. Control research, by contrast, aims to: target the intended species; avoid exposing other organisms; maintain attraction for the necessary period; allow foragers to carry material to the nest when testing a Trojan horse approach. These objectives can conflict. 6. The Trojan horse approach: the biological principle Trophic transfer works differently from conventional trapping. In an ingestible lethal bait system: attraction → ingestion → death of the exposed individual. In a trophic transfer system: attraction → feeding and collection → transport to the nest → social transfer → colony exposure. The intended target extends beyond the individual hornet to the colony’s social network. This approach has mainly been tested against V. velutina, with results supporting the feasibility of the principle in that species [4]. 7. Protein baits and biocides: evidence from experimental studies 7.1. Fipronil: the best-documented experimental example Fipronil has been studied in the greatest detail. Barandika et al. examined protein baits containing this active ingredient in V. velutina. The study combined laboratory tests on larvae with field tests in multiple apiaries [4]. The experiment examined how larvae were exposed to the active ingredient through food brought into the colony, in addition to any effects on adult foragers. Several concentrations were tested in the laboratory, and the formulation that performed best there was then used in the field trial [4]. At apiaries under high pressure from V. velutina, observers recorded a significant reduction in hornet activity for at least two weeks. The reduction was greater where more bait was consumed [4]. This provides a proof of principle for control through trophic transfer. 7.2. Fipronil metabolism in larvae Metabolites form as the organism processes the parent compound A subsequent analytical study examined what happens after ingestion. Using HPLC-DAD and GC-MS, the researchers detected fipronil and its metabolites fipronil sulfone and fipronil sulfide in larvae [6]. This matters because the effects of a bait may depend on compounds formed after ingestion as well as on the parent compound. The target organism can convert the active ingredient into metabolites with different toxicological properties. The authors noted that fipronil sulfone is highly toxic. This metabolic pathway could have implications for future research on lower-dose systems [6]. It remains a research question with no established field application for the European hornet. 8. Which biocides have researchers studied? Recent studies have looked beyond fipronil. 8.1. Acetamiprid A study published in December 2025 evaluated the oral toxicity of acetamiprid to workers of V. velutina nigrithorax [5]. Among the compounds tested, acetamiprid had the highest oral potency and acted relatively quickly under the study conditions. Acetamiprid is a neonicotinoid that acts as an agonist at nicotinic acetylcholine receptors [5]. The experiment showed a marked effect on hornets after ingestion. The authors also emphasised the need to assess risks to pollinators and other non-target organisms [5]. 8.2. Spinosad Spinosad showed a different profile. In the study by Souto et al., its effects developed progressively and included both mortality and behavioural changes [5]. Spinosad acts orally through a neurotoxic mechanism distinct from that of neonicotinoids. Its sublethal effects on foraging and the ability to return to the nest are also worth studying. In a trophic-transfer system, a compound that rapidly repels or immobilises a forager may prevent it from carrying bait back to the colony. 8.3. Cypermethrin Cypermethrin caused substantial mortality after ingestion in the 2025 tests, but hornets also showed marked avoidance [5]. Even a highly toxic compound may be unsuitable for trophic transfer if the target species detects and avoids it. Formulation research therefore has to answer two questions. How toxic is the compound? And can it remain effective while allowing the hornets to accept and transport the bait? 8.4. Natural pyrethrins The natural pyrethrin mixture was less effective than acetamiprid, spinosad and cypermethrin under the study conditions [5]. Pyrethrins remain of interest for comparative research because they are neurotoxic and can degrade rapidly in the environment. For trophic transfer, selectivity and forager behaviour remain key uncertainties. 9. Qualitative comparison of the main compounds studied The available evidence supports the following comparison: Compound or class Evidence in vespids Relevance to trophic-transfer bait research Main limitation Fipronil Substantial, including a field trial in V. velutina [4] High research interest Limited selectivity, risks to non-target organisms and effects of metabolites [4,6] Acetamiprid High oral toxicity in V. velutina [5] High research interest, with transfer yet to be tested Risks to pollinators and uncertainty about whether individual toxicity translates into colony-level effects Spinosad High oral toxicity and behavioural effects [5] Of research interest Bait acceptance, transport and effects on non-target organisms still need assessment Cypermethrin High oral toxicity [5] Less suitable for transfer research Observed avoidance or repellency [5] Natural pyrethrins Activity documented, with lower potency in the test [5] Of possible research interest Lower efficacy and persistence; non-selective This table highlights a point often overlooked: the compound with the highest acute toxicity is not necessarily the most suitable for trophic transfer. 10. What would a true “Trojan” bait need? A formulation for research on trophic transfer would ideally meet at least six requirements. 10.1. High attractiveness The hornet must recognize the substrate as food. 10.2. Low repellency The active ingredient must not deter feeding. Cypermethrin is an instructive example: hornets showed avoidance in the 2025 study [5]. 10.3. Stability during collection The bait must remain palatable long enough for hornets to collect and transport it. 10.4. Compatibility with social behaviour Hornets must carry the material into the nest and transfer it to the brood. 10.5. An appropriate delay before onset An excessively rapid effect could be counterproductive: a forager immobilized at the bait is unlikely to carry it to the nest. 10.6. Ecological selectivity This is probably the hardest requirement to meet. An ideal formulation would be recognized mainly by the target species and pose minimal risk to bees, wild hymenopterans, flies and other organisms. 11. The future: from toxicity to behavioural selectivity Future research could shift its focus from the compound to the behaviour of the target species. 11.1. Semiochemistry V. crabro has complex chemical communication systems. Studies of mating behaviour have shown that males respond to chemical cues associated with females and have identified differences in cuticular lipid profiles [9]. These findings open up research into semiochemicals that could increase species-specific attraction. This approach could address a limitation of general-purpose food baits. 11.2. Pheromones and alarm signals Researchers have also investigated compounds involved in the response to alarm signals in V. crabro [10]. A promising line of inquiry is to understand which compounds alter the insect's activity, orientation or tendency to remain near a resource. Their suitability as bait cues is a separate question. 11.3. Designing bait around behaviour Future bait could be conceived as a system with several components: semiochemical cue → attraction; food matrix → acceptance; active ingredient → biological effect; delayed onset → return to the nest; trophallaxis → distribution; low environmental persistence → reduced non-target exposure. This approach would account for more steps in hornet behaviour than a conventional trap containing food and insecticide. 12. A crucial question: time to onset Timing is particularly important in the Trojan-horse approach. If the active ingredient kills an individual almost immediately, the carrier may fail to reach the nest. If the effect takes too long, the amount transferred may be insufficient. Mortality is only one factor to consider. The relevant combination is: acceptance × amount ingested × return time × amount transferred × brood exposure × colony mortality. This is one of the main reasons why individual oral toxicity data, although important, are insufficient for developing a bait that works through trophic transfer. An LC₅₀ or LD₅₀ result alone cannot predict efficacy at the nest level. 13. The problem of sublethal doses Another line of research concerns sublethal effects. A compound may leave a worker alive initially while affecting its: orientation; flight activity; foraging ability; return to the nest; ability to feed the brood; social interactions In the 2025 study, for example, spinosad caused both mortality and behavioural changes, while hornets showed avoidance of cypermethrin [5]. These findings suggest that the highest acute lethality may not provide the best pharmacological profile for a Trojan bait. An active ingredient that could preserve the ability to transport bait while gradually impairing colony function might be of greater biological interest, although it would require much more extensive research. 14. Metabolism as a design tool The case of fipronil and fipronil sulfone is particularly interesting for another reason. The target insect's metabolism could inform the design of a control system. The substance in the bait could act as a precursor to a more active metabolite produced by the insect itself. Experiments on V. velutina show that fipronil is converted to fipronil sulfone and fipronil sulfide inside the larvae [6]. This observation suggests a line of pharmacological research: an ideal formulation might contain a compound that the target organism itself metabolizes into a more active substance. In theory, this could reduce the initial amount of active ingredient. However, the same metabolic transformation would also need to be studied in non-target organisms before it could be regarded as an ecotoxicological advantage. 15. Towards more selective compounds Conventional classes of insecticides were generally developed to target broad groups of insects. Controlling colonies of vespid wasps calls for much greater selectivity. Future research could explore: 15.1. Compounds with selective neurophysiological effects The aim would be to exploit pharmacological differences between the target and non-target pollinators. 15.2. Growth regulators A compound that interferes with larval development or metamorphosis could be better suited to a colony-level approach than a very fast-acting pyrethroid. This hypothesis would require direct testing in vespid wasps. The known mode of action in other insects is insufficient to establish it. 15.3. Behavioural modulators A compound that alters social behaviour or foraging could theoretically impair a colony's ability to sustain itself, even without immediately causing high mortality among individual insects. 15.4. Proinsecticide systems The most novel concept is the one suggested by the transformation of fipronil: a relatively less active compound that the target organism converts into a more potent metabolite. This approach is scientifically promising but calls for a much more sophisticated toxicological assessment. 16. Why Vespa crabro needs species-specific research Vespa crabro is native to most of Europe and plays a role as a predator in ecosystems Nearly all modern evidence on the Trojan-horse approach comes from studies of V. velutina. This reflects the fact that V. velutina is an invasive alien species with a substantial impact on European beekeeping and biodiversity. V. crabro differs in its ecology. It is native to most of Europe and plays a role as a predator in ecosystems. The Sardinian study also found that the species showed no substantial behavioural changes in the area surveyed that would suggest a strongly invasive pattern [2]. It would therefore be methodologically unsound to apply a protocol developed for V. velutina directly to V. crabro. Researchers would first need to determine the following for V. crabro: seasonal food preferences; rate of bait consumption; amount carried to the nest; frequency of trophallaxis; susceptibility to oral exposure at different life stages; avoidance behaviour; metabolism of the active ingredient; sublethal effects; exposure of non-target organisms. 17. Proposed experimental framework Future research on V. crabro should proceed in stages, with intermediate steps between laboratory studies and field trials. Phase 1 — Assessing attractiveness Compare sugar-based and protein-based matrices at different times in the season. Phase 2 — Feeding behaviour Measure the amount consumed and the time spent at the bait. Phase 3 — Transport Determine the percentage of foragers that return to the nest after feeding. Phase 4 — Social transfer Quantify the transfer of food to the brood and adults. Phase 5 — Pharmacology Compare the oral toxicity and sublethal effects of the compounds. Phase 6 — Metabolism Identify the metabolites and characterize their toxicological profiles. Phase 7 — Selectivity Compare with A. mellifera and the non-target insects most likely to be exposed. Phase 8 — Controlled microcolonies Assess effects on colony growth as well as individual mortality. Phase 9 — Field trial Proceed only after demonstrating an acceptable balance of benefits and risks. This sequence would help avoid a major pitfall in applied research: confusing individual toxicity with effective colony management. 18. Biocides and regulation: the boundary between research and application Regulatory requirements are particularly important for baits containing biocides. Regulation (EU) No 528/2012 sets out the European framework for approving active substances and authorising biocidal products. A biocidal product may be placed on the market or used only in accordance with the applicable authorisation requirements. Scientific studies of its active ingredient alone do not confer authorisation [11,12]. The distinction is essential: a compound studied in the laboratory ≠ an authorised product. Likewise: a product authorised for a specific use ≠ general permission to prepare bait for a different target organism. Fipronil illustrates the distinction. The ECHA database lists its active-substance approval status as “expired” for product type 18 (PT18), while individual biocidal products are authorised in various countries for specific uses [12]. The status therefore needs to be checked for the active substance, the product, the product type and the relevant national or Union authorisation. For V. crabro, the available scientific evidence is also insufficient to regard biocidal baits based on trophic transfer as a standard control method. 19. Why biocidal baits can make the problem worse An often underestimated risk is that a single bait can simultaneously serve as: a means of control; an attractant; a source of environmental exposure. An attractive bait draws more predators to the point where it is placed. At an apiary, this can have the opposite of the intended effect. Protein bait can also attract other organisms, and a broad-spectrum insecticide can affect species outside the scope of control. The issue is particularly important in a Trojan-horse system because the active ingredient enters the colony's social network. Biological efficiency and ecological risk can therefore increase together. That is why selectivity should be the main criterion in future development. 20. An integrated approach to protecting honey bee colonies In practical beekeeping, an integrated approach remains the most appropriate strategy. Strengthening colonies A strong colony is better able to defend itself [1]. Managing the hive entrance Carefully restricting access can help more vulnerable colonies. Most of the evidence comes from management of V. velutina, but restricting access is consistent with the defensive behaviour of honey bees. Monitoring Baits can help track seasonal activity and determine whether the predator is present [8]. Locating the nest When predation pressure persists, finding the source is often more appropriate than indiscriminately increasing the number of traps. Professional control A problematic nest should be dealt with using procedures and products permitted under the applicable regulations. Experimental research The Trojan-horse approach is a subject of scientific research and remains distinct from standard control practice. 21. Looking ahead: from poisoned bait to applied behavioural ecology Early studies focused on one question: which substance kills hornets most effectively? The next generation of studies should address a more complex question: which combination of behaviour, bait and pharmacology can disrupt a colony with the least impact on the ecosystem? An advanced strategy would need to account for the whole sequence: phenology → attraction → ingestion → transport → trophallaxis → metabolism → sublethal or lethal effects → colony collapse. It would also need to account for: selectivity for the target → minimising effects on non-target organisms → limiting environmental dispersal → checking regulatory requirements. In this model, the active ingredient is one component of the system. Control depends on how the compound interacts with the hornet's social biology. 22. Conclusions The biology of Vespa crabro reveals a complex system in which predation, food transfer and reproduction are closely linked. Its interaction with Apis mellifera is generally opportunistic. Field observations indicate that predation occurs mainly outside the hive, especially on foragers, while strong colonies mount an effective collective defence [1,2]. The latter part of the season is of particular interest to beekeepers because the hornet colony reaches peak activity and its food requirements rise [2]. Conventional baits are useful for monitoring, but the results must be interpreted in light of their attraction effect. A trap can temporarily remove captured individuals without necessarily reducing overall predation pressure. Under some conditions, it can even create a new local concentration of predators. The Trojan-horse concept is of particular biological interest because it exploits the social structure of the hornet colony. The strongest experimental evidence comes from studies of V. velutina using protein baits containing fipronil [4]. Subsequent studies of metabolism also demonstrated the formation of fipronil sulfone and fipronil sulfide in larvae, suggesting a line of research into systems that exploit metabolic bioactivation of the active ingredient [6]. More recent work has extended the scope to acetamiprid, spinosad, cypermethrin and natural pyrethrins. Acetamiprid and spinosad showed particularly notable oral toxicity profiles in V. velutina, while cypermethrin showed an important behavioural limitation: repellency [5]. These findings point to a fundamental principle: the suitability of a compound for Trojan bait depends on acceptance, transport, social transfer, efficacy at colony level and minimal exposure of non-target organisms as well as toxicity. For V. crabro, much of the research remains to be done. Studies should now focus directly on the European hornet and examine the following together: seasonal food preferences; sugar- and protein-based attractants; semiochemistry; transport behaviour; trophallaxis; oral toxicity; sublethal effects; metabolism; selectivity with respect to A. mellifera; exposure of non-target insects; colony-level effects. The most promising direction is therefore to design a system that combines behavioural and pharmacological approaches to colony control with enough selectivity to be integrated into modern apiary management. In this context, the Trojan-horse approach is a potential tool of applied behavioural ecology. It remains experimental for V. crabro and uses the predator's social organisation to distribute the active substance. Notes and scientific references [1] Baracchi, D., Cusseau, G., Pradella, D., & Turillazzi, S. (2010). Defence reactions of Apis mellifera ligustica against attacks from the European hornet Vespa crabro. Ethology Ecology & Evolution, 22, 281–294. DOI: 10.1080/03949370.2010.502323. The study documents predation by V. crabro on honey bee foragers and the bees' collective defence response. (PubMed Central (PMC)) [2] Pusceddu, M., Lezzeri, M., Cocco, A., Floris, I., & Satta, A. (2022). Bio-Ethology of Vespa crabro in Sardinia (Italy), an Area of New Introduction. Biology, 11, 518. DOI: 10.3390/biology11040518. A study of the phenology, foraging and social behaviour of V. crabro and its predation on A. mellifera. (MDPI) [3] Kojima, J. (1991). Comparative study of the composition of hornet larval saliva, its effect on behaviour and role of trophallaxis. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology Part C, 99, 79–84. DOI: 10.1016/0742-8413(91)90079-9. The study includes V. crabro and documents the composition of larval saliva and the role of food exchange in the colony. (ScienceDirect) [4] Barandika, J. F. et al. (2023). Efficacy of Protein Baits with Fipronil to Control Vespa velutina nigrithorax in Apiaries. Animals, 13, 2075. DOI: 10.3390/ani13132075. A laboratory and field study on the trophic transfer of fipronil via protein bait. The field trial involved 222 beekeepers, of whom 90 returned the questionnaire. The effect was most evident in apiaries under high pressure from V. velutina. (PubMed) [5] Malaquias Souto, P. et al. (2025). Assessing the oral toxicity of acetamiprid, spinosad, cypermethrin, and pyrethrins in the invasive hornet Vespa velutina nigrithorax. Scientific Reports, 15, 45112. DOI: 10.1038/s41598-025-31988-x. A comparative oral toxicity study of four formulations containing acetamiprid, spinosad, cypermethrin and a mixture of natural pyrethrins. Acetamiprid showed the greatest oral potency in the experimental system. Spinosad caused mortality and sublethal changes, and hornets showed avoidance of cypermethrin. (Nature) [6] de la Hera, O., Izaguirre, A., Rivas, A., & Alonso, R. M. (2024). QuEChERS-Based Method for the Determination of Fipronil in Protein Baits and Vespa velutina Larvae by HPLC-DAD and GC-MS. Separations, 11, 317. The study experimentally documents fipronil and its metabolites, fipronil sulfone and fipronil sulfide, in V. velutina larvae, with implications for research on formulations and metabolic bioactivation. (MDPI) [7] Jurczyková, T. et al. (2026). Chemical and structural analysis of a European hornet nest. Scientific Reports, 16, 9395. A multidisciplinary study of the structure and composition of a V. crabro nest, which helps explain the temporary nature and architecture of the colony's nest. (Nature) [8] Martano, M., Power, K., Montagnaro, S., Esposito, M., D'Emilio, C., & Maiolino, P. (2026). Evaluation of Bait Attractiveness for Vespa orientalis and Vespa crabro (Hymenoptera: Vespidae) in Urban and Apiary Environment of Campania Region (Italy). Insects, 17(4), 368. DOI: 10.3390/insects17040368. The study covered 15 apiaries and 10 urban areas in September and October 2025. V. crabro showed a marked preference for beer-based bait over the other matrices tested. (MDPI) [9] Spiewok, S., Schmolz, E., & Ruther, J. (2006). Mating system of the European hornet Vespa crabro: male seeking strategies and evidence for the involvement of a sex pheromone. Journal of Chemical Ecology, 32, 2777–2788. DOI: 10.1007/s10886-006-9162-4. The study provides experimental evidence of chemical cues involved in sexual attraction in V. crabro, with potential implications for applied semiochemistry. (PubMed) [10] MacLean, C., & Schmolz, E. (2004). Calorimetric investigations on the action of alarm pheromones in the hornet Vespa crabro. Thermochimica Acta, 414, 71–77. A study of physiological and behavioural responses to chemical cues associated with the species' alarm system. [11] European Commission. Regulation on the supply and use of biocidal products. Regulation (EU) No 528/2012 governs the approval of active substances and the authorisation of biocidal products. The Commission specifies that placing a biocidal product on the market or using it requires compliance with the applicable authorisation framework. (Public Health) [12] ECHA – European Chemicals Agency. Information on biocides / Biocidal active substances. The ECHA database lists the active-substance approval for fipronil in PT18 as “Expired”, while individual products may hold authorisations in specific markets and under specific conditions of use. (ECHA) Methodological note. The evidence on fipronil, acetamiprid, spinosad, cypermethrin and pyrethrins cited in the biocide sections comes primarily from research on V. velutina. The article presents it as a review of current research and possible directions for experiments. The evidence does not establish efficacy or authorise or prescribe use against V. crabro. The quantitative findings from experimental studies should be read in their research context. Author: Davide Simeone Published: 16 August 2026
- From Varroa control to breeding the host
Preface Varroa destructor on an Apis mellifera pupa inside a capped cell. The mite reproduces in capped brood Selective breeding of Apis mellifera for resistance to Varroa destructor is one of the most promising ways to make beekeeping more sustainable and gradually reduce reliance on chemical control of the parasite. Resistance results from the interaction of several behavioural, physiological, genetic and social mechanisms. These include general hygienic behaviour (HYG), Varroa sensitive hygiene (VSH), mite non-reproduction (MNR, a more precise term for reduced mite reproduction), recapping and grooming. This article examines the genetic and behavioural basis of these traits, with particular attention to quantitative trait loci (QTL) and candidate genes, the social structure and patrilines of the colony, heritability, test repeatability and phenotyping methods. These include the pin test, the freeze-killed brood test, the VSH test and the Harbo test. It also compares studies of different sizes, distinguishing research on at least 100 colonies housed in standard Dadant or Langstroth hives from experiments using nucleus colonies or smaller samples. The available literature shows that breeding for resistance to Varroa can be combined with selection for honey production, spring development, overwintering and gentleness. Pol-line honey bees (a breeding population of Apis mellifera developed in the United States specifically for greater resistance to Varroa destructor while retaining traits useful for commercial beekeeping) provide a prominent example under conditions close to commercial practice. A longitudinal study of 366 colonies in 10-frame Langstroth hives found significantly better survival in the selected population, with no significant reduction in honey production among surviving colonies [1]. Similarly, a Canadian programme following 604 colonies over eight generations found that infestation by Varroa, spring development, honey production, winter food consumption and hygienic behaviour have a genetic component that can respond to selection and can be included in a single selection index [2]. The practical conclusion is to treat VSH as a priority health trait within a multi-trait breeding index. A commercial operation needs a population that combines consistently high resistance to Varroa with productivity, gentleness, a low tendency to swarm, colony development, longevity and adaptation to local rearing conditions. 1. Introduction: from controlling Varroa to breeding the host Varroa destructor is a major cause of mortality in managed colonies of Apis mellifera worldwide. In addition to feeding on host tissues, particularly the fat body, the mite disrupts host physiology and plays an important role in transmitting and amplifying viruses, impairing the health of both individuals and colonies [3]. Conventional control targets the parasite directly with acaricides, biotechnical methods or both. Selective breeding instead changes the susceptibility of the host over successive generations. A realistic breeding goal concerns the growth of the population of Varroa. If mite numbers rise slowly enough, the colony may be able to function normally for a substantial part of the year. The systematic review by Mondet et al. found that survival in the presence of Varroa is associated with a range of phenotypic and genomic mechanisms [4]. This leads to a first principle: Varroa resistance is a complex colony-level trait that cannot be captured by a single gene or diagnostic test. 2. Individual and social immunity Honey bee defences against pathogens can be grouped broadly into: individual defences; social defences. The second group includes behaviours in which workers recognise and remove infected, parasitised or dead individuals. Hygienic behaviour is therefore a form of social immunity. A worker can: detect an abnormality; locate the cell; uncap it; remove the pupa or larva; carry the material away. In the case of Varroa, this mechanism is particularly complex because the worker must recognise cues associated with the mite's presence and reproductive activity. 3. HYG: general hygienic behaviour Hygienic behaviour (HYG) is the ability of workers to detect and remove dead, diseased or otherwise abnormal brood. The phenotype comprises two main behavioural components: detection and uncapping and removal. Hygienic behaviour (HYG) is the ability of workers to detect and remove dead, diseased or otherwise abnormal brood Rothenbuhler originally proposed a relatively simple model with separate genetic factors for uncapping and removal. Subsequent quantitative studies found a much more complex architecture. Lapidge, Oldroyd and Spivak identified seven suggestive QTL associated with hygienic behaviour, each explaining a limited share of the variation in the population studied [5]. Oxley, Spivak and Oldroyd later identified six QTL associated with the behavioural threshold at which a worker begins hygienic activity [6]. These findings indicate that the phenotype arises from the interaction of multiple genomic regions and, in particular, from how they are expressed in the social context of the colony. 4. VSH: a specialised form of hygienic behaviour Varroa sensitive hygiene (VSH) is a specific form of hygienic behaviour in which workers preferentially detect brood infested with Varroa and remove it. The distinction from general HYG matters. The conventional HYG test asks: “How quickly does the colony detect and remove a dead pupa?” Experimental design used to assess the VSH response to cells containing Varroa and to different cues associated with the mite's presence The VSH test asks a different question: “How effectively does the colony detect and remove brood associated with Varroa, particularly when the mite is reproducing?” Tsuruda et al. identified genomic regions associated with VSH, including a QTL on chromosome 9 [7]. These regions contain candidate genes linked to sensory perception and stimulus processing. The identified regions explain only part of the variance, and the overall genetic architecture remains polygenic. 5. Candidate genes: olfaction, the nervous system and behaviour One line of VSH research concerns chemical perception. Mondet et al. compared the antennal transcriptomes of bees that displayed VSH with those of bees that did not [8]. The findings suggest that the antennae play a central role in detecting cues from infested brood. The profile of VSH bees was more similar to that of nurse bees than to that of foragers, consistent with the behaviour being expressed mainly by workers performing tasks inside the nest. The literature discusses several groups of genes and candidates: OBPs, odorant-binding proteins; olfactory receptors; CSPs, chemosensory proteins; nanchung; dopaminergic pathways; Dscam; genes involved in neuronal development and connectivity. Dscam is of particular interest. A genome-wide association study (GWAS) of 155 colonies of A. m. mellifera from France and Switzerland identified two QTL significantly associated with recapping of brood infested by Varroa. One was located in an intron of Dscam, a gene involved in neuronal connectivity [9]. Taken together, the findings suggest that behavioural resistance involves several linked processes: perception → neural processing → learning and behavioural thresholds → social response. 6. SMR, MNR and VSH: three distinct concepts The terms SMR, MNR and VSH are a recurring source of confusion in research and technical publications. SMR – Suppressed Mite Reproduction The term was used to describe colonies in which a very high proportion of mites in the brood did not reproduce. Harbo and Harris later showed that adult bee behaviour accounted for an important part of this phenomenon [10]. In one experiment, naturally infested combs of freshly capped brood were transferred to SMR and control colonies. After eight days, SMR colonies had a much lower proportion of infested cells than controls, and a much smaller share of the remaining mites were reproductive [10]. MNR – Mite Non-Reproduction MNR is now the more descriptive term. It refers to the observed mite phenotype, namely failure to reproduce. VSH VSH describes the behaviour of the bee. In summary: VSH = a behavioural trait of the bee MNR = an observable outcome in the mite's reproductive cycle SMR = the historical term for the phenotype and the original selection approach The distinction matters because non-reproduction can have several causes. Its presence alone does not establish VSH [4,10]. 7. The colony as a genetic and social unit One feature of honey bee genetics sets breeding apart from breeding in many other domesticated animals. The queen generally mates with many drones, so the colony comprises several patrilines. Workers share a mother but may have different fathers. A single colony therefore contains several genotypes. A colony's VSH phenotype depends on the proportion of workers predisposed to the behaviour and on how they interact. Selection must therefore account for both parents. The queen contributes a substantial share of the colony's genetic potential, and the drones that sire her offspring also help determine the phenotype. This has a practical consequence: a queen from a high-VSH line can produce a colony with modest VSH if the paternal lines have not been selected for the trait. 8. The role of nurse bees Workers that perform tasks inside the nest are chiefly responsible for hygienic behaviour. Mondet et al. found that the profile of VSH bees was closer to that of nurse bees than to that of foragers [8]. This is consistent with the biology of the colony: workers that carry out tasks inside the nest are the most likely to encounter and interact with capped brood. Selection therefore needs to consider the colony as a social system, with the individual as one part of that system. 9. Measuring HYG: the pin test The pin test is a simple method for preliminary assessment of hygienic behaviour. A patch of capped brood of uniform age is selected and the pupae are mechanically injured with a needle. It is preferable to use a standard number of cells, such as 50–100. Counts are made at predetermined intervals, typically: 12 hours; 24 hours; 48 hours if needed. Example of an assessment of hygienic behaviour using artificially damaged brood. The percentage of cells from which brood has been removed is recorded at standard intervals The final percentage matters, as does the speed of removal. A colony that clears 95% of the cells in 12 hours differs behaviourally from one that reaches the same level after 48 hours. The pin test is therefore particularly useful for: preliminary screening; rapid selection; comparisons within an apiary. A definitive genetic assessment should draw on other evidence as well. 10. Freeze-killed brood test The freeze-killed brood test (FKB) is easier to standardise. A patch of brood is frozen and then returned to the colony. Observations determine the percentage of cells from which the colony has removed the brood. Facchini et al. compared the conventional FKB method with a shortened variant, FKB* [11]. In 2016, the methods were compared in 25 colonies. In the subsequent breeding programme, 56 colonies were phenotyped in 2017 and 95 in 2018, with two records per colony [11]. The correlation between the colony effects for the two methods was: r = 0.93 Estimated heritability for a single record was: h² = 0.23 and rose to the following value when two records were averaged: h² = 0.37.[11] The practical implication is: repeating the test improves the reliability of genetic evaluation Professional breeding programmes should therefore preferably use two HYG assessments. 11. What heritability of 23% or 37% actually means A common misinterpretation is: “A trait with h² = 0.37 is transmitted at a rate of 37%.” In narrow-sense heritability, h² = Vₐ/Vₚ. It represents the proportion of phenotypic variance attributable to additive genetic variance in the population and experimental conditions considered. It describes variation across the population. The expected response to selection can be approximated by R = h²S, where S is the selection differential. Selecting individuals well above the population mean can therefore improve the average genetic merit of the next generation when the trait has substantial heritability. 12. Heritability of economically important traits A reference for commercial beekeeping is the Canadian breeding programme of Maucourt et al., which covered 604 colonies across eight generations [2]. The reported estimates were: Trait Estimated h² Infestation by Varroa 0.44 ± 0.56 Spring development 0.30 ± 0.14 Honey production 0.20 ± 0.13 Hygienic behaviour 0.18 ± 0.13 Winter food consumption 0.11 ± 0.09 Some estimates carry considerable uncertainty. In particular, the estimate of 0.44 for infestation by Varroa applies to the population and conditions studied. The main contribution of the study was to show that: the traits can respond to genetic selection; they can be selected simultaneously; a multi-trait selection index can be put into practice [2]. 13. Keeping honey yield in the selection index A VSH breeding programme needs to select for productive colonies as well as for survival. In commercial beekeeping, a key economic outcome is honey yield per colony. The Canadian programme estimated the heritability of honey production at approximately: h² = 0.20 ± 0.13.[2] This estimate suggests that honey yield can respond to selection, while remaining strongly affected by: environmental conditions; nectar availability; climate; colony strength; management; the apiary; geographic location. Evaluation should therefore cover several years and, ideally, several environments. 14. Evidence from 366 colonies: the Pol-line case The Pol-line study is particularly relevant because it examined colonies under conditions comparable to commercial beekeeping. O’Shea-Wheller et al. studied 366 colonies: 193 commercial colonies; 173 Pol-line colonies. The colonies were housed in 10-frame Langstroth hives and followed over time [1]. Survival was 59.884% among Pol-line colonies compared with 26.042% among commercial colonies. The hazard of death was significantly lower in the Pol-line colonies. Of particular economic interest, the comparison of honey yields from 141 commercial and 137 Pol-line colonies found no statistically significant difference [1]. For commercial beekeeping, these data offer evidence from a larger and more representative setting than a trial involving a few nucleus colonies. The results support the following conclusion: a population selected for Varroa resistance can maintain commercially competitive honey yields. 15. Evidence from 268 colonies in Langstroth hives Another study, by Kefuss et al., began in 1999 with 268 commercial colonies housed in standard deep Langstroth hives and used for honey production and queen rearing [12]. The colonies came from commercial stock that included A. m. ligustica, A. m. carnica, A. m. caucasica and A. m. mellifera. Acaricide treatment was discontinued, and survival became a selection criterion. After more than two-thirds of the original colonies were lost, the survivors supplied breeding stock for a new population. By 2013, the programme had 519 untreated colonies from the two groups, with very low mite levels [12]. The study shows that it is possible to select a resistant population under commercial conditions. Its scope matters when interpreting the results: selection was based heavily on survival without treatment, and the experiment was not designed to isolate VSH. It therefore provides evidence of overall resistance or tolerance, with the role of specific mechanisms still to be established. 16. Evidence from 604 colonies across eight generations The Canadian programme provides another reference [2]. It included 604 colonies across eight generations. When the population size allowed, each generation comprised about 100 colonies. Each year, around 20 colonies with the best overall performance were selected. Of those: 7–14 supplied maternal breeding stock; around 10 supplied drones [2]. This programme illustrates the transition from selecting on individual phenotypes to breeding at population level. 17. Evidence from 649 colonies: a large sample with variation in colony size Gerdts et al. studied 649 colonies across nine beekeeping operations and 21 apiaries in Australia [13]. The large sample improves the robustness of the estimates. However, colony size ranged from nucleus colonies on about four frames to production colonies with bees covering more than 16 frames. This variation in size needs to be taken into account. Sixteen per cent of colonies met the threshold for strict hygienic behaviour, defined as removal of at least 95% of dead brood [13]. Colonies in breeding programmes were 5.8 times as likely to be highly hygienic, while colonies headed by queens descended from hygienic mothers were 2.2 times as likely [13]. These associations are consistent with a heritable component that can respond to selection. Environmental conditions can also affect how the trait is expressed. 18. What studies with small samples can tell us Studies involving a few colonies can be important for: discovering a mechanism; identifying a candidate gene; developing a method; demonstrating a causal relationship; comparing extreme phenotypes. The difficulty arises when such studies are used to estimate the genetic response of a commercial population. For example, Harbo and Harris used 17 colonies in their study of the mechanism behind SMR, with nine SMR colonies and eight controls [10]. Their experiment helped explain the mechanism. Estimating the frequency of the trait in a commercial population requires other evidence. Studies at larger scales include: 155 colonies in the recapping GWAS [9]; 268 colonies in the commercial selection study by Kefuss et al. [12]; 366 colonies in the Pol-line comparison [1]; 604 colonies in the Canadian programme [2]; 649 colonies in the Australian study [13]. Such studies can give breeders a firmer basis for population-level decisions. Study design also matters: a poorly controlled experiment with 150 colonies may be less informative than an experiment with 40 colonies and a rigorous genetic design. 19. Dadant and Langstroth hives and mini-hives: the question of biological scale For commercial beekeeping, it helps to distinguish among: experimental colonies; nucleus colonies; mini-hives; production colonies. Colony size influences: the amount of brood; the number of nurse bees; nest temperature; the frequency of interactions; resource availability; pressure from Varroa; the expression of social behaviours. A result obtained in a nucleus colony cannot automatically be extrapolated to a production colony in a Dadant-Blatt or Langstroth hive. Trials intended to guide commercial breeding programmes should therefore be conducted primarily on full-size production colonies. The Pol-line and Kefuss studies are relevant in this respect because they used standard Langstroth hives and large populations [1,12]. 20. An important limitation of the freeze-killed brood test The FKB test measures general hygienic behaviour. A colony that removes a frozen pupa quickly may show a different response to mite-infested brood. Spivak and Danka pointed out that removal of artificially killed brood does not always reliably predict resistance to specific pathogens or parasites [14]. In the Australian study, 16% of the 649 colonies tested were highly hygienic, but hygienic behaviour did not significantly predict the presence or severity of chalkbrood [13]. These findings clarify what HYG measures: HYG reflects general social immunity, while VSH is a more specific trait. 21. Annual phenotyping schedule A professional breeding programme should spread testing across the season. For northern and central Italy, one possible schedule is: Period Assessments February–March survival, colony strength, food stores, queen status March–April spring development, gentleness, swarming April–May pin test or FKB test May–June second HYG assessment, development, production June–July VSH, Harbo test, Varroa in brood July–August Varroa population growth, production, colony population August–September infestation of adult bees, Varroa in brood, MNR September–October final honey yield, winter readiness, health status Autumn–winter data analysis and selection of breeding stock Dates should be adjusted to local climate and phenology. The main point to standardise is the biological stage at which the comparison is made. 22. Pin test protocol For each colony: select a comb with capped brood of uniform age; mark out 50–100 cells; pierce each pupa with an entomological pin; record the initial number of cells; photograph the area; check after 12 and 24 hours; record the percentage of cells uncapped and the percentage from which brood was removed. For selective breeding, record the 24-hour result: HYG₂₄ = (cells cleared by 24 h ÷ cells initially treated) × 100 and the earlier measurement as an indicator of removal speed: HYG₁₂ so that colonies reaching the same final result at different rates can be distinguished. 23. FKB protocol Use a standardised patch of brood for the freeze-killed brood test, preferably with at least 100 assessable cells. After freezing: return the section to the colony; photograph it; check after 24 hours; record the percentage of brood removed; repeat the test at another stage of the season. Removal of 95% within 24 hours is one possible threshold. Gerdts et al. assessed removal after 48 hours [13]. 24. Direct VSH test Direct measurement of VSH requires brood infested with Varroa. The general procedure is to: select combs with capped brood; identify cells containing Varroa; record an initial sample; leave the brood in the colony for a defined interval, typically about a week; check which cells have been uncapped or cleared; assess the presence of mites; compare infested and uninfested cells. The key requirement is sufficient parasite pressure. A colony with negligible infestation cannot be classified as highly VSH solely because no mites are found. 25. Harbo test Examination of capped brood to assess Varroa destructor reproduction. Classifying the offspring helps distinguish reproductive from non-reproductive mites The Harbo test assesses the reproduction of Varroa in brood. Capped cells are opened to assess: presence of a foundress mite; presence of eggs; presence of a male; presence of daughters; development of offspring; failure to reproduce. Developmental stages of Varroa destructor The sample should be large enough to contain an adequate number of infested cells. For a professional breeding programme, one proposed target is at least 100 infested cells suitable for assessment, with a larger sample when mites are scarce. A simple count records only: the number of mites found. The reproductive status of the mites also needs to be classified. A colony with few mites, all of which are reproducing, cannot automatically be ranked above a colony with more mites and a very high proportion of non-reproductive mites. 26. Interpreting MNR alongside VSH For each colony, calculate: MNR = (non-reproductive mites ÷ total mites that could be assessed) × 100 alongside: VSH = (infested cells cleared ÷ initially infested cells) × 100 Using both measures helps distinguish: colonies that remove a large amount of infested brood; colonies in which the remaining mites show low reproductive success; colonies with both phenotypes; colonies with low infestation because parasite pressure is low. 27. Varroa on adult bees and in brood Monitoring resistance requires measures beyond VSH. At intervals, record: mites on adult bees; mites in brood; the seasonal trend; the relative growth of the mite population. A single observation tells us little about the trend. The growth rate is more informative: r = ln(Nₜ/N₀) ÷ t where N₀ is the initial infestation level, Nₜ is the level after a defined interval, and t is the duration of that interval. In a breeding programme, a colony that consistently limits the growth of Varroa throughout the season is of greater interest than one with a single very low reading. 28. Environmental effects Environmental conditions strongly influence hygienic behaviour and VSH. Factors to record include: nectar availability; protein availability; temperature; rainfall; time of year; colony strength; amount of brood; pressure from Varroa; concurrent diseases; beekeeping practices. In the large Australian study, nectar availability influenced the expression of hygienic behaviour [13]. For a fair genetic comparison, assess colonies as far as possible: in the same apiary; at the same time; at comparable strength; under comparable feeding conditions. 29. A selection index for commercial beekeeping A single-trait index would be: I = VSH. A multi-trait index could instead take the following form: I = w₁VSH + w₂M + w₃D + w₄S + w₅H + w₆SW + w₇HYG where: VSH = hygienic response to brood infested by Varroa; M = honey yield; D = gentleness; S = spring development; H = overwintering; SW = low swarming tendency; HYG = general hygienic behaviour. One possible set of starting weights is: Trait Illustrative weight VSH, MNR and infestation by Varroa 30% Honey production 25% Gentleness and calmness 15% Spring development 10% Overwintering and longevity 10% HYG 5% Low swarming tendency 5% Adjust the weights to reflect the operation's actual costs and returns. 30. Keeping gentleness as a breeding criterion Gentleness has economic value in commercial beekeeping. A defensive colony increases: handling time; use of smoke; occupational risk; stress for workers; management difficulty; indirect costs. A highly defensive colony with exceptional VSH should therefore be assessed against a mandatory minimum standard for gentleness before it is used for breeding. The same principle applies to swarming tendency. 31. Swarming tendency as an exclusion criterion A low tendency to swarm is particularly important in commercial beekeeping. A simple record of whether the colony swarmed gives only part of the picture. It is preferable to record: number of queen cells; date when they first appear; number of interventions required; number of swarms; frequency of swarm cells; associated loss of production. A colony that repeatedly needs swarm control is less economical to manage, even if it has excellent VSH. 32. Measuring honey yield directly Selection should use kilograms of honey produced per colony alongside indirect measures such as: number of occupied frames; brood area; apparent colony strength. Colony strength is an intermediate trait. Honey yield is the economic outcome. Production should therefore be measured over at least the main nectar flows. A commercial breeding programme needs to distribute selection pressure across a range of biological and economic traits. These include general hygienic behaviour and VSH, reduced mite reproduction, colony development, honey yield, gentleness, swarming tendency and overwintering ability. The aim is a stable genetic balance between parasite resistance and overall value to beekeepers. Multi-trait selection in Apis mellifera Breeding for Varroa resistance should include the principal traits of economic interest. VSH, general hygienic behaviour, reduced mite reproduction and survival are the main resistance-related traits. Honey yield, colony development, gentleness, low swarming tendency and overwintering ability determine the overall value of the line to beekeepers. Selection aims to improve the combination of traits over successive generations. 33. A five-year breeding plan for Varroa-resistant bees suited to commercial beekeeping Year 1 – Baseline assessment Suggested population: 100–200 colonies. Preferred conditions: standard Dadant-Blatt or Langstroth hives; individually identified queens; initial pedigree records; comparable apiaries; uniform management. The first year is for collecting a phenotypic baseline before applying strong selection pressure. Record the following for each colony: overwintering; colony strength; brood; honey yield; gentleness; swarming tendency; HYG; Varroa infestation; VSH or Harbo test results when parasite pressure permits. Year 2 – Initial selection The breeding pool can be narrowed to 20–30 candidate maternal colonies and 20–40 drone-producing colonies. Selection should proceed in two stages. First screen Exclude colonies that are: highly defensive; highly prone to swarming; low in productivity; diseased; weak; poor at overwintering. Second screen Among the remaining colonies, select for: high HYG scores; high VSH scores; high MNR; slow population growth of Varroa. This prevents a colony with poor commercial performance from entering the programme on the strength of a single test. Years 2–3 – Instrumental insemination Instrumental insemination of an Apis mellifera queen. Controlling the paternal contribution makes planned crosses possible in a breeding programme Instrumental insemination allows control of the paternal contribution. There are two main approaches. Single-drone insemination Semen comes from one drone. Advantages: precise pedigree records; close genetic control; useful for studying segregation; useful for fixing combinations of traits. Disadvantages: risk of inbreeding; strong dependence on how genetically representative the chosen drone is. Multiple-drone insemination Semen comes from several selected drones. Advantages: greater diversity; lower risk of inbreeding; greater colony robustness. For commercial populations, retaining some paternal diversity is generally preferable. Selection of drone-producing colonies Breeding programmes also need to select the paternal lines. Drones should come from colonies with: high VSH scores; high HYG scores; good productivity; gentleness; good health; good survival; low infestation. The Canadian programme provides a precedent: around 20 colonies were selected each year for breeding, some to produce queens and others to produce drones [2]. Year 3 – Progeny testing The focus shifts from the mother to the family. Produce enough daughter queens from each mother to assess the family. The question moves from “How strong is this queen’s VSH?” to “How strong is VSH among her offspring on average, and how stable is the trait?” Expression can decline in subsequent generations. An exceptional mother alone gives limited evidence that the line will remain stable. Years 3–4 – Family selection For each family, calculate: mean VSH score; standard deviation; mean HYG score; mean infestation level; mean yield; mean gentleness score; swarming tendency; overwintering performance. A family with less extreme but more consistent results may have greater breeding value than a family with one exceptional colony. The principle is: family breeding value ≠ best individual phenotype Year 4 – Testing under production conditions Test the best lines in: Dadant-Blatt hives; Langstroth hives; production apiaries; actual nectar flows; migratory beekeeping conditions where relevant. At a minimum, compare: honey yield; colony strength; swarming; gentleness; Varroa infestation; overwintering; mortality; queen longevity. This phase establishes whether the lines have enough commercial value to justify their use in production. Year 5 – Consolidation In the fifth year, the programme should be able to identify: 10–15 principal maternal families; 20–40 paternal families; numerous tested daughter queens. The aim is to build a genetically resistant population that retains sufficient diversity. Genetic diversity is especially important in honey bees because of complementary sex determination, which involves the csd gene. Intense selection among a few lines can raise the risk of inbreeding and reduce overall fitness. 34. The role of natural selection A commercial breeding programme can combine artificial selection with controlled natural selection. Kefuss et al. describe an approach in which survival in the presence of Varroa was used as an initial screen. Surviving colonies were then selected for economic traits as well [12]. This approach can exert strong selection pressure, at the cost of high mortality. Commercial operations may need to limit the initial colony losses. A more conservative strategy uses: Varroa monitoring; VSH testing; MNR; HYG; survival; honey yield; as combined criteria. 35. Selective breeding and acaricide treatment A professional breeding programme should define how to manage heavily infested colonies and distinguish the breeding apiary from the production apiary. Breeding apiaries can use predefined experimental thresholds and authorised protocols. In production apiaries, colony protection and health management take priority. If a candidate colony shows uncontrolled population growth of Varroa, its infestation calls for intervention under the applicable protocol. The purpose of selection is to improve population fitness while limiting avoidable colony losses. 36. Exclusion criteria Exclude a candidate breeding colony if it shows: defensive behaviour incompatible with commercial management; recurrent swarming; low honey yield; poor overwintering; high susceptibility to disease; a markedly irregular brood pattern; rapid population growth of Varroa; abnormal queen behaviour. A high VSH score should not outweigh a serious production or management problem. 37. Suggested selection method A practical approach combines minimum thresholds with a selection index. First screen The colony must meet the minimum resistance criteria: low infestation; slow population growth of Varroa; HYG above a defined threshold; VSH or MNR above a defined threshold. Second stage Among colonies that pass the screen, select for: higher honey yield; greater gentleness; lower swarming tendency; better colony development; better overwintering. In shorthand: breeding stock = minimum resistance standard + highest economic value This approach aligns breeding decisions with the practical needs of commercial beekeeping. 38. Which studies should carry most weight in breeding decisions? Pol-line colonies developed through US breeding programmes for Varroa resistance. Pol-line illustrates selection under commercial beekeeping conditions For a commercial breeding programme, the evidence can be ranked as follows: First tier Studies with: ≥100 colonies; production colonies; standard hives; pedigree records; multiple generations; repeated measurements. Examples include: 604 colonies across eight generations – Maucourt et al.[2] 366 colonies in Langstroth hives – Pol-line.[1] 268 colonies in Langstroth hives – Kefuss et al.[12] 649 colonies – Australian study.[13] 155 colonies – recapping GWAS.[9] Second tier Genetic and mechanistic studies with smaller samples and tightly controlled experimental designs: Tsuruda et al.; Harbo & Harris; Mondet et al.; Oxley et al. Third tier Studies involving: nucleus colonies; mini-hives; <30 colonies; a single season. These studies are mainly exploratory. 39. High heritability estimates from small samples A high estimate of h² can have a large standard error when it comes from a small sample. An estimate of h² = 0.65 from a small experiment may be less reliable than an estimate of h² = 0.20 from hundreds of colonies across several generations. Report the estimate alongside: sample size; standard error; pedigree structure; environment; statistical model. 40. Following performance over time An isolated result gives limited information: VSH in 2026 = 80%. A more useful record would be: VSH in 2026 = 80%; VSH in 2027 = 76%; VSH in daughter colonies = 74%; low autumn Varroa infestation; above-average honey yield; high gentleness. Breeding value is better assessed by examining the consistency of the phenotype over time. The five-year programme should therefore be designed as a longitudinal study. 41. Suggested colony breeding record Assign each colony a permanent identity. Identification colony ID; queen ID; queen’s year of birth; mother; paternal source; apiary; hive. Health Varroa infestation in May; Varroa infestation in July; Varroa infestation in August or September; MNR; VSH; HYG. Production spring honey yield; summer honey yield; total honey yield. Colony biology adult bee population; brood; colony development; overwintering. Behaviour gentleness; calmness; swarming tendency; tendency to rob other colonies. Over time, these records become more informative than individual tests. 42. Final decision model A candidate colony could receive a standardised score from 0 to 100 for each trait. For example: Trait Score VSH 90 MNR 85 HYG 88 Honey yield 92 Gentleness 95 Colony development 90 Overwintering 87 Low swarming tendency 91 The overall index could then be calculated as follows: I = 0.30(VSH) + 0.25(honey yield) + 0.15(gentleness) + 0.10(development) + 0.10(overwintering) + 0.05(HYG) + 0.05(low swarming tendency) It is particularly important to set minimum thresholds. For example: VSH below threshold → exclude; gentleness below threshold → exclude; honey yield below threshold → exclude. This prevents an exceptional result on one trait from masking a serious shortcoming for commercial production. 43. Conclusions The available research supports the conclusion that resistance of Apis mellifera to Varroa destructor is a complex, heritable trait that can respond to selection. VSH is one of several mechanisms involved in overall resistance. The broader biological picture includes: general hygienic behaviour, VSH, MNR or SMR, recapping, grooming, brood dynamics, the colony response and survival. The genetic component is polygenic. QTL identified by Tsuruda et al., Lapidge et al. and Oxley et al. show that behavioural variation is associated with multiple genomic regions [5–7]. Molecular studies of the antennae also suggest that olfaction and the peripheral nervous system play an important role in VSH [8]. Colony social structure also matters. A colony consists of cooperating workers from different patrilines. Breeding programmes therefore need to select both maternal and paternal lines and test the offspring. Heritability estimates need to be interpreted in context. In the Italian study by Facchini et al., estimated heritability was 0.23 for a single HYG measurement and 0.37 when two measurements were averaged [11]. The Canadian programme involving 604 colonies found that infestation by Varroa, spring development, honey yield, winter food consumption and HYG all have a genetic component that can respond to selection [2]. Large-scale studies are especially relevant. In the Pol-line study, which involved 366 colonies in 10-frame Langstroth hives, survival was about 60% compared with 26% in the commercial stock, with no significant difference in honey yield between the surviving groups assessed [1]. Kefuss and colleagues started with 268 commercial colonies in Langstroth hives, and the programme later reached 519 untreated colonies. Their results show that selection under commercial conditions can yield populations with low levels of Varroa [12]. These results are especially relevant to commercial breeding because they extend beyond trials in nucleus colonies or in a few dozen colonies. The main implication concerns which colonies to breed from. A high VSH score is one criterion among several. Select colonies with: adequate VSH; slow population growth of Varroa; high HYG; a high proportion of non-reproductive mites; high honey yield; gentleness; calmness on the comb; low swarming tendency; good spring development; good overwintering; good queen longevity; good overall health. The breeding objective combines: Varroa resistance + production + ease of management + fitness while taking into account: VSH as one component of resistance In commercial beekeeping, VSH is most useful as part of multi-trait selection. A five-year programme starting with 100–200 colonies provides a firmer basis for selection when it includes repeated phenotyping, pedigree records, selection of maternal and paternal families, instrumental insemination, testing of daughter colonies and evaluation under standard production conditions. The ultimate aim is to build a stable, productive, gentle commercial population with progressively greater resistance to Varroa destructor. Final methodological note The heritability estimates reported here describe variation within the populations studied. They depend on the population, pedigree, environment, measurement method, season and statistical model. Operational thresholds for HYG and VSH serve as selection tools and can vary with the protocol. An Italian breeding programme could use estimates from the literature as initial prior information and gradually replace them after three to five generations with genetic parameters estimated from its own population. Keep individual records for each colony and queen, including maternal and paternal lines. The performance of a VSH line is best evaluated over time and across its offspring. Look for slow population growth of Varroa and adequate survival alongside sustained honey yield, gentleness, colony development and consistent productivity. References [1] O’Shea-Wheller, T. A., Rinkevich, F. D., Danka, R. G., Simone-Finstrom, M., et al. (2022). A derived honey bee stock confers resistance to Varroa destructor and associated viral transmission. Scientific Reports, 12, 4852. DOI: 10.1038/s41598-022-08643-w. (PubMed Central (PMC)) [2] Maucourt, S., Fortin, F., Robert, C., & Giovenazzo, P. (2020). Genetic Parameters of Honey Bee Colonies Traits in a Canadian Selection Program. Insects, 11(9), 587. DOI: 10.3390/insects11090587. (PubMed Central (PMC)) [3] Noël, A., Le Conte, Y., & Mondet, F. (2020). Varroa destructor: how does it harm Apis mellifera honey bees and what can be done about it? Emerging Topics in Life Sciences, 4, 45–57. DOI: 10.1042/ETLS20190125. (PubMed Central (PMC)) [4] Mondet, F., Beaurepaire, A., McAfee, A., Locke, B., Alaux, C., Blanchard, S., Danka, B., & Le Conte, Y. (2020). Honey bee survival mechanisms against the parasite Varroa destructor: a systematic review of phenotypic and genomic research efforts. International Journal for Parasitology, 50, 433–447. DOI: 10.1016/j.ijpara.2020.03.005. (PubMed Central (PMC)) [5] Lapidge, K. L., Oldroyd, B. P., & Spivak, M. (2002). Seven suggestive quantitative trait loci influence hygienic behavior of honey bees. Naturwissenschaften, 89, 565–568. DOI: 10.1007/s00114-002-0371-6. [6] Oxley, P. R., Spivak, M., & Oldroyd, B. P. (2010). Six quantitative trait loci influence task thresholds for hygienic behaviour in honeybees (Apis mellifera). Molecular Ecology, 19, 1452–1461. DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-294X.2010.04569.x. [7] Tsuruda, J. M., Harris, J. W., Bourgeois, L., Danka, R. G., & Hunt, G. J. (2012). High-Resolution Linkage Analyses to Identify Genes That Influence Varroa Sensitive Hygiene Behavior in Honey Bees. PLoS ONE, 7(11), e48276. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0048276. (PubMed Central (PMC)) [8] Mondet, F., Alaux, C., Severac, D., Rohmer, M., Mercer, A. R., & Le Conte, Y. (2015). Antennae hold a key to Varroa-sensitive hygiene behaviour in honey bees. Scientific Reports, 5, 10454. DOI: 10.1038/srep10454. (PubMed) [9] Guichard, M., et al. (2022). Two quantitative trait loci are associated with recapping of Varroa destructor-infested brood cells in Apis mellifera mellifera. Animal Genetics, 53, 156–160. DOI: 10.1111/age.13150. Genome-wide association study of 155 colonies. (PubMed) [10] Harbo, J. R., & Harris, J. W. (2005). Suppressed mite reproduction explained by the behaviour of adult bees. Journal of Apicultural Research, 44(1), 21–23. DOI: 10.1080/00218839.2005.11101141. (ARS USDA) [11] Facchini, E., Bijma, P., Pagnacco, G., Rizzi, R., & Brascamp, E. W. (2019). Hygienic behaviour in honeybees: a comparison of two recording methods and estimation of genetic parameters. Apidologie, 50, 163–172. DOI: 10.1007/s13592-018-0627-6. (Springer Nature) [12] Kefuss, J., Vanpoucke, J., Bolt, M., & Kefuss, C. (2016). Selection for resistance to Varroa destructor under commercial beekeeping conditions. Journal of Apicultural Research, 54(5). DOI: 10.1080/00218839.2016.1160709. (Taylor & Francis Online) [13] Gerdts, J., Dewar, R. L., Simone-Finstrom, M., Edwards, T., & Angove, M. (2018). Hygienic behaviour selection via freeze-killed honey bee brood not associated with chalkbrood resistance in eastern Australia. PLoS ONE. Study of 649 colonies. (PubMed Central (PMC)) [14] Spivak, M., & Danka, R. G. (2021). Perspectives on hygienic behavior in Apis mellifera and other social insects. Apidologie, 52, 1–16. (Springer Nature) [15] Mondet, F., Parejo, M., Meixner, M. D., et al. (2020). Evaluation of Suppressed Mite Reproduction (SMR) Reveals Potential for Varroa Resistance in European Honey Bees (Apis mellifera L.). Insects, 11(9), 595. (PubMed Central (PMC)) [16] Bigio, G., Al Toufailia, H., & Ratnieks, F. L. W. (2014). Honey bee hygienic behaviour does not incur a cost via removal of healthy brood. Journal of Evolutionary Biology, 27, 226–230. DOI: 10.1111/jeb.12288. Author: Davide Simeone Published: 20 August 2026
- Grooming against Varroa: mandible shape and mite damage in feral honey bees
Annual losses of 30–40% have been reported in managed honey bee colonies (Kulhanek et al. 2017). The ectoparasitic mite Varroa destructor has been a major threat to European honey bees since its introduction into the United States (Akimov et al. 2004; Nazzi and Le Conte 2016). The mite feeds on bee fat body tissue and transmits viruses. Infestation can impair bee development, alter behaviour and shorten lifespan (Ramsey et al. 2019; Wilfert et al. 2016). The Asian honey bee (Apis cerana) is the original host of Varroa mites (Oldroyd 1999).Apis cerana has evolved several defences against Varroa, including grooming, removal of infested brood, other hygienic behaviours and suppression of mite reproduction (Grindrod and Martin 2023; Morfin et al. 2023). Some feral populations of Apis mellifera have also developed mite resistance. Varroa destructor Grooming is one of several behaviours associated with mite resistance. Bees can dislodge mites and may bite them in the process (Arechavaleta-Velasco et al. 2012; Büchler et al. 1992; Diao et al. 2018; Moritz et al. 2007; Peng et al. 1987; Ruttner and Hanel 1992; Seeley 2007; Morfin et al. 2020; Smith et al. 2021). Feral honey bees in Kentucky have been identified as Apis mellifera mellifera (Carpenter and Harpur 2021). A study of Africanised honey bees reported mite removal at a rate of 38.5% (Moretto et al. 1991). Puerto Rican gentle Africanised honey bees (gAHB, hybrids with A. m. scutellata ancestry) have also shown mite resistance in the context of local evolution (Avalos et al. 2017). X-ray microcomputed tomography (micro-CT or µCT) produces three-dimensional images at fine spatial resolution with relatively little sample preparation (Palci et al. 2016). It has been used to study the anatomy and evolution of bees, ants and other insects (Coty et al. 2014; Larabee et al. 2017; Li et al. 2011; Smith et al. 2021). The authors used micro-CT to scan bee mandibles and compare their three-dimensional measurements. Researchers traditionally assessed mite damage associated with grooming by examining specimens under a microscope (Grindrod and Martin 2023). Mobile apps and image classification may make this assessment easier. A convolutional neural network (CNN) can learn visual features with relatively little manual preprocessing (Jogin et al. 2018). Transfer learning can adapt a pretrained network to classify new objects using a relatively small dataset (Shin et al. 2016). The authors expected feral colonies in Ohio (A. m. ligustica) and Kentucky (A. m. mellifera) to show more mite-biting behaviour than commercial colonies. They compared mandible morphology in selected A. m. ligustica populations, gentle Africanised hybrids and commercial bees. They also developed a mobile app that uses CNNs to identify damaged mites in images. Results Grooming behaviour in feral Apis mellifera Regression analysis found no significant difference associated with the total number of mites collected per colony. The authors compared the three populations using the proportion of damaged mites in each colony as an indicator of mite-biting behaviour. They collected 2,518 mites from 58 commercial colonies and 4,981 from 97 feral colonies. Kentucky feral A. m. mellifera colonies had a proportion of damaged mites about 34% higher than that of commercial colonies.Ohio feral A. m. ligustica colonies had a 49% higher proportion of damaged mites than commercial colonies. Both the Ohio and Kentucky feral groups showed evidence of grooming. Population was a significant predictor of the proportion of damaged mites. The authors used ordinary least-squares regression to test whether the sampling year predicted grooming. They sampled 20, 28, 57 and 50 colonies in 2020, 2021, 2022 and 2023, respectively. Year was not a significant predictor. Micro-CT image of the inner surface of a honey bee mandible Comparison of mandibles in Apis mellifera and Apis cerana The authors measured four features of worker mandibles: long edge, short edge, height and the span of the spined area. The groups were A. cerana, gentle Africanised hybrids with A. m. scutellata ancestry, feral Ohio A. m. ligustica and commercial A. m. ligustica package bees. The long and short edges were significantly longer in the commercial bees than in the other three groups. Mandible height was greatest in A. cerana and lowest in feral Ohio A. m. ligustica. The span of the spined area did not differ significantly among groups. Conclusions The proportion of damaged mites was higher in feral Ohio A. m. ligustica and Kentucky A. m. mellifera colonies than in commercial colonies, consistent with more mite-biting during grooming. The authors also identified differences in mandible shape among A. cerana, feral Ohio A. m. ligustica, Puerto Rican gentle Africanised hybrids and commercial A. m. ligustica. They developed a mobile application that uses machine learning to identify damaged mites in images. The total number of mites collected did not differ significantly between commercial and feral colonies, suggesting a similar distribution of mite counts across the colonies sampled. Grooming is one of several traits that may help reduce infestation in adult bees. Its effectiveness and heritability have been debated (Büchler 2010). More recent studies reported survival in colonies with high grooming activity even at infestation levels similar to those of control colonies (Nganso et al. 2017; Smith et al. 2021). Infestation also depends on factors such as genetic differences among mites, pathogens transmitted by Varroa and other interactions between host and parasite (Mondet et al. 2020; Le Conte et al. 2020; Moro et al. 2021; Zheng et al. 2023). Further research could use population genetics to determine whether different Varroa lineages are present in the colonies as selection for grooming, one component of mite resistance, continues.Earlier research showed that workers can amputate the legs of Varroa mites (Ruttner and Hanel 1992). Ruttner and Hanel (1992) described visible white tissue at the cut ends of legs on damaged mites collected alive or dead. Counting damaged mites revealed a significantly higher proportion in the feral Ohio and Kentucky colonies than in commercial colonies. The finding supports earlier evidence that grooming or mite-biting is associated with mite resistance in feral colonies (Russo et al. 2020; Smith et al. 2021).The proportions of damaged mites in feral Kentucky and Ohio colonies were 34% and 49% higher, respectively, than in commercial colonies. Grooming that involves removing and biting parasitic mites has been reported since 1929 (Haydak 1929; Frisch 1967; Smith et al. 2021). The findings support considering grooming alongside other traits in breeding programmes for mite resistance (Danka et al. 2011; Rinderer et al. 2010; Spivak 1996). Van Alphen and Fernhout (2020) also reported high levels of grooming in feral colonies in Europe and South America. Worker bees use their mandibles for several tasks, including defence against parasites (Papachristoforou et al. 2012; Ruttner and Hanel 1992). The authors found differences in the long edge, short edge and height among the studied populations of A. cerana and A. mellifera. Earlier scanning electron microscopy images of amputated mite legs led researchers to suggest that the two cutting edges of the mandible act like scissor blades (Ruttner and Hanel 1992). The cutting edges in feral and gentle Africanised bees tended to resemble those of A. cerana and were significantly shorter than those of commercial bees. The authors suggest that shorter edges might improve flexibility or efficiency when biting mites. The comparison does not establish that these differences evolved in response to Varroa. The authors propose that natural selection since the introduction of Varroa in 1987 may have favoured more efficient mite removal in feral colonies (Hunt et al. 2016; Smith et al. 2021). This is consistent with earlier work reporting differences in the long cutting edge in Indiana colonies selected for mite-biting (Smith et al. 2021). A. cerana is generally slightly smaller than A. mellifera (Ruttner and Hanel 1992; Yue et al. 2018). In this study, the long and short cutting edges of feral bees were shorter than those of commercial bees and longer than or similar to those of A. cerana. Earlier work also found that heatwaves and temperature changes can influence worker body size (Poot-Báez et al. 2020). Further comparisons of mandible size in feral and commercial colonies are needed. This study used the proportion of damaged mites as an indirect measure of grooming and assumed that the damage was caused by workers in the colony. Earlier work supports using damaged mites as an indicator of grooming (Büchler et al. 1992; Ruttner and Hanel 1992). Direct observations of bees grooming live mites are difficult to obtain in colonies (Peng et al. 1987). Automated systems have been used to analyse aggressive behaviour in insects (Li-Byarlay et al. 2014; Lim et al. 2014). The authors call for field observations of bee grooming. Earlier work described a camera and machine-learning system for detecting Varroa in bee colonies (Bilik et al. 2024). In this study, the authors developed a CNN-based application to identify mite damage in images. It could reduce the time needed to assess damage, and a future version could run in the cloud. Overall, the study found a higher proportion of damaged mites in feral A. m. ligustica and A. m. mellifera colonies than in commercial colonies, consistent with more mite-biting during grooming. The researchers found differences in the long edge, short edge and height of worker mandibles in their comparisons involving gentle Africanised hybrids and feral Ohio A. m. ligustica. They also developed a mobile app that uses a convolutional neural network to identify damage to mites. The findings help characterise grooming in feral colonies and point to questions for future research and breeding. Apidologie (2025) © The Author(s), 2024 · Hongmei Li-Byarlay (Department of Agricultural and Life Sciences, Central State University, Wilberforce, OH 45384, USA) Kaila Young (Department of Agricultural and Life Sciences, Central State University, Wilberforce, OH 45384, USA) Xaryn Cleare (Department of Agricultural and Life Sciences, Central State University, Wilberforce, OH 45384, USA) Deng Cao (Department of Computer Science and Mathematics, Central State University, Wilberforce, OH 45384, USA) Shudong Luo (Institute of Apicultural Research, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Beijing 102600, China) Full article https://doi.org/10.1007/s13592-024-01126-z
- Factors that affect heat resilience in honey bee drones and their sperm
Global warming Climate change is expected to make heatwaves more frequent and severe, threatening fertility in many animals, including insects. Temperatures within the range that can occur during summer heatwaves (35–45 °C) can reduce fertility in red flour beetles (Tribolium castaneum), fruit flies (Drosophila spp.), bumble bees (Bombus spp.), oriental fruit moths (Grapholita molesta), parasitoid wasps (Anisopteromalus calandrae and Aphidius avenae) and honey bees (Apis mellifera). Heat stress affects many insects, but the possible consequences for honey bees are especially important because of their widespread use in crop pollination. Honey bees tolerate a wide range of climates and have native populations in Africa, Asia and Europe. However, queens and drones are susceptible to heat-related loss of fertility, including reduced sperm viability. Queens can survive heat stress while the viability of sperm stored in their spermatheca declines. Previous experiments reported losses after exposure above 38 °C for more than two hours. Heat exposure can also kill sperm in drones. These losses cannot readily be reversed. Queens mate during a short period early in life and do not replenish their sperm reserves later. Drones produce sperm during development rather than adulthood. Although drones and queens have similar body masses, drones are more susceptible to heat-related mortality. Honey bee colonies can maintain stable brood nest temperatures, but few studies have measured temperature fluctuations inside colonies during heatwaves. In one California study, temperatures inside colonies exceeded 42 °C when ambient temperatures reached 45 °C and access to water was limited. Temperatures were particularly high at the edge of the nest, where sexually mature drones tend to gather. Other studies have measured brood nest temperatures as high as 40 °C. Drones might also experience extreme temperatures during bearding, when many bees leave the nest in hot weather and cluster outside, reducing heat production inside. The authors note that this possible exposure has yet to be studied directly. Colony thermoregulation can buffer heat exposure, but drones may still experience heat stress under extreme conditions. Drone honey bees (males) Despite the role of drones in reproduction, little is known about the factors that determine how heat affects their survival and fertility. Two earlier studies found that drones were susceptible to heat-related mortality, but reported different survival rates. McAfee et al. found 50% survival after six hours at 42 °C. Stürup et al. found 23% survival after four hours at the same temperature. Several factors could explain this difference. Drones from different populations may vary in heat tolerance, and traits such as body mass or exposure to other stressors such as infection may also influence survival. In some insect species, heavier individuals are more heat tolerant. The authors had previously found that drone body mass was positively associated with the number of viable spermatozoa in a drone, suggesting greater investment in reproduction. They therefore considered whether heavier drones might produce sperm of higher quality and greater resistance to stress, including heat. Pathogen infections could increase or decrease heat resilience, depending on the pathogen. Disease can directly reduce individual fitness, or immune responses may compete with reproduction for resources, as observed in other insects. A recent correlational study did not support that trade-off in honey bee drones. Because antiviral immunity and the heat-stress response share some mechanisms, the authors also considered whether some viral infections might improve heat tolerance. Although upper thermal tolerance varies relatively little among insects in general, heat tolerance in terrestrial ectotherms tends to decline with increasing latitude, from tropical to temperate climates. Previous research found that Saudi Arabian honey bees (Apis mellifera jemenitica) tolerated heat better than European honey bees (Apis mellifera carnica), consistent with that trend. In Colombia, ancestry analyses found more African ancestry in colonies at warmer, lower elevations and more European ancestry in colonies at cooler, higher elevations. Protein expression patterns in worker honey bees sampled along a latitudinal gradient also show evidence of local climatic adaptation. Whether these patterns extend to reproductive individuals and other populations remains to be tested. Knowing how different lineages respond could help predict their performance as the climate changes. A warmer climate may also affect interactions with pathogens. Heat shock proteins (HSPs) are a conserved group of proteins whose expression generally increases with heat exposure. They help limit protein misfolding and aggregation, and evidence indicates they also contribute to antiviral immunity in honey bees and other insects. Heat exposure and viral infection may therefore interact in honey bee physiology. McMenamin et al. found that heat exposure and experimental viral inoculation each increased HSP expression. Exposing bees to heat shortly after infection also improved viral clearance. The authors considered whether the reverse might occur, with an earlier infection increasing heat tolerance in drones or their sperm through the dual roles of HSPs. Neither possibility had been tested in drones, which are disproportionately exposed to viruses because Varroa destructor, an important virus vector, preferentially parasitises drone brood. Little is known about how viral infections affect drone fertility or how infection and heat interact. Historical records show that the number of heatwave days increased most in tropical regions, but temperate regions can also experience extremes. During the 25 June to 1 July 2021 heatwave in western Canada and the Pacific Northwest, temperatures reached 49.6 °C and local beekeepers reported adverse effects, including colony deaths. Beekeepers in high-latitude temperate regions may therefore need heat-management practices they did not previously use. Measures such as year-round hive insulation or shade may help buffer shorter periods of heat exposure. If managing hive temperatures becomes ineffective or impractical, selecting and breeding for heat resilience could contribute to an integrated response. This first requires identifying how heat resilience relates to population origin and other factors in existing stocks. Southern California was less affected by the 2021 heatwave, but it too has experienced a shift towards more extreme temperatures. The study describes a shift from historically semi-arid conditions (Köppen BSk) towards a hot, dry climate more like BWh. Heatwaves have become more frequent in Southern California since 1950. During the 5–7 September 2020 heatwave in Riverside County, daytime highs reached 47 °C. Genetic analyses found about 38% African ancestry in unmanaged honey bees in Southern California. Given this ancestry and repeated exposure to intense heat, the authors hypothesised that this population might show adaptations to heat stress. Drone after ejaculation. High temperatures can trigger involuntary eversion of the endophallus and death. The study examined factors that affect heat resilience in honey bee drones and their sperm. The researchers tested how population origin and body mass related to drone survival and sperm viability after heat exposure. They also tested the effect of viral infection acquired in adulthood on sperm heat resilience. First, the researchers recorded adult body mass and survival after four hours at 42 °C. In a separate experiment, they compared survival in drones from Southern and Northern California to explore possible local adaptation. Southern California is drier and experiences more extreme maximum temperatures. Finally, they used in vitro assays to examine relationships among body mass, viral inoculation and heat exposure, testing sperm extracted from drones at different temperatures and exposure durations. The authors hypothesised that 1) heat resilience in drones and their sperm would reflect local climates at their populations of origin, with Southern California drones expected to be more heat tolerant than Northern California drones, 2) heavier drones would be more likely to survive a heat challenge and would produce more heat-tolerant sperm, and 3) viral infection would improve sperm heat resilience because the heat-shock response and antiviral gene expression interact. Materials and methods: Read the original article Conclusions To understand what contributes to heat resilience in honey bee drones and to their reproductive potential, assessed through sperm viability, the authors examined population origin, body mass and viral infection in a series of experiments. The main findings were as follows. 1) Heavier drones were more likely to survive acute heat exposure. 2) Sperm heat resilience varied widely among drones from different populations within British Columbia. 3) Southern California drones were more likely to survive heat exposure than drones from Northern California. 4) Sperm from heavier drones was no more heat tolerant than sperm from lighter drones. 5) Experimental viral infection in adulthood reduced sperm heat resilience. The drone survival tests used four hours at 42 °C, conditions that drones might encounter inside or outside hives during extreme heat. Direct field data on drone exposure during heatwaves are scarce. In vitro tests of sperm from British Columbia drones used the same temperature and duration. The broader in vitro temperature and exposure-duration series and the viral infection experiments also used temperatures that may be outside the biologically relevant range. Exposure to 60 °C, for instance, is unlikely in nature. Spermatozoa from honey bee drones These experiments were designed in part to identify the limits within which sperm remain viable and to characterise their responses under extreme conditions. Future work could measure the conditions drones experience in the field, including their internal body temperatures, and use those data to guide laboratory experiments. The higher survival of heavier drones agrees with findings in some other insects, including males of the squash bee Xenoglossa pruinosa. Other studies have found no relationship between size or mass and heat resilience, measured as the critical thermal maximum (CTmax), within or across insect species. These species-specific results suggest that other factors also contribute to heat resilience. Larger individuals take longer to heat up, so heating time may matter more than cooling capacity during short exposures. This alone does not explain why many species show no relationship between CTmax and body size. Water supports hydration at both the colony and individual level, including in drones. The researchers measured wet body mass, which depends on hydration. Body size is a separate measure.Hydration can influence heat resilience. Better-hydrated individuals may have a higher specific heat capacity and a greater capacity for evaporative cooling.Larger individuals have a lower surface-area-to-volume ratio, which can limit cooling. Studying how hydration and body size interact could help explain why the relationship between size and heat tolerance varies among species. Some water may have evaporated between a drone’s death and weighing, lowering its measured mass independently of heat resilience. The authors considered this effect likely to be small because most deaths occurred near the end of the four-hour exposure, when all drones were weighed. Southern California drones survived the heat challenge more often than Northern California drones, as predicted. Southern California colonies tend to have more African ancestry than colonies in Northern California, which lies outside the hybrid zone. The authors hypothesise that the warmer southern climate and earlier selection in warm environments could have favoured heat resilience. The Southern California colonies in the experiment had feral origins or had bred with the local population for multiple generations. The observed difference reflected both a modest increase in heat tolerance and unexpectedly low survival in the control group, so the authors could not attribute it to ancestry alone. Illustration of a sperm cell approaching an egg Larger control groups and tests for concurrent conditions, such as infections, after heat exposure could help explain this pattern. Comparable sperm viability data were unavailable for the California groups and for survivors of different genetic origins. The authors did compare sperm from different sources within British Columbia and found wide variation in heat responses. Beekeepers may have assessed drone age differently, but the range of responses in the University of British Columbia colonies, where age was controlled, resembled the range across other sources in the province. The researchers then examined possible interactions with viral infection for three reasons. First, drones naturally infected with deformed wing virus type B (DWV-B) had higher sperm viability than drones without a detected DWV-B infection (figure S2 in file S1). Second, earlier work had linked at least one heat shock protein to higher viability of stored sperm. Third, McMenamin et al. had found an antiviral effect of heat exposure. The authors hypothesised that heat shock proteins could help explain these observations by contributing to both antiviral responses and protection against other stressors. They initially considered whether virus-induced heat shock proteins might protect sperm from subsequent heat stress. When they experimentally infected adult drones and then exposed their sperm to heat, they found the opposite. Sperm from infected drones was less heat resilient than sperm from controls. This could reflect a trade-off between sperm maintenance and immunity or a direct effect of infection on sperm quality. The apparent discrepancy with the positive association observed for natural infection remains unresolved. Possible explanations include how long the drones had been infected before sampling, differences between Israeli acute paralysis virus (IAPV) and DWV-B, and whether infection occurred before, during or after spermatogenesis. Competition for cellular resources is another possibility. Overall, the experimental data suggest that IAPV infection can exacerbate the loss of drone sperm viability caused by heat. This matters because Varroa destructor preferentially parasitises drone brood and is an important vector of bee viruses. The relatively small effect of infection acquired in adulthood could account for only a small share of the variation in sperm heat resilience observed among sources in British Columbia. Other factors probably contribute to sperm heat resilience. Genotype is one possibility, but the study did not include genetic tests that could distinguish genetic differences from differences in environment or management. In Drosophila fruit flies, the upper thermal limits of male fertility predict species distributions better than CTmax, suggesting that fertility at high temperatures can be subject to strong selection. The wide geographical range of honey bees may allow more variation in this trait than in other insects. Alternatively, colony thermoregulation may buffer sperm from selection imposed by heat, allowing more variation among individuals. Understanding the sources of variation in drone fertility remains important as beekeeping regions that historically experienced little extreme heat face hotter conditions. Published 7 February 2025 · PLOS ONE · DOI 10.1371/journal.pone.0317672 · Adapted under CC BY Authors Alison McAfee 1,2; Bradley N. Metz 2; Patrick Connor 2; Keana Du 2; Christopher W. Allen 3; Luis A. Frausto 3,4; Mark P. Swenson 3,4; Kylah S. Phillips 3,5; Madison Julien 3; Zoe Rempel 6; Robert W. Currie 6; Boris Baer 3; David R. Tarpy 2; Leonard J. Foster 1 1 Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Michael Smith Laboratories, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada; 2 Department of Applied Ecology, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, North Carolina, United States of America; 3 Center for Integrative Bee Research (CIBER), Department of Entomology, University of California Riverside, Riverside, California, United States of America; 4 Department of Microbiology & Plant Pathology, University of California Riverside, Riverside, California, United States of America; 5 Department of Molecular, Cell & Systems Biology, University of California Riverside, Riverside, California, United States of America; 6 Department of Entomology, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada
- What is colony depopulation, and why does it have multiple causes?
Understanding colony depopulation Colony depopulation is a decline in the adult bee population. Colony Collapse Disorder (CCD) is a more specific syndrome involving rapid loss of adult workers, often leaving the queen, brood and food stores with too few bees to sustain the colony. Depopulation can involve interacting pressures such as Varroa destructor, associated viruses, Nosema infections, acute and sublethal pesticide exposure, hornet predation, heat and nutritional stress. No single causal agent consistently explained the CCD cases in the study by vanEngelsdorp et al. (2009). Management practices such as brood interruption or late splits can also change colony demography. Poor timing can add pressure when the colony is preparing for winter. Some combinations of stressors can act synergistically and increase risk disproportionately. The effect depends on the stressors and conditions. [vanEngelsdorp & Meixner 2010] [De Miranda & Genersch 2010] [Goulson et al. 2015] Nosema biology, effects and interactions Nosema ceranae, now common in many regions, and N. apis are microsporidia that infect the midgut epithelium of adult bees. Infection can alter nutrient use and metabolism and shorten lifespan. It can also affect nurse physiology and the ability to support brood. Changes in orientation, drift or a decline in forager numbers may occur, although these observations alone do not establish infection. Additional stressors can worsen outcomes. Varroa and associated viruses can burden host defences. Some sublethal pesticide exposures have increased susceptibility to Nosema or spore counts in experiments. Prolonged heat and protein shortage can add physiological pressure, with outcomes varying by conditions. Nosema can contribute to depopulation when colonies face other stresses. [Higes et al. 2008] [Mayack & Naug 2009] [Goblirsch et al. 2013] [Doublet et al. 2015] [Pettis et al. 2012] [Martín‑Hernández et al. 2009] Varroa amplifies risk, and timing matters Mite pressure can rise in late summer as the replacement of adult bees slows, increasing the risk of collapse if infestation is left unmanaged Varroa destructor damages developing and adult bees by feeding on host tissues, particularly the fat body in adult bees. It also transmits viruses, especially deformed wing virus (DWV). Parasitism and viral infection can impair the physiology and longevity of winter bees, whose fat-body reserves and vitellogenin help support overwintering. Timing matters because Varroa should be brought below the locally appropriate intervention threshold before winter bees are reared. In the conditions described here, that means planning and acting from mid-July so the nurses that will rear winter bees develop under lower parasite pressure. The timing should follow local brood dynamics and measured infestation. Late treatment can reduce mites, but it cannot reverse physiological damage already sustained by developing winter bees. [Ramsey et al. 2019] [van Dooremalen et al. 2012] [Rosenkranz et al. 2010] [Di Prisco et al. 2013] [Medrzycki et al. 2010] [Mattila & Otis 2007] Pesticides and predation reduce bee numbers and disrupt colony activity Acute poisoning can be accompanied by large numbers of dead bees around the hive. Sublethal effects can be harder to detect. Depending on the substance and exposure, they can affect orientation, feeding or the microbiota. In combination with other pressures, they can reduce forager survival. Hornet predation can suppress departures, increase entrance defence and alter the colony’s energy balance. Small colonies, recently divided colonies and those undergoing brood interruption may be especially vulnerable when the workforce is needed to rear winter bees. Coordination with growers, suitable entrances and physical protection where effective can reduce exposure or give bees more opportunities to forage. [Godfray et al. 2014] [Pettis et al. 2012] [Monceau et al. 2014] Extreme heat and hive microclimate During heatwaves more bees may fan or collect water, leaving fewer to forage. Brood at the edges of the nest may face dehydration. Prolonged heat can add physiological stress, and the effects on gut health and infection risk depend on conditions. In small colonies, nuclei or colonies undergoing brood interruption, diverting workers to cooling can slow late-summer recovery and increase the risk of depopulation. Shade, suitable insulation, ventilation adapted to the hive and nearby shaded water can help manage the microclimate. [Human et al. 2006] [Martín‑Hernández et al. 2009] How interacting pressures can start a downward spiral One possible sequence starts when brood interruption or a late split creates a gap in worker replacement. Heat can divert bees to ventilation and water collection and reduce pollen foraging. Residual Varroa and viral pressure can shorten adult lifespan, while Nosema infection may further impair workers already under stress. Hornet predation and possible sublethal pesticide exposure can further reduce flight activity or impair orientation. Even with a queen and stores, a colony may then struggle to cover and rear its brood. As worker numbers decline, recovery becomes harder. Studies of multiple stressors show that their combined effects can be nonlinear under some conditions. [Goulson et al. 2015] [vanEngelsdorp & Meixner 2010] Winter bees and why preparation can begin in July Winter bees have greater fat-body reserves, more vitellogenin and a longer lifespan. They maintain thermoregulation and help restart brood rearing near the end of winter. Their development depends partly on the nurses that rear them. Parasitism, viruses, Nosema, heat and inadequate protein can undermine this workforce and the developing cohort. In many temperate areas winter bees are raised from late summer into autumn. The planning window should precede that transition. In the conditions discussed here, mid-July is a practical starting point for monitoring parasite pressure, protein supply and hive microclimate. Care for the workers that will rear winter bees is part of protecting the winter cohort itself. [Amdam et al. 2003] [Seehuus et al. 2006] [Mattila & Otis 2007] [Genersch 2010] [Medrzycki et al. 2010] Management measures Use regular, standardised Varroa counts before and after intervention to establish whether infestation has fallen below the relevant threshold in time. Brood interruption can improve the effectiveness of appropriately selected treatments against exposed mites when capped brood is absent. Plan the intervention around colony strength, season and the authorised product instructions. Provide appropriate protein and, if needed, suitable low-HMF syrup as an energy source. Arrange access to shaded water and adequate ventilation during hot weeks. A sudden forager decline, uneven brood or unusual food consumption has several possible causes. Consider diagnostic testing for Nosema. Hygiene measures can include replacing old comb as appropriate, managing moisture and limiting robbing and drift. Inactivated yeasts, beta-glucans, buffered organic acids and plant-derived products may be marketed for nutritional support. Evidence varies by formulation, and their use should follow local rules and label instructions, including restrictions during honey production. When pollen is scarce, a suitable protein supplement with a balanced amino acid profile can support nurses and brood. Coordinate pesticide application times and methods with growers, and provide a reliable water source to limit exposure. Against hornets, match the entrance to colony strength and consider entrance protection where it has worked in comparable conditions. Finally, match population management to the season. Late splits without sufficient stores or parasite control can make colonies more vulnerable. When planning the end of brood interruption, allow enough time for one or more complete brood cycles before winter, according to local conditions and colony strength. [Rosenkranz et al. 2010] [Di Pasquale et al. 2013] [Fries 2010] [Pettis et al. 2012] [Monceau et al. 2014] A working schedule from mid-July to September From the second half of July in the conditions described, prioritise reducing Varroa below the local threshold before the winter cohort is reared. Winter workers typically emerge from late summer into autumn in temperate climates. They differ physiologically from summer workers in their fat reserves, vitellogenin levels and lifespan. They maintain the colony through the cold months and support the first spring brood. Plan a brood interruption or a suitable alternative, and arrange shade, water and nutrition to cover pollen shortages. In August, complete planned interventions, check their effect by counting mites and manage the hive microclimate during heatwaves. Adapt entrances or use physical protection as needed where hornets interfere with flight. In September, check for reinfestation, address weak nuclei and prepare for winter by adjusting insulation, ventilation and stores. This sequence aims to protect the nurses that rear winter bees and leave colonies strong enough to overwinter and resume development. Adapt dates to local forage, climate and colony condition. [Rosenkranz et al. 2010] [Human et al. 2006] [Fries 2010] [Monceau et al. 2014] [Mattila & Otis 2007] Economic implications for beekeeping businesses Protecting the generation that rears winter bees can reduce spring replacement costs. Fewer nuclei may need to be purchased or made, fewer queens replaced and fewer hours spent dealing with losses. Stronger colonies may also be better positioned to use early nectar flows and take on pollination work. For example, an improvement of 10–15% in overwinter survival could materially affect an annual margin. This is an illustrative scenario. The actual outcome depends on baseline losses, costs, production and prices. Healthier, more uniform colonies can also support more stable revenue and commercial reliability. [vanEngelsdorp & Meixner 2010] Conclusion To reduce the risk of depopulation, include the bees that rear winter workers in the management plan. In the conditions described here, the second half of July is an opportunity to act. Bring Varroa below the locally relevant threshold, support protein nutrition, manage heat and hygiene, and reduce pesticide exposure and hornet pressure. An integrated plan timed to colony development can support overwinter survival and production. Practical note: Follow applicable regulations and product labels. Discuss health and treatment decisions with the responsible veterinarian or local bee health adviser. Interactions among stressors vary with climate, forage and management, so use local observations to plan interventions. Main references Genersch 2010; vanEngelsdorp & Meixner 2010; Rosenkranz et al. 2010; Higes et al. 2008; Mayack & Naug 2009; Goblirsch et al. 2013; Doublet et al. 2015; Pettis et al. 2012; Martín‑Hernández et al. 2009; Human et al. 2006; Di Prisco et al. 2013; Medrzycki et al. 2010; Mattila & Otis 2007; Seehuus et al. 2006; De Miranda & Genersch 2010; Goulson et al. 2015, Science. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1255957 Author: Davide Simeone. Published July 2026
- Impact of the Fungicide Tebuconazole on Drone Semen Quality
Successful reproduction depends on more than mating itself. In honey bees, one of the key factors is the quality of drone semen. Low sperm viability can compromise reproduction, a basic issue that underlies the discussions of subspecies and selective breeding that have shaped beekeeping in recent years. Understanding threats to honey bees means recognising the role of drones. Queens depend on drones for fertilisation, and beekeeping depends on the resulting colonies. Collecting drone semen Honey bees are affected by the loss of natural habitats and by some modern agricultural practices. Losses of bees and colonies have been reported worldwide. Contributing factors include changes in seasonal conditions, bee diseases, poor husbandry and chemical pesticides (Gregorc, 2020). The effects of agricultural pesticides on honey bees are receiving increasing attention. Honey bees pollinate orchards (Halder et al., 2019), making agricultural land an important location for beekeepers to place their hives. However, poorly timed or excessive pesticide use can kill honey bees and disrupt biodiversity. Spraying while orchards are in bloom poses a particular risk to bees (Uhl & Brühl, 2019). Tebuconazole (TEB), (RS)-1-(4-chlorophenyl)-4,4-dimethyl-3-(1,2,4-triazol-1-ylmethyl)pentan-3-ol, is a fungicide that inhibits ergosterol biosynthesis in fungi and helps control soilborne and foliar fungal pathogens (Ito et al., 2013). However, previous studies have reported adverse effects of TEB on tissues, including reproductive organs and cells. In a study using human placental trophoblast cell lines, exposure to 10 µM TEB decreased cell proliferation and migration, increased apoptosis and lowered mRNA levels associated with proteases, hormones, angiogenic factors, growth factors and cytokines (Zhou et al., 2016). Exposure to 0.1 µM TEB was reported to inhibit testosterone and oestrogen production in hamster ovarian tissue (Kjærstad et al., 2010), and 10 µM TEB inhibited progesterone synthesis in bovine luteal cells (Atmaca et al., 2018). In bovine testicular cells, 1 µM TEB reportedly increased testosterone secretion while reducing sperm viability (Kabakci et al., 2021). Syngenta systemic triazole fungicide for crops including apple, pear, peach, grapevine and tobacco The study discusses TEB's acute toxicity and reported endocrine effects. EU approval of the active substance for plant protection products has been extended to 31 July 2028 under Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/1421. The reported median lethal dose (LD₅₀) in rats was 1,700 mg/kg (EFSA, 2015). For honey bees, the reported median lethal concentrations were 2,770 mg/L and 1,840 mg/L after two and four days of exposure, respectively. At concentrations 20–30 times lower, TEB reduced the activity of enzymes involved in metabolism, digestion and detoxification and affected expression of genes related to immunity, growth and apoptosis (Cang et al., 2023). Several studies have detected TEB residues in plants and fruit. Exposure during the flowering of apple, pear, cherry and peach trees, which provide nectar and pollen for honey bees, is a potential concern (Fang et al., 2020; Li et al., 2020; Lucini & Molinari, 2009; Mohapatra, 2015; Szarka & Ramanarayanan, 2021). Previous studies have linked pesticide exposure on treated flowers or through contaminated food to acute toxicity or larval mortality (Fine et al., 2017; Yoder et al., 2017). Johnson et al. (2010) reported higher TEB residues in honey bees and lower levels in pollen and honey. Drone semen quality is critical to reproduction. Sperm motility (MOT) is widely used to assess fertilising capacity. After mating, semen initially collects in the queen’s oviducts. A fraction of the sperm migrates to the spermatheca. During egg laying, sperm released from this organ fertilises eggs that can develop into workers. Sperm motility contributes both to sperm storage in the spermatheca and to fertilisation during egg laying (Cobey et al., 2013). Plasma membrane integrity (PMI) and mitochondrial membrane potential (MMP) are also important measures of semen quality. PMI indicates cell viability through selective membrane permeability, while MMP reflects mitochondrial function, which is involved in cellular ATP synthesis (Kaya & Uysal, 2023).Poor drone semen quality can compromise the continuity of a honey bee colony. Environmental contaminants can affect semen quality. Although TEB has reported adverse effects on reproduction in various animals and in human cell models, its consequences for drone semen quality were unclear (Kabakci et al., 2021; Taxvig et al., 2007; Yan et al., 2023; Zhou et al., 2016). The study therefore investigated how the concentration and duration of in vitro TEB exposure affected drone sperm MOT, PMI and MMP. Drones came from the Beekeeping Research Centre at Kırıkkale University. Semen was collected in May and June, when mature drones are most abundant in this continental climate. The authors used six colonies of similar strength with queens of the same age and collected 100 µL of semen in total with a Schley instrumental insemination device. They tested 0, 1, 10, 100 and 1,000 µM TEB at 33 °C, measuring semen quality at the start and after 24 hours of incubation (Cobey et al., 2013). All experiments were repeated at least six times. Plasma membrane integrity of drone sperm After 24 hours of incubation, the highest TEB concentration (1,000 µM) significantly reduced sperm MOT, PMI and MMP (p < 0.05) compared with the other concentrations (Figure 4). The pattern of effects varied by concentration and exposure time. At 1,000 µM, MOT and PMI were already lower at the initial measurement (Figure 1), and MMP also fell after 24 hours (Figure 2). Mitochondrial membrane potential of drone sperm Other in vitro and in vivo studies have reported reproductive effects of triazole fungicides, including TEB, in different species. In bovine testicular cells and semen, 1 µM TEB increased testosterone production by Leydig cells and reduced sperm viability (Kabakci et al., 2021). Effects on bull sperm were observed at a lower concentration than in this drone semen experiment. Differences in sperm structure and longevity may play a role. Under the storage conditions cited by the authors, drone sperm remained viable at room temperature for about six weeks and bull sperm for about two to three days (Burley et al., 2008; De Pauw et al., 2003). Oral TEB exposure during pregnancy in rats was associated with feminisation of male offspring and altered testosterone and progesterone production (Taxvig et al., 2007). TEB exposure in zebrafish impaired testicular development and reduced sperm motility (Yan et al., 2023). Honey bees in the field can be exposed to multiple pesticides, including TEB. Research on the effects of pesticide exposure on honey bee colonies and reproductive performance remains limited.In a study on drones, oral exposure to 200 ppb imidacloprid reduced sperm motility and affected MMP, while PMI remained unchanged (Ciereszko et al., 2017).In another study, residues of amitraz, fluvalinate and coumaphos in beeswax used to rear honey bees reduced drone sperm viability by 5–20% (Fisher & Rangel, 2018). Kairo et al. (2016) found that fipronil exposure reduced PMI and ATP levels in drone sperm compared with controls (Kairo et al., 2016). Similarly, drones exposed to neonicotinoids showed a 20% decrease in sperm PMI compared with the control group (Straub et al., 2021). Few studies have examined pesticide effects on drone semen in vitro. The available studies reported changes in sperm motility, plasma membrane integrity and/or ATP content after exposure to selected pesticides (Abdelkader et al., 2015; Inouri-Iskounen et al., 2020). BASF broad-spectrum triazole fungicide The authors describe this as the first in vitro study of the effects of tebuconazole on drone semen quality. Exposure to 1,000 µM reduced MOT and PMI at both measurement times and MMP after 24 hours. At concentrations from 0 to 100 µM, the experiment detected no statistically significant differences in these measures.Sperm motility is an important measure of reproductive quality. It declined at both measurement times in the 1,000 µM TEB group. Loss of plasma membrane integrity can damage cells and reduce sperm motility. Several studies have reported a correlation between motility and PMI (Ahmad et al., 2014; Fraser et al., 2001; Varisli et al., 2009). Sperm movement requires a continuous supply of energy. ATP provides energy for motility, and mitochondria contribute to its production (Abdelkader et al., 2015).MMP decreased significantly after 24 hours of exposure to 1,000 µM TEB. This change may have contributed to the loss of sperm motility by the end of exposure. PMI is commonly measured to assess drone sperm viability (Kaya & Uysal, 2023). Exposure to 1,000 µM TEB reduced PMI in vitro. The authors discuss a possible effect on the cell membrane. In fungi, TEB inhibits a cytochrome P450 enzyme involved in ergosterol synthesis, affecting membrane integrity (Ito et al., 2013). Hajer et al. (2020) reported inhibition of testicular P450 and glutathione S-transferase activity, epididymitis and lower sperm counts in rats. In vivo studies in rats (Hajer et al., 2020) and chickens (Serra et al., 2023) reported more sperm abnormalities and declines in motility, speed, counts and/or viability. Oxidative stress is another possible explanation for reduced PMI. Previous work associated TEB exposure with lipid peroxidation, protein oxidation and severe DNA degradation in male reproductive organs (Hajer et al., 2020).MMP is an indicator of mitochondrial function. Previous studies showed that environmental pesticides can affect sperm ATP levels (Abdelkader et al., 2015; Kairo et al., 2016). In this experiment, 1,000 µM TEB reduced MMP at 24 hours. The authors discuss the possibility of sublethal effects from prolonged exposure or accumulation at lower concentrations. Fungicide residues, including TEB, have been detected in the environment, in honey bees and in bee products. Long-term exposure at low concentrations is a separate question. Endocrine, metabolic or systemic effects depend on the organism, concentration and duration of exposure (Johnson et al., 2010). Conclusion This study investigated the possible in vitro effects of the triazole fungicide TEB on drone semen quality. Plasma membrane integrity and mitochondrial function help sustain sperm viability and motility. The observed changes in these measures warrant further study of the possible implications for honey bee reproduction and the production of honey and other bee products under field conditions. Abdulkadir KAYA (Department of Reproduction and Artificial Insemination, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Kırıkkale University, Kırıkkale, Türkiye; Ankara University, Institute of Health Sciences, Ankara, Türkiye) and Ruhi KABAKÇI (Department of Physiology, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Kırıkkale University, Kırıkkale, Türkiye) Turkish Veterinary Journal, 6(2): 71–77, 2024 · DOI 10.51755/turkvetj.1577784
- First European record of the southern giant hornet Vespa soror
Translator’s preface by Davide Simeone The natural world is constantly changing. Human activity, helped by the speed of modern transport, has accelerated the movement of organisms between ecosystems. Adaptation takes time, while the disruption can be immediate. The arrival in Spain of another hornet native to Asia recalls the introduction of Vespa velutina and the damage it has caused. Italy’s mild, temperate climate might favour the new species if it were introduced. Italian beekeeping already faces the northward spread of Vespa orientalis and the potential threat of V. velutina farther south. The prospect of Vespa soror adds to those concerns. Research and cooperation are essential for limiting the spread of introduced species and managing their impact over time. I share this translation of the first Spanish study of Vespa soror in the hope that it will help researchers and beekeepers working together. Abstract An insect monitoring programme in northern Spain, designed to assess the effects of yellow-legged hornet (Vespa velutina) trapping on insect diversity, yielded Europe’s first record of the southern giant hornet, Vespa soror (Hymenoptera: Vespidae). The authors combined morphology and genetic identification and explain how to distinguish the species from other Iberian hornets. They consider plausible introduction pathways and vectors, the potential for establishment and the implications for the receiving environment. The preliminary results raise concerns about the possible threat from Vespa soror to human health and ecosystem dynamics. The hornet preys on other insects and can also take small vertebrates. The study illustrates how examining trap catches can help detect alien species early and support a rapid response. 1 Introduction The genus Vespa Linnaeus, 1758, in the family Vespidae and subfamily Vespinae, comprises eusocial hymenopterans commonly called hornets (Noll et al. 2020). Globalisation has increased the opportunities for social vespids, especially vespines, to be accidentally introduced into new regions and countries. Mated queens shelter during unfavourable weather and can go unnoticed in materials or containers that people move far from their original location (Arca et al. 2015; Castro 2019; Lioy, Bergamo and Porporato 2022; Otis, Taylor and Mattila 2023). Another factor in successful introductions is the small number of individuals needed to establish a population. Where conditions are favourable, one or a few mated queens, depending on the species, can found colonies if they survive until the first workers emerge. This occurred in Europe with Vespa velutina Lepeletier, 1836 (Villemant et al. 2011; Monceau, Bonnard and Thiéry 2014; Arca et al. 2015; Otis, Taylor and Mattila 2023). All species of Vespa are native to Asia. Only Vespa crabro Linnaeus, 1758, and Vespa orientalis Linnaeus, 1771, are also native to parts of Europe or North Africa (Archer 2012; Smith-Pardo, Carpenter and Kimsey 2020). The Iberian–Balearic fauna originally included only the European hornet, Vespa crabro, which occurs across much of the Iberian Peninsula (Vega et al. 2022). Further species arrived in the decade preceding the study, including the yellow-legged hornet Vespa velutina (Castro and Pagola-Carte 2010; López, González and Goldarazena 2011; Grosso-Silva and Maia 2012), the Oriental hornet Vespa orientalis (Hernández et al. 2013; Sánchez, Fajardo and Castro 2019; Fajardo and Sánchez 2020) and the black shield hornet Vespa bicolor Fabricius, 1787 (Castro 2019). The southern giant hornet, Vespa soror du Buysson, 1905, is native to warmer parts of Asia, including northeastern India (Arunachal Pradesh, Meghalaya and Nagaland), northern Myanmar, northern Thailand, Laos, northern Vietnam and southern China (Yunnan, Fujian, Jiangxi, Zhejiang, Hunan, Guangdong, Hong Kong and Hainan Island) (Lee 2009; Daglio 2019; Smith-Pardo, Carpenter and Kimsey 2020).It is one of the largest hornets, comparable in size to its congener the northern giant hornet, Vespa mandarinia Smith, 1852 (Kurzenko 1995; Girish-Kumar and Srinivasan 2010; Lee 2010). The authors reported no known established non-native populations of V. soror, although a queen was found at Vancouver Harbour, British Columbia, in 2019 (Kozak and Otis 2020; Bass, Needham and Bennett 2022). V. mandarinia was detected in British Columbia and Washington State. The absence of detections in 2023 and 2024 led researchers to provisionally conclude that the introduction had failed, potentially due to eradication efforts, Allee effects, ecological factors and chance (Bass, Needham and Bennett 2022; Taylor et al. 2024). The paper documents the first European record of V. soror, from northern Spain, and provides a genetic and morphological characterisation of the specimens. The authors describe and illustrate diagnostic features to distinguish this hornet from native and introduced Iberian vespines. They also provide a simplified pictorial key to the Iberian species of Vespa and discuss likely pathways and vectors of introduction, the status of the species and its possible impacts if it becomes invasive. 2 Materials and methods 2.1 Specimen collection, morphological analysis and taxonomic procedures Four V. soror specimens were collected in March 2022 and October 2023 at El Campo, Granda, Siero (43°22′36″ N, 5°45′41″ W), in Asturias, northern Spain. The specimens were caught in a commercial VespaCatch trap made for V. velutina by Véto-pharma (Palaiseau, France) and baited with VespaCatch attractant (https://www.blog-veto-pharma.com/) (Figure 1). They were prepared for preservation at the site, fixed in 70% ethanol for genetic analysis and later pinned. They were examined with an Optika SZM-2 dissecting stereomicroscope at 0.7–4.5×. Photographs were taken with a Canon EOS 1200D digital SLR and an EF-S 18–55 mm f/3.5–5.6 III lens. Specimens were deposited in the collection of the University of Oviedo’s Department of Organisms and Systems (BOS, https://bos.uniovi.es/). 2.2 DNA extraction, PCR amplification and sequencing DNA was extracted from 20–50 mg of ethanol-preserved leg tissue from one specimen using an E.Z.N.A. Tissue DNA Kit (Omega Bio-tek) according to the manufacturer’s protocol and stored at −20 °C. The mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit I barcode region (COI-5P) was amplified by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) in 40 µL using the universal primers LCO1490 and HCO2198 (Folmer et al. 1994). The mixture contained 2.5 µL template DNA, MgCl₂, 0.25 mM of each dNTP, 0.25 µM of each primer, 0.5 U Taq polymerase (GoTaq G2 Flexi DNA Polymerase) and 1× buffer. The published methods specify the MgCl₂ concentration. After initial denaturation at 95 °C for 4 min, 35 cycles were run at 95 °C for 45 s, 48 °C for 45 s and 72 °C for 30 s, followed by a final extension at 72 °C for 7 min. The PCR product was checked by horizontal electrophoresis in a 2% agarose gel and sent to Macrogen (Madrid, Spain) for forward and reverse Sanger sequencing (Sanger and Coulson 1975). Location where Vespa soror was found in Asturias (a) and location of Asturias within Spain (b). View of the study plot (c) and detail of a VespaCatch trap on an apple branch at the site (d). 2.3 Genetic analysis Forward and reverse Sanger reads were processed in Geneious Prime 2022.2.2 (https://www.geneious.com) to trim low-quality sequence and remove primer sequences. The reads were aligned and checked manually for base-calling errors. A consensus sequence was generated from the corrected alignment using the default settings. Preliminary genetic identification used nucleotide BLAST in Geneious Prime with default settings to search GenBank. The authors also searched the BOLD Public Record Barcode Database using its identification engine (https://www.boldsystems.org/index.php/IDS_OpenIdEngine). The phylogenetic analysis used 31 COI sequences (GenBank accessions in Supporting Information SX). The dataset included the new Spanish sequence, available V. soror sequences longer than 500 bp, at least one sequence for each other Vespa species represented in the database and four outgroups. Sequences were analysed with RAxML in Geneious Prime 2022.2.2. The authors used ModelTest in the PAUP pipeline to select the nucleotide substitution model by the Akaike information criterion (AIC). They searched for the best-scoring maximum-likelihood tree under GTR+G+I with 10,000 bootstrap replicates. They reported a consensus tree with a 10% burn-in, a 50% bootstrap support threshold for the consensus and a 70% threshold for considering a node supported. 3 Results 3.1 Morphological characterisation Synonyms include Vespa ducalis var. soror du Buysson, 1905, and Vespa mandarinia soror van der Vecht, 1957. Archer (1991) first treated Vespa soror as a distinct species. Material examined. Four female workers from El Campo, Granda (Siero, Asturias, northern Spain), collected by A. Arias. Two were collected on 29 March 2022, one on 3 October 2023 and one on 10 October 2023. Description. Vespa soror has a distinctive colour pattern shared by very few Asian species in the genus and unique among European hornets. Both sexes are tricoloured, with black to blackish-brown, light brown and yellow areas (Figure 2). Four alternating light and dark blocks are apparent. The exceptionally large head is mostly yellow, followed by a black to blackish-brown section comprising most of the mesosoma. A long section from the scutellum to the end of the second tergum (T2) is mainly yellow and light brown, generally with dark bands or marks. The terminal metasomal segments, roughly the rear half, are black. The antennae and legs are mostly brown and the wings are yellowish. The metasomal colour pattern distinguishes V. soror from the other Vespa species and queens of Dolichovespula media (Retzius, 1783) in Iberia and elsewhere in Europe despite some variation within species (Figure 3).In V. soror the posterior metasomal segments are entirely black. Other native or introduced hornets have substantial yellow or orange areas in the rear half (Figure 3). Vespa soror specimens trapped in Asturias, northern Spain. Ethanol-preserved specimens are shown in dorsal view (A), dorsal detail of the head and thorax (B), lateral detail of the head and thorax (C), full lateral view (D), ventral view (E) and lateral view (F). A pinned specimen is shown in head detail (G) and in lateral (H), ventral (I) and dorsal (J) views. Typical colour patterns of Iberian Vespa and Dolichovespula. Vespa velutina (A), Vespa orientalis (B), Vespa crabro (C), Vespa bicolor (D), Vespa soror (E) and a Dolichovespula media queen (F). Drawings adapted from Perrard et al. (2014). Notes. Archer (2012) distinguished females of V. mandarinia and V. soror from other Vespa by their unusually broad genae. In lateral view, at the level of the posterior margin of the clypeus, genal width (GW) exceeds 1.7 times eye width (EW), compared with less than 1.3 times in other species. In V. ducalis the ratio is about 1 (L. Castro, unpublished data). Males of V. mandarinia and V. soror also have broad genae (GW over 1.4 times EW at the same level) and share a distinctive combination of characters in the sword-shaped aedeagus, the two apical sterna, the eyes and the antennae (Archer 2012). Characters distinguishing the two species include the median pronotal impression and the proportions of the first gastral tergum in dorsal view. Its length is about half its width or more in V. soror and less than half its width in V. mandarinia. T3–T6 are usually entirely black in V. soror. In V. mandarinia, T3–T5 have orange bands and T6 is orange (Nguyen et al. 2006). Vespa ducalis Smith, 1852 has a similar colour pattern, but its genae in lateral view are about as wide as the eyes, whereas those of V. soror are visibly wider. Identifying female caste in social vespids can be important. Body length depends on specimen posture and shrinkage, and wing span and wing length can be difficult to measure. Weight, cuticular chemistry and ovarian development have also been used to identify Vespa castes but present practical difficulties (Pérez de Heredia et al. 2017; Castro and del Pico 2021). Pérez de Heredia et al. (2017) proposed measuring mesoscutal width between the tegulae. The mesosoma is rigid, remains stable after death and can be measured precisely. The ranges reported for gynes and workers of the species examined did not overlap. Mattila et al. (2023) applied six measures to V. soror: head width, forewing length, mesosomal width and the width of the first three terga. The authors of the Spanish study considered T2 width the most reliable, as the observed ranges of gynes and workers showed almost no overlap. They identified the four Asturian specimens as workers from intertegular measurements of reference specimens from five Asian countries (L. Castro, unpublished data) and maximum T2 width following Mattila et al. (2023). 3.2 Genetic results BLAST identified the sequence from the one sequenced specimen (GenBank OP735561, BOLD INVA001-22) as V. soror, with 97.7–98.1% pairwise identity to four reference specimens. The remaining matches to V. crabro and V. bicolor had no more than 87.8% similarity. The BOLD identification procedure yielded 100% and 99.44% similarity to two records identified as V. soror. BOLD marked those sequences as private and the authors reported that they were part of unpublished research (Table 1). BLAST and BOLD identification results for the consensus sequence from the collected specimen. The phylogenetic analysis placed the Spanish sequence with GenBank sequences identified as V. soror. The node grouping them had 99.97% bootstrap support (Figure 4). The sequence distance matrix is available in Supporting Information SY. Best-scoring maximum-likelihood tree from the COI sequence analysis under GTR+G+I with 10,000 bootstrap replicates. The analysis used 31 nucleotide sequences and 658 positions. GenBank accession numbers are listed in Supporting Information SX. 4 Discussion Vespa soror preys on invertebrates of different sizes, including butterflies, dragonflies, mantises, grasshoppers and other wasps. It also takes small vertebrates such as geckos (Lee 2009). It has been observed raiding nests of Vespa bicolor, Polistes and Parapolybia (Pa. indica, Pa. nodosa and Pa. varia) to feed the captured larvae and pupae to its own brood (Lee 2009). Reports also describe how V. soror attacks colonies of the Asian honey bee, Apis cerana Fabricius, 1793, in groups. These attacks can destroy colonies and cause losses to beekeepers (Lee 2009; Mattila et al. 2020; Cappa et al. 2021). A similar risk could arise for Apis mellifera Linnaeus, 1758, in Asturias if V. soror becomes established, adding to losses already associated with invasive V. velutina (Requier et al. 2019; Laurino et al. 2020; Cappa et al. 2021). V. soror stings are reported to cause intense pain and lasting effects. The authors hypothesise that its venom may be potent, as in its close relatives V. tropica (Linnaeus, 1758) and V. mandarinia, both of which have been described as hazardous stinging insects (Schmidt et al. 1986; Lee 2009).Stings could become a public health concern if the species establishes. In its native range, the authors highlight September to December, when large colonies can be particularly defensive before males and new queens emerge (Lee 2009). In the native range, most V. soror colonies occur in wooded areas from sea level to over 700 m. The nest is usually underground, often in well-drained soil on a slope, with an angled entrance hole often situated among the roots of large trees (Lee 2009; Mattila et al. 2023). Some nests are only a few centimetres below the surface, while others are deep underground and connected to the entrance by one or more tunnels at least 60 cm long (Lee 2009). Nesting behaviour resembles that of V. mandarinia (Archer 1995; Lee 2009; Smith-Pardo, Carpenter and Kimsey 2020; Bass, Needham and Bennett 2022; Mattila et al. 2023). As with V. velutina, detecting and removing nests would be an important part of control if V. soror spreads in northern Spain. In that case, underground nesting could make nests harder for the responsible authorities to locate and remove. In Hong Kong, queens usually emerge between late March and April each year. Nest initiation probably begins in early May, with the first workers generally emerging in June (Lee 2009). Mattila et al. (2023) give preliminary information on the colony cycle in Vietnam. These studies help assess when one or more colonies may have been active in Asturias. The two workers collected in late March 2022 were detected earlier in the year than would be expected from those native-range observations. The authors discuss whether they could have come from a nest founded unusually early in 2022 or from a nest founded in 2021 that survived winter. They note similarities between native-range conditions and the weather in Asturias in spring 2022 and suggest that the mild climate might have influenced nesting timing, as reported locally for V. velutina. The two workers collected in October 2023 could have come from a colony founded by a queen produced in 2022 that survived winter. A separate introduction is another possibility. The captures alone cannot establish the history of the colonies. The authors consider accidental transport of an overwintering queen from the native range a plausible introduction pathway, as proposed for V. mandarinia and V. velutina (Otis, Taylor and Mattila 2023). The Entomological Society of America proposed “southern giant hornet” as the common name for V. soror. Spanish renderings include “avispón gigante del sur” and “avispón gigante meridional”. Both are precise, but in everyday use they may be shortened to “avispón gigante”, which could cause confusion with V. mandarinia, the northern giant hornet. Generic or sensational names can likewise obscure the identity of the species. The authors propose the shorter Spanish name “avispón sóror”, which has a direct connection to the scientific name, along the lines of “avispa velutina”, “avispón bicolor” and “avispón oriental”. 5 Conclusions The first European records of V. soror are supported by morphological and genetic analyses. This brings the number of introduced Vespa species recorded on the Iberian Peninsula to four. Accidental transport from the native range is a likely explanation. If V. soror becomes established in northern Iberia, where V. velutina is already widespread, their combined effects could increase environmental, economic and public health impacts. The authors call for early surveillance and a rapid response to locate any nests and assess potential spread and impacts around Siero and neighbouring areas. The dedicated Asturian trapping programme reported no V. soror captures in its 2025 survey. The four original specimens therefore document an occurrence, while establishment remains unconfirmed. Omar Sánchez, Leopoldo Castro, Álvaro Fueyo, Yaisel J. Borrell, Andrés Arias First published 9 November 2024 · https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.70502
- How honey bee drones acquire bacteria in their gut and reproductive tissues
The western honey bee (Apis mellifera) is an important pollinator of crops worldwide. Worker bees forage and perform the tasks that sustain the colony. Drones, the males of the species, contribute genetically by mating with virgin queens from other colonies. Their reproductive fitness can affect queen performance and, in turn, colony survival. U.S. beekeepers have reported annual colony losses as high as 50.8% Beekeepers have reported substantial colony losses in the United States and elsewhere. The study cites annual U.S. losses as high as 50.8%. That figure refers to colony losses from all reported causes. Colony collapse disorder (CCD), widely reported from 2007 onward, describes a particular pattern of loss. Pathogens, parasites, poor nutrition, climate change and agricultural chemicals are among the factors investigated in relation to colony health. Queen health is also an important factor in colony survival. Honey bees are eusocial insects, and a single queen normally produces the colony’s brood. The study cites a historical lifespan of two to seven years in the queen’s original colony and reports that queens are now replaced more often. In the cited studies, about half of colonies replaced a queen within six months and queen replacement was associated with a threefold increase in the risk of colony loss. Workers make up 90% or more of the colony and forage, maintain the hive and care for the queen, drones and newly emerged workers. They may replace a queen for several reasons, including excessive laying of unfertilised eggs, which develop into drones, if the queen’s sperm reserves are depleted or of poor quality. Drones are male honey bees Drones make up less than 10% of the colony population during spring and summer. Their reproductive role is to mate with virgin queens from other colonies. Their reproductive fitness can therefore affect future queens and the colonies those queens head. Drone health and fertility have received less research attention than worker and queen health. Figure 1. How the researchers classified drone reproductive maturity. In immature stage 1 (I1), little or no sperm had migrated from the testes to the seminal vesicles. In immature stage 2 (I2), migration had begun. In mature drones (M), migration was complete and the testes had degenerated or were no longer visible. Drones develop for about 24 days before emerging as adults. Spermatogenesis is completed by emergence, when the seminal vesicles and mucus glands are still developing and sperm remain in the testes (Figure 1). Sperm migrate to the seminal vesicles about six to twelve days after emergence and are stored there until mating. Once migration is complete, the drone is sexually mature and the testes degenerate and cease to function (Figure 1). Honey bee queens mate early in life, during one or a few mating flights. Colony growth and longevity depend in part on the quantity and quality of sperm collected on those flights. Seminal fluid must help maintain sperm viability in the male’s seminal vesicles, during mating and subsequently in the queen’s spermatheca. Queens rely on stored sperm for the rest of their lives. Drone sperm counts vary widely, but the factors that determine drone reproductive fitness remain incompletely understood. The gut microbiota contributes to worker honey bee health. Research has linked it to immunity, defence against pathogens, metabolism and potentially behaviour and development. Workers are the largest group in the colony, and their microbiota has been studied extensively. They acquire gut microbes through social interactions and exposure to hive materials. Under typical conditions, the worker gut community is established about five days after emergence and stays relatively stable in healthy bees. It consists mainly of five bacterial groups: Bifidobacterium, Snodgrassella, Gilliamella, Lactobacillus and Bombilactobacillus.These core groups are shared among workers, but the strains within them vary among individuals. This can give different communities different functional capacities. Gut microbiota The drone gut contains some of the same bacterial groups as the worker gut, but is generally less diverse and varies more among individuals.At the time of the study, little was known about how drones acquire their microbiota or whether social interactions help establish it. Microbes have been found in the reproductive tissues of several animals, including insects. In some insects, such as mosquitoes and tsetse flies, reproductive tissue-associated bacteria have been linked to development or reproductive fitness. Such findings motivated the authors to ask whether honey bee reproductive tissues also harbour bacteria and whether these might be relevant to health and fertility. Queens are difficult to study experimentally because of their indispensable role in the colony. Since a queen’s reproductive fitness and lifespan depend in part on the drones she mates with, drones offer a way to investigate whether bacteria are present in honey bee reproductive tissues and what their role might be. This study asked whether bacteria occur in drone reproductive tissues, how drones acquire their gut and reproductive tissue-associated microbiota, and how those communities change during maturation. The authors used 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing to identify and characterise bacteria in the guts and reproductive tissues of conventionally reared and experimentally reared drones. In particular, the study reported the first detection of bacteria in the reproductive organs of honey bee drones. Drones that emerged naturally and were then kept under sterile laboratory conditions without social contact rarely harboured the bacterial groups found in conventionally reared drones and workers, such as Snodgrassella, Bifidobacterium, Gilliamella, Lactobacillus and Bombilactobacillus. The findings suggest that social contact with workers , for example through feeding and grooming, helps establish the gut and reproductive tissue-associated microbiota of drones. The discovery of a conserved bacterial community in drone reproductive organs also makes the honey bee a candidate model for investigating how microbes associated with reproductive tissues may affect host fitness. Materials and methods Read the full article Results The authors detected a microbiota associated with drone reproductive tissues. This finding opens a line of investigation into drone reproductive fitness. The experiment also indicated that the establishment of typical bacterial communities in the gut and reproductive tissues depended strongly on social interactions with workers, because drones that emerged on hive frames but were kept in the laboratory without worker contact did not develop the typical microbiota. Drones returned to the colony were housed in foster cages with limited contact with hive material. This supports the interpretation that contact with the workers caring for them helped establish their microbiota. As reported previously, drone gut communities were less diverse than worker gut communities and were dominated by Lactobacillus species. This difference may be related to the fact that nurse bees feed and care for drones and often give them less attention when resources are scarce. Social contact in the hive The authors hypothesise that the amount of social contact a drone receives during and after emergence influences how its microbiota becomes established. Diet and lifestyle may also account for differences between workers and drones. Workers consume substantially more pollen than drones, and their diet changes as they age and move from nursing to foraging. Foragers spend much of their time outside the hive, whereas drones leave the colony mainly for mating-related flights. The 16S copy numbers initially suggested unexpectedly high bacterial loads in the guts and reproductive tissues of laboratory-kept drones (NE-D0 and Lab-D5), although the communities lacked typical honey bee-associated groups. One possible explanation is that resident bee-associated bacteria normally outcompete environmental microbes. In the hive, nurse bees help drones remove the wax capping at emergence and feed them immediately, potentially beginning microbiota acquisition. The authors suggest that some or all of the bacteria found in the laboratory-reared drones may have come from their brood cells during emergence. Brood cells can contain plant-derived material and environmental microbes. Many NE-D0 samples did not yield usable sequencing data, possibly because their guts and reproductive tissues contained very few bacteria. After quality filtering, more than 10% of the reads from the guts of laboratory-kept drones were assigned to mitochondria or chloroplasts or remained unassigned. In some individuals, these reads accounted for more than 40% of the total. This suggests that few bacterial sequences were present. Mitochondrial and chloroplast reads sometimes occur in honey bee gut 16S surveys because host tissue and plant material are present, but they usually account for a small fraction, for example less than 1%. An unusually high fraction of reads from the testes of laboratory-kept drones, particularly NE-D0 drones, also came from mitochondria or could not be assigned. Immature drone testes contain many spermatozoa, whose middle region is largely made up of mitochondrial derivatives. Lactobacillus The 16S copy numbers measured by quantitative PCR (qPCR) in tissues of laboratory-kept drones may therefore overestimate bacterial abundance because the primers can amplify mitochondrial or chloroplast DNA. After the study, the authors found that their qPCR primers were particularly prone to off-target mitochondrial amplification in samples with few bacteria. Gut and reproductive tissue communities were broadly similar in Hive-D5 and Hive-D18 drones, both dominated by Lactobacillus. Differences in total bacterial abundance and relative taxon abundance could reflect shifts during maturation. The authors did not quantify the absolute abundance of individual taxa, so a change in relative abundance does not establish a change in the actual number of bacteria of a given taxon. The NE-D0, Lab-D5 and Hive-D5 groups were sampled in late summer 2021. Hive-D18 drones came from a different colony in spring 2022, because in summer 2021 the workers stopped tending the drones and the males died before reaching maturity. Previous worker studies found little effect of colony origin on gut community composition but did report seasonal differences in composition and absolute abundance. Winter workers, for example, had higher bacterial abundance and lower within-sample diversity. Season may therefore contribute to the differences between Hive-D5 and Hive-D18. Bacterial loads were higher in spring Hive-D18 drones than in late-summer Hive-D5 drones. The groups showed no significant difference in alpha diversity in the gut or reproductive tissues, and Lactobacillus predominated in both. Further work is needed to determine how season, colony origin and other environmental factors affect drone microbiota. Gut and reproductive tissue communities contained similar bacterial groups. Sterile dissection, care to keep the gut intact and the substantial bacterial signals in reproductive tissues argue against accidental gut contamination during sampling. Similarities between these communities have also been reported in other insects, including the tomato leafminer (Tuta absoluta) and some mosquitoes. Honey bees have specialised, coevolved gut communities. Some core bacterial groups may contain strains adapted to particular tissues, with functional differences among them. How bacteria reach the reproductive tissues remains unclear. Given the taxonomic similarity within individual drones, the authors hypothesise that the immune system and the gut barrier are still developing at emergence, potentially allowing bacteria from the gut to reach other organs. Fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH) or other fluorescent labelling could help locate cells in the tissues, and metagenomic sequencing and culture could test for strain-level differences. Worker gut microbes contribute to metabolism, defence against pathogens and immunity, and may also affect development. The effects of gut microbes on drone health were not tested directly, although similarities with worker communities suggest some functions may be shared. This was the first study the authors knew of to characterise bacteria associated with honey bee reproductive tissues. Effects on drone health or fertility, and any subsequent effects on queens and colonies, remain hypotheses. Future work should determine what the reproductive tissue-associated bacteria do. The study identifies them as a factor to investigate in drone health and reproductive fitness, and suggests that honey bees may serve as a model for research on reproductive as well as gut microbiota. Published online 19 December 2024 · mSphere · DOI 10.1128/msphere.00705-24 Full article https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/msphere.00705-24 Authors · Alexis Burks (Department of Biology, University of North Carolina, Greensboro, North Carolina, USA) Patrick Gallagher (Department of Plant and Microbial Biology, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, North Carolina, USA) Kasie Raymann (Department of Biology, University of North Carolina, Greensboro, North Carolina, USA) and (Department of Plant and Microbial Biology, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, North Carolina, USA)
- Post-thaw dilution of dialysed, cryopreserved drone semen and honey bee queen fertility
Cryopreservation in liquid nitrogen at −196 °C brings sperm metabolism almost to a halt Preface Cryopreserving semen from honey bee drones (Apis mellifera) remains a challenge. Despite decades of research, the difficulty of preserving sperm viability and function after thawing still limits the practical use of frozen semen. This study examined how diluting cryopreserved drone semen with Bee Semen Solution (BSS) after thawing affected sperm viability and queen reproductive performance. Queens were instrumentally inseminated with fresh or cryopreserved semen, with diluted and undiluted groups for each. The authors measured sperm count and quality in the spermatheca and assessed the brood pattern. Cryopreservation reduced sperm viability and queen fertility compared with fresh semen. After thawing, BSS dilution showed a trend towards better spermathecal sperm parameters and queen fertility. The results suggest that post-thaw handling, including the choice of diluent, may help improve outcomes when semen is cryopreserved by a protocol that uses dialysis. The authors also propose investigating repeated insemination as a way to increase spermathecal sperm counts and improve queen fertility. Introduction Apis mellifera spermatozoa Cryopreserving and storing honey bee drone semen remain challenges for instrumental insemination, breeding and research. Despite years of work on effective protocols (Melnichenko and Vavilov, 1975; Harbo, 1977; Kaftanoglu and Peng, 1984; Hopkins et al., 2012; Wegener et al., 2014a; Alçay et al., 2019), there is still no widely adopted method for maintaining semen fertility during long-term storage (Cobey, 2016; Smilga-Spalvina et al., 2023). Difficulties include freezing and storage and the effective insemination of queens with thawed material. Freezing and thawing can increase sperm abnormalities such as deformed heads and twisted tails (Yániz et al., 2024) and reduce sperm motility and viability (Hopkins and Herr, 2010; Özkök and Selcuk, 2020). Several studies have examined the diluent used before cryopreservation and its effects on semen quality (Harbo, 1979; Taylor et al., 2009; Hopkins and Herr, 2010; Wegener et al., 2012; Alçay et al., 2019, 2022; Gulov and Laskin, 2021; Aktar et al., 2024; Nur et al., 2024; Mohammadi et al., 2025). Some commonly used cryoprotectants can harm spermatozoa, queens or both (Hopkins and Herr, 2010; Wegener and Bienefeld, 2012; Wegener et al., 2012). Diluting or removing much of the cryoprotectant after thawing may reduce its toxic effects (Wegener et al., 2014a; Gül et al., 2017; Auth and Hopkins, 2021). This has prompted interest in alternative diluents that stabilise sperm membranes after thawing while minimising damage. Few studies have examined the effects of post-thaw dilution on spermathecal sperm quality and queen fertility. Wegener et al. (2014a) diluted cryopreserved semen with BSS and then centrifuged it to remove the cryoprotectant and reconcentrate the spermatozoa. Spermathecal sperm motility and queen fertility declined, and worker brood accounted for 27% of the brood. Gül et al. (2017) washed and centrifuged semen samples using a semen extender, glucose solutions or fresh drone seminal plasma. They found no significant increase in the proportion of worker brood. In both studies, centrifugation after dilution may have adversely affected sperm function and insemination success (Cobey et al., 2013). Wegener et al. (2014a) reported better sperm quality and queen fertility when they gently diluted the thawed samples with BSS and mixed them by hand without centrifugation. Only three queens underwent that procedure, and the dilution ratio of one part semen to two parts BSS differed from the 1:1 ratio commonly used in queen insemination (Skowronek et al., 1995; Gerula et al., 2016; Kahya and Gençer, 2022). The present study examined how BSS dilution after thawing semen that was dialysed before freezing affected queen fertility and spermathecal sperm count and quality. Materials and methods (read the full article) Results Motility reached 98% in the freshly collected semen and 62% in the thawed samples tested. Queen mortality did not differ significantly across the four treatments (Table 1). A Monte Carlo simulation gave χ² = 1.14, df = 3 and p = 0.77. Non-parametric analyses detected overall differences in the assessed reproductive and sperm traits. The proportion of worker brood differed between groups (Kruskal–Wallis H(3) = 28.13, p < 0.001). Queens inseminated with cryopreserved semen (groups 3 and 4) produced a lower proportion of worker brood than queens inseminated with fresh semen (groups 1 and 2) (Table 1). Cryopreservation had a large effect (Cliff’s δ = 0.94–1.00). The two fresh-semen groups showed no significant difference (p = 1.000). Among the cryopreserved groups, BSS dilution was associated with a small to moderate estimated improvement (δ = −0.35 for group 3 versus group 4), which was not statistically significant. Table 1. Queen mortality and brood pattern (% worker brood) after insemination with semen subjected to different treatments Spermathecal sperm counts differed across treatments (p = 0.0005 as reported, Table 2). Queens inseminated with cryopreserved semen had lower sperm counts than those inseminated with fresh semen (p < 0.05, δ = 0.72–1.00). Post-thaw BSS dilution showed a trend towards higher sperm counts in the cryopreserved groups (δ = −0.30 for group 3 versus group 4, p = 1.000, Table S1). Sperm motility also varied across treatments (H(3) = 25.60, p < 0.001). Motility declined with cryopreservation (δ = 0.73–1.00). Post-thaw BSS dilution was associated with higher motility than undiluted thawed semen (δ = −0.52 for group 3 versus group 4, p = 0.26). Viability likewise varied across treatments (H(3) = 23.70, p < 0.001). Sperm count (millions) and sperm quality in the spermatheca of queens inseminated with semen subjected to different treatments Cryopreservation was associated with substantially lower viability than fresh semen (δ = 0.83–1.00). The estimated difference in viability between the two thawed groups was negligible (δ = 0.03, p = 1.000, Table S1). Discussion Cryopreservation affected the count and quality of sperm stored in queen spermathecae, as reported in earlier studies (Harbo, 1983; Kaftanoglu and Peng, 1984; Hopkins et al., 2012; Wegener et al., 2012, 2014a; Gül et al., 2017; Paillard et al., 2017; Gulov and Laskin, 2020, 2021; Yániz et al., 2020; Nur et al., 2024; Egyptien et al., 2025; Mohammadi et al., 2025). Relatively few studies have assessed the fertility of queens inseminated with cryopreserved semen, and these differ in freezing protocols and in the diluents used before or after freezing. An important practical measure is whether a queen can produce enough workers to support colony growth (Bryła and Trzcińska, 2024) or enough fertilised eggs to rear replacement queens and preserve genetic lines for selective breeding (Wegener et al., 2012). Queens inseminated with cryopreserved semen can lay fertilised eggs, although fertility outcomes vary. Early single-insemination trials reported egg laying with 3.3 µL or unspecified volumes, respectively, but low worker brood proportions (8–22% and 47%) and spermathecal counts (0.1–0.2 million spermatozoa) (Harbo, 1983; Kaftanoglu and Peng, 1984). The effects of different extenders have varied. Wegener et al. (2012) reported lower spermathecal counts after cryopreservation with dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), at 0.7–1.3 million compared with 2.4–3.6 million for fresh semen. Addition of cryoprotectant by dialysis yielded 49–79% worker brood. Gentle post-thaw dilution without centrifugation yielded up to 65.8% worker brood and up to 1.8 million spermathecal spermatozoa in the reported experiments (Wegener et al., 2014a). Instrumental insemination of honey bee queens Hopkins et al. (2012) found that queens inseminated with 5 µL of cryopreserved semen could produce fertile offspring across generations. Fertilisation reached 95–100% in the best cases and averaged 50% initially and 46% in the first generation. Subsequent studies modified freezing and insemination protocols to improve post-thaw sperm viability and queen fertility. Gül et al. (2017) reported that queens inseminated once with 5 µL of thawed semen washed in drone seminal plasma produced comparable proportions of worker brood to frozen controls (48% and 47%, respectively), with spermathecal counts of 0.81 and 1.6 million, respectively. They found no significant improvement. Some alternative pre-freezing diluents, including honey-based solutions, yielded more promising results. Gulov and Laskin (2020, 2021) reported that queens inseminated once with 8–12 µL of cryopreserved semen produced 17–99% worker brood (mean 61%) and stored a mean of 1.98 million spermatozoa in the spermatheca. Nur et al. (2024) achieved egg laying with single inseminations of 8–10 µL using diluents without cryoprotectants, but did not report brood or sperm data. Excessive dilution lowered spermathecal counts to 0.14–0.15 million regardless of centrifugation (Paillard et al., 2017). Using a simple antibiotic-free freezing protocol, Egyptien et al. (2025) obtained fertilised eggs from a small proportion of queens inseminated once with 5 µL of cryopreserved semen, showing that the method was feasible but had limited efficiency. In the present study, worker brood reached up to 90% (mean 66%) with undiluted thawed semen and up to 95% (mean 78%) with diluted thawed semen. Mean spermathecal sperm counts were 1.86 and 2.04 million, respectively. Together, these studies show that cryopreserved semen can support fertilisation and worker production, with outcomes depending on the insemination volume, semen handling, including dilution and centrifugation, and the cryoprotectant or diluent. In the present study, queens were inseminated twice, which may partly explain the differences in spermathecal counts from earlier studies. Woyke (1960), Mackensen (1964) and Bieńkowska et al. (2011) found that splitting a dose across two inseminations increased spermathecal sperm counts compared with a single insemination. Bolten and Harbo (1982) also found that inseminating a queen twice with small amounts of diluted thawed semen delivered significantly more spermatozoa to the spermatheca than inseminating her once with the same total volume. The second insemination delivered 68–77% more spermatozoa than the first. Gąbka (2021) found no difference in the onset of egg laying among queens inseminated with different semen doses. Repeated insemination may also increase the risk of semen contamination and infection of the queen (Gąbka, 2021; Smilga-Spalvina et al., 2023). BSS – Bee Semen Solution Repeated insemination may therefore be worth investigating as a means of increasing the number of spermatozoa that reach the spermatheca, particularly with cryopreserved semen, because freezing can reduce sperm viability and motility and thereby affect queen reproductive performance (Wegener et al., 2012; Yániz et al., 2024). Dilution in a suitable medium may have influenced the results, although diluting fresh semen did not significantly improve the parameters measured. Earlier experiments with fresh semen found little effect of dilution on insemination outcomes (Mackensen, 1969; Skowronek et al., 1995; Lodesani et al., 2003; Gerula et al., 2016; Gąbka and Cobey, 2018; Kahya and Gençer, 2022). Across the diluents and dilution ratios examined, these studies found no significant differences in spermathecal counts between queens receiving diluted and undiluted fresh semen.Dilution likewise produced no statistically significant differences between the two cryopreserved semen groups. The authors suggest that dilution could have a greater effect after dialysis against a hypertonic cryoprotectant solution, as in this experiment. Dialysis draws water out of the semen, and post-thaw dilution may help restore osmolarity and viscosity. This could explain the higher values observed for diluted thawed semen when the authors compared means, medians and effect sizes (Cliff’s delta). The trends were most apparent for sperm motility, sperm count and worker brood. Trehalose, an ingredient of BSS (Wegener et al., 2014a), occurs naturally in drone seminal fluid (Blum et al., 1962). Compounds in this fluid, including proteins, amino acids and sugars, can help maintain sperm viability during storage (den Boer et al., 2009). Nur et al. (2020) reported that adding 0.1 or 0.05 M trehalose to a freezing medium with 12% DMSO improved post-thaw sperm motility and plasma membrane integrity. Tsvetkov et al. (2024) found higher post-thaw motility and better sperm movement parameters with trehalose without DMSO than with DMSO or glycerol. BSS containing trehalose could partly offset losses of motility and help sustain fertilisation. Many spermatozoa are lost or lose viability during transfer through the oviducts to the spermatheca. After natural mating, only about 3–5% reach the spermatheca (Yániz et al., 2020). Any additional loss of motile sperm after cryopreservation could therefore affect queen fertility. Paillard et al. (2017) reported a higher risk of failing to lay fertilised eggs when fewer than 0.5 million spermatozoa reach the spermatheca. Semen dilution may help the sperm disperse. Dilution can also reduce semen viscosity (Tofilski, 2014; Bratu and Pătruică, 2021). Semen is dense and tends to clump, particularly when collected from older drones, and can be difficult to draw into a narrow insemination tip (Cobey et al., 2013; Czekońska et al., 2013; Bieńkowska and Panasiuk, 2006). Dilution could make semen easier to deliver during insemination and help spermatozoa move through the queen’s reproductive tract. Further studies of diluent composition and insemination protocols are needed to improve queen fertility and make semen cryopreservation a practical tool for honey bee breeding and genetic conservation. Published in December 2025 · Journal of Apicultural Science · DOI 10.2478/JAS-2025-0013 Authors Mikołaj Borański, Małgorzata Bieńkowska, Beata Panasiuk and Dariusz Gerula · The National Institute of Horticultural Research, Poland Jakob Wegener · GrüBie Ashiralieva&Wegener Gbr, Germany Italian translation by Davide Simeone
- How mixing honey bee drone semen affects sperm quality: a preliminary study
Preface After mating, sperm from multiple Apis mellifera drones mix in the queen’s spermatheca. Their behaviour there matters for long-term sperm survival and successful fertilisation. The honey bee’s polyandrous mating system may also allow cryptic female choice and sperm competition to favour traits that contribute to successful reproduction. Cryptic female choice refers to mechanisms by which a female can influence the use of sperm from different males after mating, for example by retaining or expelling different proportions of their ejaculates. This preliminary study measured several sperm quality traits in mixed drone semen. The researchers collected 31 ejaculates and split them to prepare samples with semen from one, two or three drones. They used computer-assisted sperm analysis at baseline and after 60 minutes. Total motility declined significantly in two-drone samples (p = 0.004). Three-drone samples tended to show lower motility and kinematic values at baseline, without a significant difference between groups in those baseline measures. After an hour, the three-drone group alone showed increases in progressive motility, swimming speed and kinematic measures. Sperm concentration correlated with most functional measures, whereas morphometric measurements did not. The observed changes may reflect the combined effects of mixing, sperm concentration and time available for sperm interactions. Introduction Live and dead spermatozoa In polyandrous insects, a female mates with several males and receives semen from each. Among Hymenoptera, this can increase genetic diversity and benefit colony health and fitness. The honey bee (Apis mellifera) is an example of extreme polyandry. In some populations, a queen may mate with as many as 77 drones (Withrow and Tarpy 2018; Delaplane et al. 2021). The benefits associated with polyandry include improved worker performance and productivity, more efficient foraging, greater brood survival and larger colonies (Mattila and Seeley 2007; Delaplane et al. 2021). Multiple mating can also reduce the risk that a queen exhausts her sperm reserves (Delaplane et al. 2021). It may help provide enough spermatozoa with traits that support long-term fertilisation. The Cape honey bee, A. m. capensis, has smaller drones with lower sperm counts and queens with a larger spermatheca than European subspecies such as A. m. carnica. This may increase the number of matings needed for a lifetime supply of sperm (Kraus et al. 2004). Receiving large numbers of spermatozoa from multiple males may help ensure an adequate supply of viable sperm. Unlike queens, honey bee drones mate only once. After mating, sperm survival depends on conditions in the queen (den Boer et al. 2010). About 4–6 million spermatozoa reach and remain in the spermatheca, roughly 3–5% of the total transferred by the drones and 5–10% of an individual drone’s contribution according to the cited estimates. The remainder is expelled through the bursa copulatrix (Baer 2005; Gençer and Kahya 2020; Liu et al. 2020; Gençer et al. 2014). An estimated 1–1.6 million spermatozoa are eventually used to fertilise eggs over the following years (Baer 2005). Their ability to remain viable over that time makes sperm quality important (Baer 2003; Stürup et al. 2013). Researchers have therefore explored sperm competition in honey bees (Moritz 1986; Woyciechowski and Król 1996; Shafir et al. 2009). Competition among males and cryptic female choice can shape reproductive outcomes before or after mating. After mating, sperm competition has been proposed in both the oviducts and the spermatheca (Gençer and Kahya 2020). It might also occur when sperm leave the spermatheca, pass through its duct and reach an egg (Harbo 1990). In polyandrous species, sperm competition can favour traits that contribute to fertilisation (Pearcy et al. 2014). Candidate traits include progressive motility, swimming speed, viability, morphology and dimensions such as head, tail and total sperm length (Fitzpatrick and Lüpold 2014; Pearcy et al. 2014). Insect sperm kinematics are still poorly understood. Common measures are curvilinear velocity (VCL), straight-line velocity (VSL), average path velocity (VAP), linearity (LIN), straightness (STR), wobble (WOB), amplitude of lateral head displacement (ALH) and beat-cross frequency (BCF) (Lu et al. 2014; WHO 2021). Computer-assisted sperm analysis (CASA) systems typically track the sperm head and are widely used for mammalian sperm (Hook and Fisher 2020; WHO 2021). Insect sperm have much smaller heads and long flagella, which complicate detailed tracking. Above, individual and combined helical swimming patterns. Below, more progressive sperm movement under negative phase-contrast microscopy. After copulation, honey bee sperm mix (Borsuk et al. 2018) and form dense bundles in the spermatheca (Wegener et al. 2014). Over several hours, they can form groups that swim in circles (Tofilski et al. 2018). These changes could reflect interactions or cooperation among spermatozoa, which may contribute to fertilisation in insects (Lüpold et al. 2012; Pearcy et al. 2014). In some insects, sperm cooperation can change motility and swimming speed and may help sperm move through the reproductive tract (Pizzari and Foster 2008; Lüpold et al. 2012; Pearcy et al. 2014; Liberti et al. 2018). Greater motility and speed may come at a cost to viability, which is important during long-term storage. Sperm movement requires energy and is associated with increased metabolism. Mitochondria produce adenosine triphosphate (ATP) and reactive oxygen species (ROS), which can help regulate movement. If ROS production exceeds antioxidant capacity, oxidative stress can damage sperm structure and function and eventually cause cell death (Reinhardt 2007; Abdelkader et al. 2018). For example, insecticide exposure in adult drones in vivo and in honey bee sperm in vitro increased metabolic activity, as indicated by higher ATP production. Both studies also recorded higher sperm mortality and lower viability (Abdelkader et al. 2015, 2018). Most in vitro studies of mixing honey bee drone semen found no apparent effect on sperm viability (Shafir et al. 2009; Tofilski et al. 2012; Gençer et al. 2014). Viability also appeared similar in the lateral oviducts and spermatheca during the first four hours, when migration to the spermatheca is greatest in instrumentally inseminated queens (Gençer and Kahya 2011). Work on the consequences of mixing semen from multiple drones during and after mating has largely focused on swimming patterns and viability. Which structural and functional traits are most favourable for fertilisation remains unclear. In monandrous Hymenoptera, such as most bumble bees and solitary bees, the female mates with one male (Baer 2003). In some species, males form a mating plug that reduces the likelihood of further mating. Sperm from a single male may therefore reach the spermatheca without encountering sperm from other males, making sperm competition in the female reproductive tract less likely (Baer et al. 2006; Strobl et al. 2019). This preliminary study investigated sperm quality in A. m. capensis drones and how mixing semen from multiple drones might affect sperm behaviour and quality. It compared individual and mixed samples in vitro. The first aim was to determine whether mixing altered motility and kinematic measures. The second was to examine whether structural measures of sperm were associated with the observed function or behaviour. Materials and methods. See the original article. Results Semen-filled spermatheca of a honey bee queen This study examined functional and structural sperm traits after mixing drone semen in vitro. Tofilski et al. (2018) previously reported changes in sperm movement over time in queen spermathecae after instrumental and natural insemination. Little forward movement was visible in the first eight hours, although a small fraction of sperm moved rapidly forward. After 16 hours, the researchers observed coordinated circular movement and groups of spermatozoa swimming slowly in circles. The present experiment ended after 60 minutes. Most sperm in the mixed samples moved slowly and non-progressively, and some groups swam in circles. Total motility was initially highest in single- and two-drone samples. It fell markedly in two-drone samples by 60 minutes and declined less in three-drone samples. Borsuk et al. (2011) similarly found that mixing semen from two mature A. m. carnica drones initially produced very active sperm, but activity subsequently declined. They did not report the interval between observations. In the leaf-cutting ant Acromyrmex echinatior, a male’s own seminal fluid has been reported to produce a smaller increase in sperm motility, possibly helping maintain viability. Mixing it with the seminal fluid of a rival produced a larger increase in motility (Liberti et al. 2018). Total motility comprises progressively (PR) and non-progressively (NP) motile sperm. In two-drone samples, the proportion of non-progressive and slow sperm fell without a corresponding increase in progressive or faster swimmers. Instead, the proportion of immotile sperm rose by more than 50% relative to baseline as total motility declined. Mixing semen from two related drones may therefore have impaired sperm quality in this experiment. Damage to the sperm membrane could affect motility by disrupting the cell’s ability to retain substances needed for movement, such as ATP. A decline in ATP could leave sperm less motile or immotile. Superoxide dismutase (SOD) acts as an antioxidant and contributes to sperm survival and motility. Therefore, if excess ROS overwhelm the antioxidant defences in semen, oxidative stress can impair sperm function (Reinhardt 2007; Abdelkader et al. 2014, 2018). Oxidative stress may therefore have affected sperm in the two-drone samples. Because viability was not measured over time, the study cannot establish whether the increase in immotile sperm also meant that more sperm had died. Using sperm obtained from seminal vesicles, den Boer et al. (2010) found across six insect species, including honey bees and the leaf-cutting ants Atta colombica and Acromyrmex echinatior, that sperm survival improved with exposure to a male’s own seminal fluid. Survival fell when sperm were exposed to seminal fluid from a related or unrelated male of the same species.The authors suggested that seminal fluid may contain substances with opposing effects, some that impair rival sperm and others that support sperm survival. When Shafir et al. (2009) mixed semen from two unrelated drones and stored it for four days at 25 °C, the mixtures showed slightly higher viability than individual samples, but the difference was not statistically significant. Tofilski et al. (2012) found no difference in sperm viability when they assessed it after collection. Other studies found substantially lower viability in four-drone semen mixtures (below 50%) than in individual samples (Collins 2004). However, in mixtures of semen from five to eight drones (Collins 2003) or eight to ten drones (Gençer et al. 2014), viability did not change. Tofilski et al. (2012) also found more particles in two-drone samples and proposed a possible role for sperm competition, in which seminal fluid from one drone might cause coagulation and immobilise sperm from another. No coagulation was observed in the present experiment. Differences among studies may reflect collection, storage and sample preparation methods, which can damage sperm (Collins 2004; Shafir et al. 2009; Gençer et al. 2014). Sperm viability can also vary among individual drones (Collins 2004). Many other factors have been associated with reduced viability, including drone age. Environmental factors such as season, the availability of floral resources and exposure to parasites or pesticides may have a considerable influence (Rangel and Fisher 2019; Yániz et al. 2020; Morais et al. 2022).Varroa infestation levels and the acaricides used to control the mite should also be considered as possible influences on drone sperm viability (Collins 2004; Rinderer et al. 1999). Varroa infestation levels were not measured in the present study. Higher viability in the spermatheca than in ejaculates suggests that viability may play a role in which sperm are stored (Lodesani et al. 2004). Instrumental insemination Sperm viability matters in both the drone and the queen, but the mechanisms that preserve it appear to differ. For example, the levels of proteins involved in metabolism, including enzymes, differ considerably between spermathecal and seminal fluid. Spermathecal fluid contains more substances that support sperm survival (Collins et al. 2006; Baer et al. 2009). Dense packing of sperm in the spermatheca may help maintain viability by limiting dilution and, in turn, reducing osmotic stress and endogenous respiration. This can reduce the metabolic activity of densely packed sperm (Reinhardt 2007). In the spermatheca, limiting sperm motility may help preserve viability. Sodium and potassium concentrations are much higher in spermathecal fluid than in drone semen, which may contribute to reduced motility (Verma 1973). Immotile sperm appear more common in older queens, when sperm counts and hypertonicity are lower (Al-Lawati et al. 2009). However, reduced viability in pooled drone semen could be particularly relevant to instrumental insemination because sperm viability may decline faster in instrumentally inseminated queens than in naturally mated queens (Tarpy and Olivarez 2014; Lodesani et al. 2004). Loss of viable sperm can impair reproduction and eventually leave a queen laying unfertilised eggs that develop into drones. Nevertheless, one study found that instrumental insemination with semen of 42.6% viability still allowed queens to lay sufficient fertilised eggs under the conditions tested (Collins 2000). In contrast to the changes in the two-drone samples, mixing semen from three drones appeared to improve sperm movement over time. In this group, the proportions of non-progressively motile and slow-swimming sperm fell, while the proportions of progressively motile and faster-swimming sperm increased. Most of the resulting values were higher than those in single- and two-drone samples. This was also the only group in which all measured kinematic values increased over time, although the increases were not statistically significant. Increases were most apparent for VSL, LIN and STR. LIN is calculated from VSL and VCL, and STR from VSL and VAP. Higher total motility in honey bee sperm has been associated with greater progressive and rapid motility and higher VCL, VSL, VAP, LIN and STR in individual drone samples from seminal vesicles and ejaculates (Inouri-Iskounen et al. 2020; Murray et al. 2022). The authors propose that concentration, possible sperm cooperation and elapsed time together contributed to the changes observed in three-drone samples. These samples had higher sperm concentrations, which correlated positively with functional measures. Higher sperm concentration might increase viscosity and affect movement, as suggested by observations in the spermatheca (Tofilski et al. 2018). Al-Lawati et al. (2009) proposed that hypertonicity in the spermatheca might contribute to circular swimming. The authors speculate that hypertonicity could also have been higher in the more concentrated three-drone samples. Experiments with a humpbacked fly and a desert ant found greater sperm swimming speeds in more viscous media (Curtis and Benner 1991; Pearcy et al. 2014). Higher sperm concentration may also favour interactions among spermatozoa. In the eusocial desert ant Cataglyphis savignyi, dozens of spermatozoa form bundles that swim 50% faster than individual sperm. Such cooperation might increase a male’s contribution to the sperm that reach and remain in the spermatheca (Pearcy et al. 2014). Changes in drone sperm movement have also been attributed to the time between observations, which can allow sperm to settle into stable movement patterns (Tofilski et al. 2018; Yániz et al. 2019). Conditions in a queen’s reproductive tract and spermatheca differ from those in ejaculates.After successful mating or insemination, only a fraction of spermatozoa are stored. Woyciechowski and Król (1996) found that the number stored did not vary with the number of drones whose semen was used for instrumental insemination. In A. m. capensis queens, spermathecal counts appear to range from 3 to 11 million spermatozoa in a volume of about 1 µL. Sample concentrations in all groups fell within this range, but how such variation affects movement in the spermatheca is unknown. Variation in sperm concentration agrees with previous findings in the same subspecies (Murray et al. 2022). A. m. capensis sperm appear shorter than those of other subspecies, such as A. m. carnica, which may affect movement (Gontarz et al. 2016). Sperm in the spermatheca also encounter spermathecal fluid and rely more on anaerobic metabolism than sperm in ejaculates (Liu et al. 2020). Sperm length can influence function and motility in insects (Fitzpatrick and Lüpold 2014). In Drosophila, for example, longer sperm swim more slowly than shorter sperm but can better resist expulsion from the female reproductive tract (Lüpold et al. 2012). In this experiment, sperm dimensions did not differ among the three groups and were not correlated with motility measures. In the wasp Dahlbominus fuscipennis, five sperm types occur in male seminal vesicles while spermathecae are uniform in size (Lee and Wilkes 1965). Seasonal variation in honey bee sperm dimensions has been reported (Gontarz et al. 2016), but sperm polymorphism among cells that reach and remain in the honey bee spermatheca after mating has yet to be described. The shorter sperm of A. m. capensis may move differently from the longer sperm of other subspecies. A limitation is that drone body size was not measured. Earlier studies associated body size with sperm concentration or the number of spermatozoa per ejaculate (Schlüns et al. 2003; Bratu et al. 2022) and with the occurrence of abnormal sperm (Bratu et al. 2022). The authors’ earlier laboratory work, however, did not suggest an adverse effect of body weight on sperm concentration. Conclusions Differences in motility and kinematic measures may reflect a combination of semen mixing, sperm concentration and changes in sperm arrangement over time. The study did not establish a genetic cause. In vitro mixing also excludes the queen’s potential influence on sperm use after mating, including cryptic female choice. In natural mating, only a fraction of the sperm received is stored in the spermatheca. Alongside environmental influences, drone sperm quality may affect queen health and reproduction through post-mating changes, with consequences for colony health and performance (Brutscher et al. 2019). Everted endophallus with exposed semen The findings may be relevant to instrumental insemination programmes and beekeepers. Measures such as concentration, motility and viability can help assess the quality of a pooled semen sample before insemination. Their value as indicators of subsequent queen and colony health warrants further investigation. To clarify the mechanisms behind changes after mixing, the authors propose testing several sperm concentrations, measuring reactive oxygen species and mitochondrial function, and examining sperm traits in the queen’s spermatheca. Routine use in beekeeping would also require simple, affordable methods for assessing drone semen. Authors Retha CM Kotzé (Department of Medical Bioscience, University of the Western Cape, Bellville, South Africa) Gerhard van der Horst (Department of Medical Bioscience, University of the Western Cape, Bellville, South Africa) Janice F Murray (Department of Medical Bioscience, University of the Western Cape, Bellville, South Africa) Anja Duminy (Department of Medical Bioscience, University of the Western Cape, Bellville, South Africa, and Applied Research Centre, Langara College, Vancouver, Canada) Mike Allsopp (Honey Bee Research Section, ARC-Plant Protection Research Institute, Stellenbosch, South Africa) African Entomology, 2024 · Adapted from the cited article under CC BY 4.0 https://doi.org/10.17159/2254-8854/2024/a17135
- Efficacy of oxalic acid vaporisation against Varroa mites
Varroa mites (Varroa destructor) are a major threat to honey bee health worldwide. Oxalic acid has become popular among beekeepers as a potential control agent. This study evaluated oxalic acid vaporisation under field conditions. Study methods Twenty-four Italian honey bee colonies (Apis mellifera ligustica) in Taiwan were divided into six groups of four. One group was untreated, four received two, four, six or eight oxalic acid applications at two applications per week, and one received flumethrin strips (40 mg per strip). The experimental dose was about 2 g of oxalic acid per hive per application. By day 35, the six- and eight-application groups showed reductions in infestation of 86.78% and 97.65%, respectively, according to Table 2. Results and discussion Worker mortality was significantly higher in colonies receiving four, six or eight applications than in untreated controls. Six or eight applications at the experimental dose (2 g per hive) reduced infestation substantially under these field conditions, with an accompanying increase in worker mortality. Colony standardisation Italian honey bee colonies (Apis mellifera ligustica) naturally infested at varying levels were used. A week before the trial, the colonies were standardised using the Liebefeld visual estimation method, to approximately 2,500 workers per frame and 50% brood area (Bhusal et al., 2011; Dainat et al., 2020). The method estimates the number of adult workers on each side of a frame and the areas occupied by open brood, capped brood, honey and pollen stores. Treatments and monitoring The experiment compared an untreated control, four oxalic acid (OA) groups receiving two, four, six or eight applications, and a flumethrin strip group (40 mg per strip, Table 1). OA was applied twice weekly, on Sunday and Wednesday at 15:00, over periods of 7–28 days. Infestation was assessed twice weekly. The paper gives different weekdays for mite counts in different parts of the methods. The researchers also monitored whether the queen was present in each trial hive. Effect of oxalic acid on Varroa mites At day 35, the percentage reduction in Varroa infestation was significantly greater with eight OA applications than with any other regimen or control (F = 165.84, df = 5, P < 0.01). Figure 3 shows no significant difference between the flumethrin group and the four- or six-application groups. This comparison is between groups. Compared with baseline, infestation declined significantly by day 35 in all four OA groups and the flumethrin group (each P < 0.01). In untreated controls it rose significantly (P < 0.01). The relative reduction ranged from 35.42% to 97.65% across the OA regimens, whereas controls recorded a 51.77% increase (Table 2). Bee mortality By day 35, total worker mortality was significantly higher after four, six or eight OA applications than in controls (F = 14.64, df = 5, P = 0.01), with no significant differences among those three OA groups. Mortality in the flumethrin group differed significantly from those three groups. It did not differ significantly from the two-application or control groups (Fig. 5). The groups showed three patterns. Mortality was highest with four, six or eight OA applications, intermediate with flumethrin or two OA applications, and consistently lowest in controls. The number of dead workers in controls was about half that in the four-, six- and eight-application groups. Conclusions Table 2 reports reductions of 86.78% and 97.65% after six and eight applications. The discussion gives 82% and 98%, so the table values are used here. The precise mode of action remains uncertain. Proposed mechanisms include exposure to airborne OA and contact with crystals. Schneider et al. (2012) suggested that OA may stimulate grooming, which can dislodge mites. Contact with oxalic acid has been investigated as an explanation for mite mortality (Aliano et al., 2006; Aliano and Ellis, 2008; Papežíková et al., 2017). Wallner and Fries (2003) proposed a role for lower pH. Contact toxicity and changes in bee behaviour may contribute to the observed effect, but the trial did not establish their respective roles or prove that the exposure is harmless to bees. Final considerations Oxalic acid vaporisation is among the methods studied for managing Varroa. Under the conditions of this trial, six or eight applications at 2 g per hive twice weekly reduced infestation by day 35. This was an experimental regimen in groups of four colonies. Worker mortality increased with the more frequent regimens. The low cost and availability of OA are practical advantages, but the trial does not establish general superiority over other treatments. Field use must follow authorised product instructions and applicable operator protection requirements. Further research could compare application methods, timing in relation to brood cycles and combinations with other integrated pest management strategies. The aim is to protect colony health and productivity over time while limiting selection for acaricide resistance. Published January 2026 Authors: Pierre Enock Philémon, Lekhnath Kafle - Department of Tropical Agriculture and International Cooperation, National Pingtung University of Science and Technology, Taiwan Ravindra Chandra Joshi - Entomology, Philippine Rice Research Institute, Philippines Full article and author details: JOURNAL OF APICULTURAL SCIENCE VOL. 70 NO. 1 2026 Translated by Davide Simeone
- Beeswax: properties and contamination
Chemical composition and physical properties Beeswax is a heterogeneous material whose exact composition can vary slightly with nectar plants, bee age and environmental factors. Nevertheless, a general chemical profile can be described. Chemical profile Virgin beeswax Virgin beeswax contains more than 300 identified constituents or fractions. The following approximate proportions illustrate its main groups; values vary by sample and analytical method. Fatty acid esters (about 70%): They make up the largest fraction. Many consist of long-chain primary alcohols (C₂₄–C₃₂) esterified with long-chain fatty acids (C₁₆–C₂₄). Myricyl palmitate, or triacontanyl palmitate (C₁₅H₃₁COOC₃₀H₆₁), is a prominent wax ester. Free fatty acids (about 9–14%): Examples include cerotic acid (C₂₆H₅₂O₂) and melissic acid (C₃₀H₆₀O₂). Hydrocarbons (about 13–16%): Mainly straight-chain alkanes (n-alkanes) with odd numbers of carbon atoms, including chains from C₂₁ to C₃₃. Heptacosane (C₂₇H₅₆) and hentriacontane (C₃₁H₆₄) are among the most abundant. Minor constituents: These include free alcohols, commonly around 1%, as well as lactones, resins, pigments such as chrysin, and traces of propolis. Physical properties The physical characteristics of beeswax determine how it serves as a structural material in the hive: Melting range: 62–65 °C. Solidification temperature: About 60.5–61 °C. Density: About 0.95–0.96 g/cm³ at 15 °C. Saponification value: About 85–105 mg KOH/g, depending on the specification. Acid value: 17–24 mg KOH/g. These physicochemical parameters help assess wax purity and screen for possible adulteration. Acaricide and pesticide contamination and residue limits Because of its lipophilic nature, beeswax acts as a reservoir for lipophilic chemicals in the environment or those intentionally used by beekeepers to control disease and parasites, particularly the mite Varroa destructor. Residue limits and regulations There is no internationally harmonised maximum residue limit (MRL) covering beeswax generally, unlike the pesticide MRL framework for honey under Regulation (EC) No 396/2005, as amended. Hive foundation wax is not ordinarily consumed as food sensu stricto, although beeswax also has food uses. Residues can transfer to other hive products and affect bee health. Applicable limits depend on use and production standards, including organic rules. Frequently detected compounds include: Synthetic acaricides: Coumaphos (an organophosphate), tau-fluvalinate (a pyrethroid), and amitraz (a formamidine), often detected through its breakdown products. Wax surveys such as Mullin et al. (2010) found some residues at mg/kg levels in brood comb wax. Chauzat et al. (2006) examined residues in collected pollen. Agricultural pesticides: Insecticides including neonicotinoids and organophosphates, herbicides and fungicides. Surveys also find residues from these groups. In EU organic production, wax is subject to specific origin and replacement requirements, including replacement with organic wax during conversion under Regulation (EU) 2018/848. The narrow exception for non-organic cappings wax has conditions, including evidence of freedom from substances not authorised in organic production. There is no general allowance for historical residues below a single threshold. Effects on bee health: focus on reproductive castes Substances accumulating in comb may chronically expose the whole colony to sublethal doses. Effects on reproductive individuals are particularly relevant to colony survival. Queen and drone cells are made of wax, so residues can expose developing bees during sensitive stages. Effects on queens Exposure of queen larvae to lipophilic residues in wax, including agricultural pesticides and in-hive acaricides such as coumaphos and fluvalinate, can affect queen development. Effects depend on the compound, dose and exposure: Queen cell on contaminated comb Reduced viability and survival: Some experiments involving coumaphos or tau-fluvalinate found reduced queen emergence or lower weight at emergence. These findings depend on dose and study design (Haarmann et al., 2002; Collins et al., 2004). Reproductive abnormalities: Studies have reported effects on ovarian development or egg laying under some exposures. Poor queen performance can weaken a colony and contribute to supersedure by workers, but smaller ovarioles, reduced egg production and rapid replacement are not universal consequences of contaminated wax (Pettis et al., 2004; Collins et al., 2004). Reduced longevity: Developmental exposure may affect adult queen survival even when it does not kill larvae immediately. The long-term consequences for colony stability depend on exposure and subsequent queen performance. Effects on drones and sperm viability Drones, essential for mating with queens, are also vulnerable. Their cells are generally wider and can contain contaminated wax, exposing developing drones to residues. A larger cell alone does not establish a higher residue concentration. Altered development: Acaricide exposure during development can affect drones. Outcomes such as delayed emergence, smaller body size or shorter lifespan depend on the substance and dose; the study by Fisher and Rangel (2018) specifically assessed sperm viability after developmental exposure in contaminated wax. Exposure to some acaricide and pesticide residues in wax can reduce sperm viability; effects on motility depend on the exposure Semen quality and sperm viability: Experimental exposure to some neonicotinoids and to fipronil has affected drone reproductive measures such as sperm count, viability or motility, depending on the substance, dose and route (Straub et al., 2016; Kairo et al., 2017). These experiments are not all wax exposures and do not show that every low dose affects all measures. Poor semen quality can compromise queen fertility and colony performance, without making early colony failure inevitable. Adulteration risks: paraffin and stearin The high cost and limited availability of pure beeswax have encouraged fraudulent adulteration. Common adulterants include petroleum-derived hydrocarbons (paraffin wax) and materials rich in fatty acids of animal or plant origin (stearin or added stearic acid). Paraffin wax Paraffin wax is a mixture of solid saturated hydrocarbons (alkanes) derived from petroleum. Adding it changes the natural hydrocarbon profile of beeswax. Risks for bees: Structural weakening and thermal collapse: Paraffin can change the melting behaviour and mechanical properties of wax. Weaker comb can fail under honey loads or in summer heat, causing loss of brood and food. The risk depends on the type and proportion of paraffin and conditions; 10–15% is not a universal collapse threshold. Interference with chemical cues: Beeswax contributes to chemical communication and nestmate recognition. Foreign hydrocarbons may interfere with those cues, but the effect depends on the adulterant and should not be assumed for all mixtures. Potentially toxic impurities: Low-grade paraffin that does not meet food or pharmaceutical specifications may contain potentially harmful impurities, including polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). Stearin and stearic acid Stearic acid (C₁₈H₃₆O₂) is a saturated fatty acid. Stearin is a commercial mixture, not pure stearic acid. These adulterants can alter hardness and workability and may be used alongside paraffin to disguise adulteration. Brood on adulterated wax: some adulterants can cause larval mortality Risks for bees: High brood toxicity (lethal effects): Unlike paraffin, which mainly weakened comb in a comparative experiment, stearin in foundation reduced brood survival directly. Experiments have found deaths of young larvae, sometimes leaving uncapped cells and a patchy brood pattern despite normal queen laying. That appearance can resemble disease, so it is not diagnostic by itself (Chęć et al., 2021, DOI: 10.1007/s13592-020-00833-7). Comb acceptance and disrupted brood rearing: Workers may draw some adulterated foundations poorly, and laying or brood development in those areas may be impaired. Responses vary with the mixture. In the stearin experiment, the queens laid normally, so patchy brood did not establish that they avoided laying there. Analytical methods for detecting impurities Gas chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry (GC–MS) is a principal method for profiling wax lipids and detecting adulteration. Hydrocarbon profiles can reveal added paraffin, while free fatty acid profiles can indicate added stearin. Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) is also useful for rapid screening. Pesticide residues can be measured after extraction using methods such as QuEChERS, followed by liquid chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry (LC–MS/MS) or gas chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry (GC–MS/MS). Conclusions Beeswax quality is critical to both the structure of the hive and the reproduction and biological success of Apis mellifera. Pesticides and acaricides accumulating in wax can harm queen development and viability and impair drone reproductive function, including sperm viability, depending on exposure. Adulteration with stearin can cause substantial larval mortality and threaten colony health. Traceable wax supply chains, regular comb renewal and analytical checks for adulteration are important measures for safeguarding beekeeping and biodiversity. Selected references Chauzat, M. P., Faucon, J. P., Martel, A. C., Lachaize, J., Cougoule, N., & Aubert, M. (2006). A survey of pesticide residues in pollen loads collected by honey bees in France. Journal of Economic Entomology, 99(2), 253-262. Collins, A. M., Pettis, J. S., Wilbanks, R., & Feldlaufer, M. F. (2004). Performance of honey bee (Apis mellifera) queens reared in beeswax cells impregnated with coumaphos. Journal of Apicultural Research, 43(3), 128–134. DOI: 10.1080/00218839.2004.11101123. Haarmann, T., Spivak, M., Weaver, D., Weaver, B., & Glenn, T. (2002). Effects of fluvalinate and coumaphos on queen honey bees (Hymenoptera: Apidae) in two commercial queen rearing operations. Journal of Economic Entomology, 95(1), 28-35. Kairo, G., Biron, D. G., Ben Abdelkader, F., Bonnet, M., Tchamitchian, S., Cousin, M., ... & Brunet, J. L. (2017). Nosema ceranae, Fipronil and their combination compromise honey bee reproduction via changes in male physiology. Scientific Reports, 7, 8556. DOI: 10.1038/s41598-017-08380-5. Mullin, C. A., Frazier, M., Frazier, J. L., Ashcraft, S., Simonds, R., vanEngelsdorp, D., & Pettis, J. S. (2010). High levels of miticides and agrochemicals in North American apiaries: implications for honey bee health. PLOS ONE, 5(3), e9754. Pettis, J. S., Collins, A. M., Wilbanks, R., & Feldlaufer, M. F. (2004). Effects of coumaphos on queen rearing in the honey bee, Apis mellifera. Apidologie, 35(6), 605-610. Fisher, A., & Rangel, J. (2018). Exposure to pesticides during development negatively affects honey bee (Apis mellifera) drone sperm viability. PLOS ONE, 13(12), e0208630. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0208630. Serra Bonvehí, J., & Orantes Bermejo, F. J. (2012). Detection of adulterated commercial Spanish beeswax. Food Chemistry, 132(1), 642–648. DOI: 10.1016/j.foodchem.2011.10.104. Straub, L., Villamar-Bouza, L., Bruckner, S., Chantawannakul, P., Gauthier, L., Khongphinitbunjong, K., ... & Williams, G. R. (2016). Neonicotinoid insecticides can serve as inadvertent contraceptive for honey bees. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 283(1835), 20160506. Published 15 May 2026 – Davide Simeone
- The honey bee queen’s spermatheca
The survival of a queen and her colony depends in part on her ability to sustain a large population. At the seasonal peak, she can lay about 1,500–2,000 eggs a day, more than her own body weight. Her paired ovaries contain roughly 360 ovarioles in total, where eggs form (Snodgrass, 1956). A queen needs a sufficient reserve of sperm to sustain fertilisation at high laying rates. She can keep stored sperm viable for years. The role of the spermatheca The spermatheca stores sperm and occurs in many insects and other invertebrates. In the honey bee queen it is a fluid-filled sphere about one millimetre across. Its wall includes a single layer of epithelial cells, and a network of tracheae covers the outside. Stored sperm are largely immotile and retain their fertilising capacity in a specialised environment. The tracheal network surrounds the organ, and spermathecal glands contribute to its fluid (Fyg, 1983, and Koeniger, 1986, as cited in the original article). Measurements by Paynter et al. (2017) found very low oxygen inside the spermatheca, consistent with a greater reliance on non-aerobic energy production during storage. After mating, sperm migrate from the oviducts to the spermatheca over roughly one to two days. Conditions during this period matter. Worker attendance, colony nutrition and population can influence the process (Woyke, 1983). Beekeepers can improve these conditions through colony management. After returning from a mating flight, the queen receives close attention from workers. They follow her across the combs, touch her with their antennae, lick and feed her, and help remove the mating sign. Worker care and the queen's activity can support sperm migration. Egg laying generally starts several days after the final mating. Colony conditions and seasonal changes affect egg production. Adequate nutrition supports egg development. A sufficiently large, healthy workforce warms the brood nest, cares for the queen and rears the brood. Laying varies with resources, colony demand and season. As the queen ages, she may release fewer sperm per fertilised egg (Harbo, 1979). Older queens can produce fewer workers and more drone brood. Fyg (1983) described deposits of complex carbohydrate-associated proteins on the spermatheca, sometimes appearing from about two years of age. He suggested that such deposits might damage the wall cells and affect stored sperm. Why reproductive status matters To keep productive colonies economically viable, beekeepers need to know the origin, age and reproductive status of their queens. Unplanned queen replacement can reduce output and lead to the loss of desirable colony characteristics. A field examination of the spermatheca can help clarify a queen's reproductive status. Comparing it with observations of the colony helps identify problems and make better-informed management decisions. I usually examine older queens when replacing them or when a queen appears to be underperforming. The examination helps assess whether sperm entered storage and can support a diagnosis of a virgin or poorly mated queen. A young queen suspected of mating poorly may be examined if there are several eggs in one cell or eggs on the cell wall. Colony conditions matter too, since laying workers and insufficient laying space may produce similar signs. Appearance alone cannot predict remaining productive life. Research on some Varroa treatments has identified possible fertility effects in queens and drones, depending on the compound and exposure. For queen breeders, field examination helps assess whether there are enough mature drones to achieve the desired mating quality and sperm stores. Adequate sperm reserves and genetic diversity both matter. Taylor and Rowell (1988) recommended placing drone-producing colonies one to two kilometres from mating stations in the setting they studied. When the weather is marginal, examination can show whether queens stored sperm successfully. Combined with other quality measures, that information helps breeders assess and select their stock. The examination also gives feedback when learning instrumental insemination. In my courses it provides a quick indication of progress. After insemination, queens are held in a queen bank for one or two days and examined to see whether sperm migrated to the spermatheca. Waiting about two days after insemination allows sperm time to migrate from the oviducts. After one day migration may still be incomplete and the oviducts may contain semen, although cloudiness can show that some sperm have reached the spermatheca. Field examination of the spermatheca A queen's spermatheca can be examined in the field using the fingers or fine forceps. The test requires sacrificing the queen. Beekeepers can carry it out when removing a queen that has already been selected for replacement. First, kill the queen promptly by crushing the head and thorax. Then grasp the last abdominal segment from its dorsal and ventral sides with a thumbnail or forceps. Separate the terminal segment from the body. The gut and a large, translucent, irregular venom sac become visible. Among these tissues is a small, robust, spherical structure about one millimetre across. This is the spermatheca, with a transparent chitinous lining. The organ first appears whitish and rough because a tracheal network covers it. Gently free the spermatheca from the surrounding tissue with the thumbnail. To remove the covering, gently roll the spermatheca between the fingers. The tracheae collect into a separate white mass, exposing the organ. Colour and opacity give a rough indication of the queen's reproductive status. Comparing specimens helps distinguish a virgin queen from one with stored sperm and can suggest whether a queen stored little sperm or has depleted reserves. The appearance gives a qualitative estimate. The presence and intensity of colour reflect the contents of the spermatheca. A virgin queen's spermatheca is usually clear, and the transparent wall is visible. In a queen with substantial sperm stores, the spermatheca is creamy or coffee-coloured with lighter and darker marbled swirls, resembling drone semen. Dense bands of sperm produce the pattern. The photographs compare a virgin and a well-mated queen. A cloudy or milky appearance may indicate a smaller sperm reserve. Differences in shading reflect differences in sperm density. Direct counts and viability tests are needed for quantitative assessment. A lack of contrasting marbling can suggest a low reserve. A queen that depletes her viable sperm may start laying more unfertilised eggs, which develop into drones. Examining queens at different stages helps the beekeeper recognise these visual patterns. Queen assessment Queen assessment is an essential part of beekeeping. Beekeepers who observe each colony and manage it carefully can use occasional dissection of a queen selected for removal to inform their decisions. That can help anticipate and prevent some economically costly problems. A field examination can resolve some questions without specialised equipment. Beekeepers can learn to recognise differences in the colour and opacity of the spermatheca. Assess the queen alongside the brood pattern and the condition of the colony. Recognising a persistent decline in laying can help determine when a queen no longer meets the colony's needs. Dissection can help clarify whether a queen suspected of being virgin or poorly mated stored sperm. Sound management includes replacing queens whose performance has persistently declined. The quality of replacement queens varies. Uncontrolled mating can change the expression of selected traits over generations, with consequences for labour and production. Used selectively, examination of the spermatheca helps beekeepers understand queen performance and investigate problems earlier. It is one tool for maintaining strong colonies with desired production characteristics. Conclusion Varroa profoundly changed beekeeping. Repeated chemical treatments can select for resistant mites. The bacterium that causes American foulbrood can also develop resistance to some antibiotics. Resistance and virulence are different traits, and routine chemical use can leave underlying colony vulnerability unaddressed. The article calls for greater attention to breeding productive bees with natural resistance to diseases and parasites. Applying this approach requires understanding the relationship between bee biology and breeding. Geneticist Rob Page likens bee breeding to pressing on a balloon: pressure in one place can cause unexpected changes elsewhere. The complexity and dynamics of honey bee behaviour create distinctive challenges, and many interactions remain to be understood. Much agricultural progress has come from breeding animals and crops. Bee breeding faces particular constraints. Related matings can fix traits and increase uniformity, but honey bees are sensitive to inbreeding, notably because of their complementary sex-determination system. Diversity and flexibility in behavioural traits help the colony function as a superorganism. Breeders must select production queens for several traits at once. Traits of economic interest are often behavioural, polygenic and strongly influenced by the environment, making assessment difficult. Controlling mating adds another challenge. It is difficult to maintain selected stocks when queens mate with multiple drones of unknown origin. Isolated mating stations supplied with selected drones and instrumental insemination are ways to control parentage. Breeding programmes also require specialised work and long-term commitment. The article reflects the state of practical bee breeding at the time it was written. Research has often focused on individual traits. Stocks selected for traits such as Varroa resistance offer a starting point for introducing resistance into commercial apiaries. The author notes that practical guidance on developing and running breeding programmes was then limited. The Page–Laidlaw closed-population breeding programme offers a practical approach to improving commercial stocks (Page and Laidlaw, 1982). Their book Queen Rearing and Bee Breeding covers the technical foundations. Growing beekeeper interest and new research methods offer opportunities to improve commercial stocks. This article introduces the basic elements of practical bee breeding. A broad supply of high-quality stocks can help build a healthier and more resilient industry. The Spermatheca, by Susan Cobey (Italian translation by Gabriele Milli, from American Bee Journal, March 2003)
- Varroa destructor and hives: biology, damage and summer strategies to protect colonies while maintaining honey production
Yes, the response had been interrupted. I’ll resume here with a version ready for publication. The mite Varroa destructor is the main parasite of the honey bee and the most delicate health issue for any beekeeper, amateur or professional. It does more than weaken individual bees: it disrupts the balance of the whole colony, reduces brood quality, spreads viruses and can cause colony collapse between late summer and winter. ScienceDirect Oxford Academic The key point is this: Varroa requires informed management, not just treatment. This means understanding its life cycle, correctly assessing colony condition, choosing authorised active substances and intervening at the right time. Summer increases the difficulty, because two often conflicting needs must be reconciled: containing infestation and protecting honey production. Why Varroa is so dangerous for the hive The mite Varroa destructor is an ectoparasitic mite originally associated with Apis cerana and now well adapted to Apis mellifera. Its danger depends not only on the number of mites present, but also on the parasite acting at several levels simultaneously: it takes resources from adult and immature bees; it reproduces in capped brood; it reduces bee vitality, longevity and immune competence; it promotes virus circulation, particularly viruses in the deformed wing virus complex. ScienceDirect PMC A colony can therefore still appear strong in midsummer while already heading towards severe weakening. The real damage often emerges later, when the bees intended to overwinter emerge already compromised. How Varroa destructor reproduces Understanding the reproductive biology of Varroa is the first step towards controlling it effectively. The adult female alternates between two phases: Phoretic phase: Varroa slips between the tergites and sternites of adult bees while waiting to enter a brood cell nearing capping the phoretic phase, when it is on adult bees; the reproductive phase, which takes place inside capped brood cells. Oxford Academic Shortly before a cell is sealed, the mite enters the brood cell, hides in the larval food and begins reproducing when the bee reaches the prepupal stage. The first egg generally produces a male, and subsequent eggs females. Mating occurs within the same cell; when the bee emerges, the mother mite and mature, mated daughters leave. Oxford Academic Varroa also shows a practically important preference for drone brood, because the drone’s longer development period allows greater reproductive output. This detail has major practical consequences: in spring and early summer, when brood is abundant, growth of the Varroa population also accelerates. Damage caused to bees Varroa damage is not only quantitative, but also qualitative. Bees developing in infested cells may emerge: with lower body mass; with shorter life expectancy; with reduced immune efficiency; with altered behaviour; in the most severe cases, with recognisable clinical signs such as deformed wings. ScienceDirect Parasitised adult bees are less efficient at feeding brood, thermoregulation and foraging. At colony level, this means a less productive, less stable hive that is more vulnerable to environmental stress. Deformed wing virus (DWV) transmitted by Varroa destructor. The colony declines rapidly as bees become unable to perform their tasks It is also now clear that Varroa plays a fundamental role as a biological vector of viruses. Some studies have shown that viruses important in bee disease, including DWV-A and DWV-B, can replicate in the mite, reinforcing its epidemiological role. PMC Why controlling the Varroa population is essential The realistic goal is not to eliminate Varroa completely, but to keep it below the intervention threshold continuously. Without control, parasite dynamics are highly likely to cause colony deterioration incompatible with good autumn and winter survival. ScienceDirect Sound management rests on three pillars: regular monitoring of infestation levels; targeted treatment with authorised medicines; integration with biotechnical methods to improve efficacy and adapt the strategy to the season. Oxford Academic This is crucial in summer: waiting until all harvests are over can mean acting too late to protect the bees that must overwinter. Authorised Varroa treatments: active substances and main brand names In Europe and Italy, the most relevant active substances for Varroa control include amitraz, thymol, formic acid and oxalic acid. The following brand names often appear in technical literature and among products on the market: Active substance Examples of commercial products General technical profile Amitraz Apivar Synthetic acaricide requiring a planned course; follow the label, including honey-super restrictions Thymol Apiguard, Api Life Var Temperature-sensitive product, useful in suitable seasonal windows Formic acid MAQS, Formic Pro Of interest because it can also act in the presence of capped brood Oxalic acid Api-Bioxal and equivalent authorised formulations Highly effective especially when brood is absent or after a brood interruption Scientific literature supports the role of these substances in Varroa management, but practical choices must always comply with current national authorisation, the product label and the conditions of use actually permitted. Oxford Academic Which products are most suitable in summer Summer is the most complex time of the beekeeping year: honey production often continues, brood is abundant and Varroa keeps multiplying. There is therefore no single solution suitable for every hive. Amitraz: effective, but better suited to after harvest The active substance amitraz, for example in Apivar, is an important tool, but generally fits best when honey supers have been removed and treatment can follow the authorised conditions. The literature also highlights the risk of resistance with repeated or poorly planned use. Oxford Academic ScienceDirect Thymol: useful at suitable temperatures The active substance Thymol, found in Apiguard and Api Life Var, is a useful option but highly dependent on environmental conditions. Excessive heat can cause overly rapid volatilisation and stress the colony; overly cool conditions can reduce efficacy. In many situations it is therefore better suited to late summer than to peak midseason temperatures. Oxford Academic Formic acid: particularly useful when brood is abundant The active substance Formic acid, in the formulations MAQS and Formic Pro, has an important technical advantage: it can reach at least some of the Varroa within capped brood. This makes it particularly useful when brood is abundant and intervention cannot be delayed for long. Oxford Academic However, this treatment requires close attention to: outside temperature; hive ventilation; colony strength; queen condition; any nutritional or climatic stress. Tolerance can be poorer in weak nucleus colonies or very hot conditions. Oxalic acid: excellent, but only in the right window The active substance Oxalic acid, as in Api-Bioxal, remains a mainstay of Varroa control, but performs best when the colony is broodless or has almost no brood. In midsummer, when the queen is laying heavily, it is rarely sufficient alone for complete control. ScienceDirect Oxford Academic It can instead be highly effective when applied following a brood interruption. Choosing treatment according to colony conditions Before treatment, four technical questions are worth asking: Question Why it matters Is there abundant capped brood? If so, a substantial proportion of Varroa is protected inside cells Are honey supers present? This determines the treatment’s practical and regulatory compatibility What are the actual temperatures in the apiary? Thymol and formic acid are strongly climate-dependent Is the colony strong and stable? Weak colonies tolerate more demanding treatments less well Other considerations include queen condition, infestation level, late honey flows and the risk of reinfestation from neighbouring apiaries. Can honey production continue during Varroa control? A precise farm-wide strategy to contain Varroa destructor underpins successful beekeeping production The correct answer is: yes, but not in the simplistic sense of “treat everything and carry on as before”. The most professional strategy considers not only the individual colony, but the organisation of the entire apiary. The goal is not to force harvesting and treatment to occur simultaneously in every hive, but to maintain production across the operation while some colonies undergo health management. Any grouping must respect label requirements for simultaneous treatment and reinfestation control. 1. Treat promptly when colonies finish their harvest Some colonies can leave the production line as soon as the main harvest ends. This enables prompt intervention without dangerous delays, protecting the bees that must face autumn. 2. Manage the operation in groups A useful strategy is to divide colonies into groups: colonies in full production; colonies out of production and under treatment; nucleus or support colonies for balancing and strengthening. This allows honey production to continue without sacrificing overall apiary health, provided treatment synchronisation requirements are met. 3. Use biotechnical methods to create treatment windows Biotechnical methods can reduce Varroa and make subsequent treatments more effective. The most useful summer methods are: drone brood removal; temporary queen caging; planned brood interruption; creating nucleus colonies or artificial swarms. When a broodless window is created, oxalic acid performs much better. This is one of the most useful ways to reconcile health and production needs. 4. Consider formic acid while brood remains abundant When environmental conditions and the label permit, formic acid can be useful for colonies that cannot wait through a long production break. It nevertheless requires caution, especially in late summer and very hot areas. Practical summer advice Do not wait until every harvest is completely finished if Varroa levels are already rising alarmingly. Check for capped brood before choosing a treatment: it fundamentally changes the efficacy of active substances. Assess actual apiary temperatures carefully, especially when considering thymol or formic acid. Adapt management to colony conditions: grouping the operation can protect production and overall health, while respecting requirements for simultaneous treatment. Use biotechnical methods to create windows of greater efficacy, especially for oxalic acid. Remove honey supers as soon as possible from colonies requiring treatment. Use only authorised products and always follow labels, doses, seasonal limits and conditions of use. Check treatment efficacy: without follow-up monitoring, you cannot know whether the colony has truly been protected. Published: 28 June 2026 Author: Davide Simeone
- Black queen cell virus (BQCV): a practical analysis of associations
Queen cell infected with BQCV The “black queen cell virus” in honey bees (Black Queen Cell Virus – BQCV) causes a viral disease affecting mainly queen larvae, which darken and die before emergence. Infection can occur vertically, when a virus-carrying queen lays infected eggs, or horizontally, through young workers cleaning recently vacated cells that contained infected individuals, or infected nurse bees feeding queen larvae with contaminated royal jelly. 🦠 1. Direct viral infection (BQCV) The primary cause is infection with Black Queen Cell Virus, a virus in the family Dicistroviridae. The virus replicates in queen larvae, causing necrosis and darkening of the queen cell. Vertical transmission is one possible route, alongside horizontal transmission. 🐝 2. Transmission through nurse bees Nurse bees can pass the virus to larvae through: contaminated royal jelly; oral contact; cell cleaning. Queen larvae are particularly exposed because they receive more frequent and more abundant feeding. 🧪 3. Contamination of equipment and beekeeping materials The virus may also spread through: contaminated combs and hives; queen-rearing equipment. 🌡️ 4. Environmental and nutritional stress Other factors that can weaken colonies and increase susceptibility: insufficient protein nutrition (monocultures or poor forage); exposure to pesticides, fungicides and foliar fertilisers; extreme weather; transport stress. 🧫 5. Coinfection or stress from Nosema spp. Infection with Nosema apis or Nosema ceranae has been associated with BQCV in several contexts. Nosema can impair adult bee physiology and defences; coinfection can increase mortality, although increased viral replication or colony-level disease is not a universal consequence. 🐝 6. Other parasites The mite Varroa destructor is not considered a primary BQCV vector, but mite-related stress can favour secondary viral problems. It is useful to examine unexpected or management-induced stresses on immunity, their association with Nosema spp., and the potential amplification of problems through inappropriate beekeeping practices. Among unexpected stressors are extreme weather events leading to unanticipated nutritional stress, such as spring frosts and sudden temperature increases, as well as incoming nectar and pollen contaminated with pesticides, fungicides or foliar fertilisers. These conditions can weaken bees’ overall defences. Nosema apis (left) and Nosema ceranae (right) For management-induced stressors, relevant practices include those associated with breeding operations: removing combs to create nucleus colonies; reusing food-store frames from colonies infected with Nosema spp. or BQCV; failing to renew comb or renewing less than the suggested 30% annually (not a universal disease threshold); seasonally inappropriate feeding; and chemical treatments against Varroa destructor. For unexpected stresses, we can try to anticipate them and put bees in the best condition to cope. Management-induced stresses offer more opportunities for prevention. One frequently reported practice is indiscriminate oxalic acid (OA) use: repeated applications to the same bee generation at varying concentrations. OA can be relatively safe when used correctly, but this does not mean that it leaves no residues whatsoever. It remains a corrosive acid and can harm bees if misused. OA trickling in the absence of brood 🧪 Damage oxalic acid can cause to bees Oxalic acid is relatively safe only when used correctly. Overdosing, overly frequent applications or unsuitable environmental conditions can cause adverse effects: 🐝 Effects on individual bees Damage to the gut epithelium ➜ irritation or necrosis of the midgut; Reduced longevity of adult bees; Physiological stress (especially at excessively high or low temperatures). 🧬 Effects on the colony A reduction in nurse bee numbers (a potentially vulnerable group); Unusually high bee mortality after treatment; Possible queen loss in extreme overdose cases. It is particularly useful to examine oxalic-acid-related damage to bees and its possible relationship with Nosema spp.: 🦠 Relationship between oxalic acid damage and Nosema Nosema (Nosema apis or N. ceranae) comprises microsporidian parasites that infect the midgut of bees. This is where a possible connection arises 👇 🔗 Why they may be linked A shared target: Several studies show that oxalic acid can also influence bee physiology, including changes in the activity of cuticular proteases and possible changes in the gut microbiota. Such alterations may affect natural defences (innate immunity and the microbial barrier) when applications are improper or repeated. Chemical stress and dysbiosis can be associated with altered Nosema loads; Nosema damages gut epithelial cells. Oxalic acid can irritate or damage those same cells. → Therefore, bees already weakened by Nosema may be more vulnerable to oxalic acid effects, depending on exposure. A single Nosema-infected bee can carry more than 1,000,000 spores. Estimates of 30–90 spores per bee have been reported as sufficient to initiate infection in some contexts; this is not a universal threshold and depends on the species, bee age and experimental conditions. Increased gut permeability: If Nosema has already damaged the epithelium, oxalic acid exposure may: increase physiological stress; worsen tissue damage; further reduce bee longevity. Indirect effects on the colony: Nosema-infected bees may have a reduced ability to feed brood, thermoregulate and fly. Excessively harsh treatments (high OA concentrations or repeated applications) can amplify this functional decline. Caution: long-term effects on the microbiome and epithelial stress depend on dose, administration route and combinations with other products. Literature reports both beneficial effects and potential adverse effects, so skilled, targeted use is essential 🧭 Summary Oxalic acid is useful against Varroa but can damage the bee gut if misused; Nosema affects the same organ, so already infected bees may be more sensitive to treatment; The combination of Nosema and improper treatment may aggravate colony mortality and stress. Having considered possible epithelial damage and susceptibility to Nosema, we can examine the relationship between Nosema spp. and BQCV. This should not be treated as a proven chain leading inevitably to exponential viral growth. Nosema ↔ BQCV (Black Queen Cell Virus) association Queen cell infected with BQCV Scientific studies report co-occurrence and associations between Nosema (especially N. apis and N. ceranae) and BQCV. Some studies find higher BQCV loads or clinical signs in colonies with Nosema; BQCV is frequently reported in queen-rearing operations. The strength and consequences of the association vary. It is plausible that immune impairment or Nosema-related gut dysbiosis may facilitate BQCV replication or clinical expression in some conditions. BQCV can be transmitted by faecal–oral routes and through nurses feeding brood. Coinfection with Nosema can therefore be relevant to disease spread and expression in queen cells, without proving that Nosema always increases transmission. The role of Varroa destructor in viral dynamics Varroa is a major driver of increasing loads of viruses introduced during feeding, such as DWV. The direct role of Varroa as a BQCV vector is less clear: BQCV is a dicistrovirus often transmitted orally or by contact and associated with Nosema. However, high Varroa levels increase colony stress and general susceptibility to viral infections, altering the dynamics of many viral diseases. Reducing Varroa remains essential to limiting their overall impact. Official OA administration protocols must be followed to avoid injury to bee tissues. Potential latent effects of BQCV on queen longevity Recent studies suggest that queens with high viral loads (particularly multiple viruses such as DWV and BQCV) can show poorer reproductive performance and reduced longevity. High queen viral loads have been associated with weaker colonies and greater colony-loss risk, although this does not establish an effect attributable to BQCV alone. BQCV primarily affects queen larvae and pupae, but also occurs in asymptomatic adults and can contribute to the total viral burden. Overview of interacting mechanisms OA in specific research protocols → can reduce spores of Nosema; but misuse or overuse → dysbiosis or altered defences → potentially greater susceptibility to Nosema or other pathogens. Nosema → gut epithelial damage and altered defences → may favour BQCV and other viral problems through faecal–oral spread and reduced immune competence; these effects are context-dependent. High Varroa → increased stress and chemical interventions; altered viral dynamics, especially DWV; poorer overall conditions and possible indirect effects on BQCV/Nosema. Having considered how Nosema, sometimes favoured by inappropriate beekeeping practices, may interact with BQCV, we should consider practical strategies for optimising Varroa management when Nosema is suspected or diagnosed. General principles Monitor Varroa using suitable validated mite-counting tests; assess Nosema separately by counting spores in worker samples and, when needed, species-specific diagnosis before choosing measures. Avoid combining stressful chemical treatments, especially those that strongly affect the microbiome or proteolytic system. Interactions depend on products and exposure; a generally harmful synergy between amitraz and oxalic acid is not established by studies assessing them separately. Practical guidance Priority: control Varroa while limiting microbiome disruption Consider OA sublimation/vaporisation where authorised and correctly performed, particularly with little or no brood or during autumn/winter. It can be effective against Varroa. Research reporting reduced Nosema used OA in syrup, a different administration route; it does not show that sublimation treats Nosema or authorise such use. Use mechanical or management methods, such as brood removal and drone brood removal, as initial measures or as part of an integrated approach. If Nosema is suspected or confirmed Assess targeted management for Nosema with professional advice; natural alternatives and probiotics have promising but variable experimental results. Prefer measures supporting microbiome recovery and nutrition (quality protein supplements and multifloral pollen); OA-in-syrup research against Nosema must not be turned into an improvised treatment. Follow authorised uses and veterinary guidance, and do not combine products outside their permitted conditions. Avoid or limit products that worsen dysbiosis Medicines or acaricides that can affect microbiota, including OA under some conditions, require careful use. Their effects on intestinal resilience and Nosema susceptibility are dose- and context-dependent, not inevitable. Nutritional and microflora support Provide quality pollen or protein patties and avoid prolonged food shortages. Consider probiotics or functional feeds with relevant evidence against Nosema, recognising that efficacy depends on the product and conditions. Queen and reproductive management Source new queens from professional breeders With BQCV or high viral loads, consider requeening with a healthy source (checked eggs/larvae); review queen-rearing practices to limit spread, including replenishment of starter and finisher colonies and repeated acaricide treatments. Ultimately, the solution is not a fixed “recipe”, but knowledge and sound assessment of both dynamics and associations, with flexibility and continued adherence to operating protocols from veterinary institutes and research institutions. Published: 3 December 2025 Author: Davide Simeone
- Robbing: understanding what happens between honey bee colonies
Brian R. Johnson & James C. Nieh in Journal of Insect Behavior (2010) 23:459–471. DOI: 10.1007/s10905-010-9229-5. “Modeling the Adaptive Role of Negative Signaling in Honey Bee Intraspecific Competition”, Brian R. Johnson & James C. Nieh provides an illuminating model of robbing, rather than a complete explanation of every aspect. To understand it, we need to take a step back. Foragers that find a rich food source tell their nestmates through the waggle dance (Seeley 1989, 1995; Passino and Seeley 2006). This signal rapidly increases the number of new bees visiting the advertised food source. Positive feedback and the resulting recruitment decline when the source is exhausted (von Frisch 1967; Seeley 1995). Bees also have a STOP signal that causes waggle dancers to stop dancing (Kirchner 1993; Nieh 1993; Pastor and Seeley 2005; Lau and Nieh 2010; Nieh 2010). Its role was clarified by Nieh (2010). The stop signal provides negative feedback in certain contexts, including fights over resources. Bees that lose fights, provided they survive, produce many stop signals directed at other foragers working at the same site (Nieh 2010). Robbing is a clear example of this behavioural context. At colony level, bees must respond to the defensive strength of colonies they might attack. Individual bees have only their own experience of the foreign nest: whether they can steal honey without fighting, or have to fight. For example, if 10 bees obtain honey, with or without fighting, while 50 are driven off by guards and some robbers are killed, this may indicate that the target colony is strong enough to defend itself and the attack should cease. Robbing can cost the attacking colony dead bees, making it unprofitable. The STOP signal may therefore provide a selective benefit by shutting down waggle dances when costs are high and benefits low. Nectar work is divided between foragers, which collect it, and receiver bees inside the hive, which accept and process it. In the model, receivers do not retain food-source information, whereas foragers do. Receivers move randomly around the dance area until they encounter a forager needing to unload. They accept nectar and are unavailable for further unloading until they have dealt with that load. Essentially, a forager returning from a food source may produce four kinds of signal: waggle dance, tremble dance, shaking signal or stop signal, depending on its experiences. If an inactive forager encounters an available waggle dancer, it begins to follow. The model assumes one follower at a time and an average following time of 5 seconds, based on Judd (1995). If the inactive bee has previously visited the advertised site, it is reactivated and returns there (Seeley 1995). If the site is unfamiliar, it tries to locate it. The tremble dance instead recruits additional nectar-receiving bees (Seeley 1992; Seeley et al. 1996; Thenius et al. 2008). The shaking signal activates bees (Schneider et al. 1986; Nieh 1998; Biesmeijer 2003). The stop signal causes waggle dancers to stop dancing (Lau and Nieh 2010; Nieh 2010). In the model’s parameterisation, nectar receivers take 20 minutes to complete a trip to the storage combs and back (Seeley 1989). A receiver that cannot find a forager to unload within 120 minutes leaves that task, reducing the total receiver population by one. These are model settings, not fixed timings for every colony. Robbing In an apiary experiencing forage scarcity, some foragers will soon discover neighbouring colonies and begin assessing whether to attack them. The study used simulations to examine attack dynamics and the effect of stop signals in two settings: attacks on colonies capable of defending themselves but requiring different response times, and attacks on colonies with different defensive abilities. When a target colony eventually recruits enough guards to stop at least 95% of attackers, but does so at different speeds, two situations arise in the simulations. With rapid guard recruitment, most robbers encounter guards, lose fights and neither persist nor recruit others. As guard recruitment slows, the stop signal increasingly influences the number of attacks and their abandonment. A few bees can slip unnoticed into the nest when guards are too few relative to the entrance size and leave with honey. Back at their own hive, these successful bees perform waggle dances to recruit a few more nestmates to rob. Meanwhile, other bees that were repelled by guards during the same attack may also return. Their stop signals counter the recruitment dances of the few successful intruders, and the attacking colony abandons the raid. The scenario changes when the target colony’s defensive ability varies or is absent. The proportion of robbers that guards stop at the entrance is crucial. In the simulations, if the target blocks only a small proportion of intruders, returning robbers recruit increasing numbers and the attack grows. If it blocks an intermediate proportion, the attack continues but attacker numbers increase little or stabilise. When it repels most attackers—more than half in the scenario described—the attacking colony gives up; this is not a universal biological threshold. In every case, stop signals from defeated bees reduce the number of attackers, and thus the number the target must repel. Essentially, attacks are more likely to be called off when the attacking colony uses stop signals than when it does not. In the model, this makes colonies more conservative: they mainly attack weak neighbours and quickly abandon attacks on colonies that can defend themselves. For the defenders, strongly repelling all intruders, or at least a substantial proportion, encourages returning robbers to inhibit further recruitment. The numerical outcome depends on the model conditions. Robbing is neither an easy nor a cost-free option for bees: its costs can exceed its rewards, and misleading initial success can draw a colony into a poor choice. Later research also found an association between infection and risky robbing: robbers were more heavily infected with Nosema and shorter-lived. Calling them “kamikaze” is a metaphor; this does not prove that viral infection generally causes suicidal robbing. First, a bee that gets inside another hive returns laden with honey and may perform vigorous waggle dances to recruit others. Second, when those recruits reach the target, it is likely to have mobilised its defences, so fighting becomes necessary and bees may die (Butler and Free 1952; Winston 1987). A forager may work intensively for several weeks (Schmid-Hempel and Wolf 1988; Visscher and Dukas 1997). Losing one in a fight can therefore cost much more than the benefit of a small stolen load. Colonies should consequently be selective about attacking another hive and quick to stop when costs approach benefits. For defence, Downs and Ratnieks (2000) and Couvillon et al. (2008) showed that colonies vary in the number of guards stationed at the entrance, which can increase after an attack. Couvillon et al. (2008) found that the response can take several hours even in colonies strong enough to repel attackers. This highlights the importance of doing everything possible as a beekeeper to prevent attacks, because the defensive capacity immediately displayed by each colony influences intruders. It makes little sense, in evolutionary cost terms, to lose many bees before discovering that a raid was unprofitable; yet direct encounters provide that information. The paper discusses roughly 50 guards as sufficient for the small entrance considered, not as a universal requirement for every hive. Therefore, a useful measure is to narrow entrances promptly in late summer as forage ends, concentrating guards over a smaller opening while maintaining adequate ventilation. This should help prevent unfamiliar bees entering and repel intruders that return home with negative experience. If some intrusions occur, effective defence may reduce robbing by encouraging the attackers to stop. Bees can slip unnoticed in and out of foreign hives, increasing in number each day until an obvious outbreak. How often do we hear, “There was nothing yesterday, and today it erupted”? More accurately, it may already have been happening yesterday without being visible, perhaps for some time. Guard determination and selectivity are not constant, and queen pheromone signalling can influence colony behaviour. For small or weak colonies, prompt entrance restriction is one preventive measure. Synthetic queen pheromone products such as Bee Boost® have also been studied for colony responses, but the evidence does not establish guaranteed prevention of robbing or improved growth in every situation. Any use should follow the product instructions and cannot replace adequate colony strength, a healthy queen and appropriate management.
- Assessing queen fitness at season’s end: physiology, colony demographics and overwintering economics
Honey production with queens selected in ESA Regine’s breeding programme In modern beekeeping, variation in honey production within an apiary is an important practical indicator of queen fitness (reproductive and functional capacity). At the end of the production season, quantitative yield comparisons often identify colonies performing well below the apiary average. Keeping these lines into autumn can carry substantial husbandry and economic risk. Scientific studies link poor queen performance with physiological and cellular changes, sometimes irreversible, that environmental and human-related stress can accelerate. 1. Spermathecal ageing: thermal and chemical stress A queen’s reproductive potential depends on sperm numbers and, above all, sperm viability in the spermatheca. Cell-physiology research shows that this storage organ can be vulnerable to external stressors. Recent thermal stress may have impaired sperm viability. Timely checks of egg laying help prepare for adequate spring recovery. Thermal stress (heat shock) Extreme temperature fluctuations and high hive temperatures, including exposure above 38°C under some experimental conditions, can damage stored sperm. Research on Apis mellifera shows that brief heat shocks can reduce sperm viability, potentially contributing to drone-laying queens or patchy brood; the effect depends on exposure and queen resilience (McAfee et al., 2020). Chemical and treatment-related stress Miticide treatments needed to control Varroa destructor remain essential, but exposure can impose biochemical stress. Depending on the compound and conditions, synthetic or organic substances may persist in wax or act systemically, contributing to oxidative stress and effects on reproductive longevity, ovary mass or sperm survival (Rangel & Fisher, 2019; Chaimanee et al., 2016). The economic connection: reduced reproductive quality may accompany altered pheromone signalling, including 9-ODA (9-oxo-2-decenoic acid), and changes in colony homeostasis and foraging. Lost yield can have economic consequences, although sperm viability alone does not establish a direct mathematical prediction of honey income. 2. Colony demographics: risks after winter Postponing replacement of a poorly performing queen until spring can overlook important colony population dynamics. Overwintering success and spring development depend on the transition from late summer to autumn, when colonies rear winter bees, characterised by high levels of vitellogenin, a reserve glycolipophosphoprotein associated with haemolymph and fat-body physiology (Amdam et al., 2003). [Exhausted/below-average queen] │ ▼ [Reduced late-summer egg laying] │ ▼ [Shortage of high-vitellogenin winter bees] │ ▼ [Undersized cluster / increased winter mortality] │ ▼ [Slow spring 2027 development = lost early harvest] A physiologically exhausted queen may fail to maintain laying sufficient for an adequate winter population. Potential consequences for 2027 can be considered in light of colony life-history research (Seeley, 1978): Winter: greater risk of cluster thermal failure or opportunistic disease, such as nosema disease, associated with premature population ageing. Spring: delayed development may prevent the colony reaching peak population during main nectar flows, such as black locust and citrus, seriously affecting the season’s yield. 3. Genetic selection: official protocols To counter poor performance and improve apiary return on investment (ROI), introducing selected breeding material is a key strategy. ESA Regine describes its work as closely following official protocols of the Albo Allevatori Api Italiane under the supervision of CREA. The approach uses quantitative genetics to estimate breeding values, focusing on heritable traits of economic relevance: Selected trait Biological mechanism Business impact Harvest performance Optimising foraging and reserve-building capacity. Maximising honey yield per hive. Hygienic and Varroa-related traits (Hyg/VSH/SMR) Detection and removal of parasitised brood and related mechanisms affecting mite reproduction. Lower Varroa pressure and less need for emergency treatments. Gentleness Low reactivity during inspections. Less handling time and greater labour efficiency. Swarming Low swarming tendency. A stable workforce to support consistent harvest performance. Winter stores Optimising stores and limiting nutritional and thermal stress. Earlier spring development and lower winter feeding costs. Queens from selected, certified lines are intended to promote Under comparable environmental conditions, young queens selected using official protocols are important for production and beekeeping economics more consistent high performance, less undesirable variation within the apiary and greater overall farm resilience. Planning end-of-season orders As day length shortens and drone numbers decline around drone congregation areas (DCAs), natural mating opportunities decrease. Consequently, availability of tested, fertile queens can fall sharply in the final weeks. Planning queen renewal at this biological stage supports overwintering and productive potential for 2027, alongside appropriate nutrition and health management. 👉 Plan replacement of below-average lines. Check current availability and place your order through our official website: www.esaregine.com References Amdam, G. V., et al. (2003). Social exploitation of vitellogenin.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 100(4), 1799–1802. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.0333979100. Chaimanee, V., et al. (2016). Sperm viability and gene expression in honey bee queens (Apis mellifera) following exposure to the neonicotinoid insecticide imidacloprid and the organophosphate acaricide coumaphos.Journal of Insect Physiology, 89, 1–8. DOI: 10.1016/j.jinsphys.2016.03.004. McAfee, A., et al. (2020). Vulnerability of honey bee queens to heat-induced loss of fertility.Nature Sustainability. DOI: 10.1038/s41893-020-0493-x. Pettis, J. S., et al. (2016). Colony Failure Linked to Low Sperm Viability in Honey Bee (Apis mellifera) Queens and an Exploration of Potential Causative Factors.PLOS ONE, 11(2), e0147220. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0147220. Rangel, J., & Fisher, A. (2019). Factors affecting the reproductive health of honey bee (Apis mellifera) drones—a review.Apidologie, 50, 759–778. DOI: 10.1007/s13592-019-00684-x. Seeley, T. D. (1978). Life history strategy of the honey bee, Apis mellifera.Oecologia, 32(1), 109–118. DOI: 10.1007/BF00344695.
- Amitraz, queen spermathecae and microbiota: interpreting the 2026 data
Why queen sperm viability matters ESA Regine equipment for instrumental insemination The queen stores sperm acquired during mating in her spermatheca and uses it when laying eggs. The percentage of viable sperm is an important biological parameter, but on its own it is not a sufficient indicator of the queen’s future lifespan or colony productivity. Sperm quantity, environmental conditions, disease and worker behaviour also contribute to reproductive outcomes. In 2026, a US research group examined the consequences of management-related exposure to amitraz and oxytetracycline on several parameters in adult queens and brood. The work’s main contribution is not a blanket condemnation of treatments, but the opportunity to distinguish measured effects on reproductive functions and microbiota. Three experiments in an apiary setting Metz and colleagues conducted three experiments at research facilities in North Carolina between 2022 and 2025. Groups exposed to products containing oxytetracycline or amitraz were compared with concurrent controls according to the research protocol. Queens were examined for morphological, sperm and microbiological characteristics; some observations concerned egg laying and brood survival. The researchers analysed sperm viability using stains that distinguish live and dead cells, and studied bacterial communities through sequencing. Not every individual yielded usable samples for every analysis: after filtering, 53 queen microbiological samples were analysed. This detail is a reminder that the findings concern defined experimental groups, not a survey of every possible condition of product use. Amitraz: the finding on stored sperm Collecting semen from an Apis mellifera ligustica drone: detail of endophallus eversion and semen In the 2023 comparison, median sperm viability was 87.3% in control queens and 65.4% in queens exposed to amitraz. The authors report a statistically significant difference for this indicator. This is a laboratory measurement of sperm viability in sampled queens, not the percentage of fertilised eggs or colony survival. The same work found no significant difference in the number of eggs laid during the trial and no general effect on the brood-survival parameters examined. It is therefore incorrect to claim that exposure automatically caused sterility or egg-laying failure. Oxytetracycline and gut microbiota Queens from the oxytetracycline-exposed group showed no significant reduction in sperm viability compared with controls from the corresponding year. The authors instead observed a modest but statistically significant difference in gut bacterial community composition, measured as diversity between samples. There was no detected reduction in diversity within individual communities, nor a simple relationship between microbiota changes and egg laying. This is an important example: “altered microbiota” does not automatically mean “sick queen”. Demonstrating a health effect requires functional links and measurements over appropriate periods. The colony’s protective effect Queen at ESA Regine’s breeding operation. Fertility, egg laying and sperm viability are distinct indicators that require careful assessment. The queen is fed and cared for by workers and carries out most of her activity near the brood. This can change the routes and intensity of exposure to substances compared with an individual treated directly in a laboratory. The authors propose that such social buffering helps explain some differences between laboratory and apiary experiments. It does not guarantee an absence of risk. Rather, it shows why results obtained through direct exposure should not automatically be transferred to an entire colony, or vice versa. Dose, formulation, duration, climate, management and colony condition all change the picture. Interpreting the relationship between health treatments and queen quality Varroa and associated viruses pose real risks to colonies. Potential adverse effects of medicines cannot be discussed while ignoring the harm caused by failing to manage the parasite. Choices must be guided by authorised product instructions, veterinary prescriptions and actual hive conditions. The research suggests maintaining attention to reproductive physiology even when treatment efficacy against Varroa is the immediate goal. It does not, however, provide a basis for arbitrarily stopping treatments or legitimise unauthorised antibiotic or acaricide use. Assessment within a breeding programme ESA Regine considers queen quality as a combination of traits: genetic origin, mating control where applicable, appropriate breeding management and progeny assessment. Sperm-related indicators are relevant to this approach, but do not replace observation of daughter-colony performance. The cited research is independent of ESA Regine; we neither attribute these trials to the company nor claim that they certify the effectiveness of our practices. Rather, the work helps maintain a technical discussion grounded in evidence and its limitations. Sample sizes and experimental units In both 2022 and 2023, the authors established an apiary of 40 colonies for each year, divided into twenty receiving the treatment under study and twenty controls. The 2022 comparison concerned oxytetracycline; the 2023 comparison concerned amitraz. Queens came from stock of predominantly Italian ancestry, but did not represent a certified, homogeneous Apis mellifera ligustica population. The subsequent 2025 trial on egg laying and brood development comprised eighteen colonies randomly assigned to three groups of six, plus two excluded from assessment. Numbers must therefore be interpreted for each experiment and outcome separately. The colony is the main unit of treatment assignment. Bees, sperm cells and microbial sequences measured within each queen are subsamples, not biological replicates of the apiary intervention. Moreover, hives in the first two years were arranged in rows: treatment allocation limited drifting, but creates possible location effects to consider. The three years and different endpoints make the study more informative than a trial on a few families, without constituting three perfectly interchangeable replicates. Effect size and negative results The 2023 comparison recorded median sperm viability of 87.3% in controls and 65.4% in the amitraz-exposed group, with dispersion expressed as median absolute deviations of 8.9 and 7.5 percentage points, respectively. The difference between medians is 21.9 percentage points; the authors’ test gives p = 0.01. In 2022, for oxytetracycline, the medians were 74.6% and 75.2%, with no statistically significant difference (p = 0.23). It is correct to say that amitraz lowered viability in that trial; inferring sterility, remaining egg-laying lifespan or increased queen replacement requires other measurements. The egg-laying trial found no statistically significant effects on the number of worker eggs (p = 0.29) or drone eggs (p = 0.62). Increased survival of drones to pupation was reported in the oxytetracycline group, but only two colonies in that group successfully produced the drone eggs assessed: this limitation weakens the inference. It is incorrect to select only the value that appears favourable or unfavourable while ignoring actual sample sizes, null results and the extent of uncertainty. Microbiota: what the sequences measure Sequencing targeted the V4 region of the bacterial 16S rRNA gene: a technique for describing microbiota taxonomic composition, not a direct measurement of metabolism or reproductive health. After filtering and checks, 53 usable samples remained. Alpha diversity, describing variety within a single sample, did not differ significantly between groups. Beta diversity, comparing community composition, showed a modest change with oxytetracycline (p = 0.032), but not amitraz (p = 0.79). The reported analysis found no consistently differentiated taxa in within-year comparisons. The researchers primarily assessed relative abundances: a percentage increase in one microbial group can also result from a decrease in another, without any increase in absolute cell numbers. Demonstrating clinically relevant dysbiosis would require functional measurements, absolute loads and independent correlations with health outcomes. This is essential both to avoid treating the absence of a significant taxonomic change as proof of complete harmlessness and, conversely, to avoid calling every statistical difference in composition a disease. Practical implications and limits to transferability The work is relevant to professional breeding because it describes a possible vulnerability of the queen’s sperm reserve to a health-management intervention. It does not, however, allow an alternative treatment schedule or a universal rule for queen replacement timing to be derived. Comparing the benefits of Varroa control with adverse risks must consider the authorised formulation, label compliance, parasite pressure and the whole season. Petit and Jack’s 2026 review documents highly heterogeneous sublethal effects across active substances, biological levels and test conditions. Turning the experimental finding into a breeding recommendation would require replication across several regions and genetic lines, assessment of the dose actually reaching the queen, and longitudinal measurements of egg laying, brood fertility, replacement probability and colony productivity. Queens in the study were dissected for analysis, so those same individuals were not followed through to the end of their reproductive lives. This is a methodological limitation, not a flaw to conceal: a rigorous article must make it clear to readers. Limitations and the need for further studies The trials took place in a single geographical setting, with queens from different groups and years. Some brood indicators showed high variability and small sample sizes. Statistical differences observed in a single parameter need replication and integration with long-term outcomes. It would be useful to follow queens over several seasons, assessing natural supersedure, egg-laying quality, sperm viability over time and differences between families in different environments. These measurements would allow a physiological finding to be translated into a more robust breeding assessment. Frequently asked questions Does amitraz make all queens sterile? No. The study found lower median sperm viability in the exposed group, but no significant halt in egg laying under the observed conditions. Does this study suggest not treating Varroa? No. Health management remains necessary and must follow veterinary guidance and authorised medicine instructions. The data call for assessment of benefits and risks, not abandonment of parasite control. Scientific sources Metz B.N., Gallagher P., Profet P., Raymann K., Tarpy D.R. (2026). Impact of Two Common Beekeeper-Applied Chemicals on Honey Bee Queen Fecundity and Gut Microbial Communities. Microbial Ecology 89, 108. DOI: 10.1007/s00248-026-02755-w. Petit L., Jack C.J. (2026). Sublethal Effects and Associated Risks of Acaricides Used Against Varroa destructor in Honey Bee (Apis mellifera) Colonies. Insects 17(5), 517. DOI: 10.3390/insects17050517. Claire – ESA Regine editorial team




















